• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Two texts that portray food to lack comfort and nourishment are Text 21 The extract Act V Scene II and Act V Scene III, from Shakespeares tragedy from 1590 Titus Andronicus, and text 22 An extract from the beginning of The Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift published in 1729

Extracts from this document...


Food is not always shown to be a source of nourishment and comfort. Compare two texts from the anthology that demonstrates this. Two texts that portray food to lack comfort and nourishment are Text 21 ? The extract ?Act V Scene II and Act V Scene III?, from one of William Shakespeare?s earliest tragedy?s from 1590 ?Titus Andronicus?, and text 22 ? An extract from the beginning of ?The Modest Proposal? by Jonathan Swift published in 1729. The purpose of Text 21 is to entertain the reader. It is mainly aimed at adults and fans William Shakespeare. Similarly, text 22 is also meant to entertain the reader. However, even though text 22 could be considered to have an entertainment factor, text 22 is a satirical essay which is argumentative and a rhetorical social commentary, on a solution to the problem of hunger in Ireland in the 18th century. It is mainly aimed at Government and politicians as well as both the rich public of the 18th century. Text 21 is structured in chronological order. It starts with the scene, where Titus reveals the characters Murder and Rape to be Chiron and Demetrius respectively. ...read more.


Again the detailed methodical step by step guide on how to achieve this is akin to how Titus in text 21 tells the villains how he is going to kill them. Again this vivid description is to help the audience and readers imagine he gruesome acts that are about to be performed. This only enhances the fact that the food might not be a source of comfort or nourishment. In text 21, during Act V Scene III when Titus is encouraging them to eat ?Will?t please you eat?? is creating dramatic irony, as the audience knows what the pasties are made of but, the characters don?t. The audience will feel nauseated watching the actors eat pies which have human flesh and bones. This only enhances the fact that food is not always a source of nourishment. Text 21 uses archaic language. This is associated with the date of its productions and reception. Also his intended audience was of the 16th century. Text 22 also uses archaic language but is a bit more modern than text 21. Text 1 has words such as ?coffin?, which meant pastry in the old days but now it is like a foreshadowing of their deaths. ...read more.


Also, phrases like ?I am assured by our merchants? and ?assured by a very knowing American? suggests that he has done his research. All of this adds to the very sarcastic tone of the whole text. Even though, the readers will be able to recognise that the whole text is meant as a satirical essay, the idea will still repulse people and show them that food can not always be nourishing. However, the mention of actually baking people and serving them to guests is genuine. This shows that the ingredients in foods do not always provide nourishment or comfort. In conclusion, text 21 shows food is not always a source of comfort or nourishment as pasties with human flesh is served to guest at a dinner party. Similarly, in text 22 children is compared to cattle, as in using the children as a source of food. Even though this is similar to the concept in text 21, the author in text 22 is being sarcastic and mocking the government about the poverty in Ireland, unlike in text 21, where human meat was served at a meal. So, text 22 shows that some foods are not always a source of comfort or nourishing. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks essays

  1. Act 3 scene 3 is a pivotal scene in the play Othello. How does ...

    "Set on thy wife to observe" Othello's trust for Desdemona totally vanishes throughout Act 3 scene 3, and through the manipulation of Iago. The view that he had that he had before of Desdemona, "Oh my sweet" is now a "Lewd Minx".

  2. Creative writing and commentary. It was the year 2015 and Earth was exploring ...

    getting ready to go out now" Rachel came back out of her room with her bag which had her bits in for the beach "I'm ready, let's go" On the way out of the hotel they had to walk past the shop that Ramani worked in, Rachel tried her hardest

  1. The Outsider - Shakespeare's Othello

    Throughout the novel there is continuous repetition of the words "ought to" and "supposed to be" when referring to how "normal" or accepted people should act or be in society. This shows how Grenouille is seen as an outsider through the imposing views of society at the time in which the novel is set.

  2. Persuasive Text

    Spread the faith. Spread the hope. Spread the happiness. Together united, we can do something to be proud of, and we will receive the same aid when we lose our own path. Together united we can share our material happiness to show that a little goes a longer way than we could dream of.

  1. Analysis of 3 texts on Childhood

    minutes a day eating; by 1995 it was down to fifty-two minutes?, ?In the mid-seventies one in three?Now it is down to nine?). However, the writer also makes an attempt to include readers, as seen in the use of a rhetorical question (?So what are they doing with the extra time together??)

  2. Analysis of 3 texts on Family

    Contractions such as ?what?s, ?I?ve? and ?they?ve? have been used to speed up speech as well. Prosodic features are also present in Louise?s speech as seen in the word stress of ?diverse? and ?bizarre? to emphasise a certain point. In contrast, B as a literary text is presented through the

  1. Text Commentary - Text 25 (Food Glorious Food Anthology)

    The style of the text is authoritative, with declaratives used to highlight the views and to encourage people to buy. It is also at times more casual, especially during the story, ?He was splashing a trifle? is slightly more colloquial language and provides a more chatty tone, which is maintained

  2. Text Commentary - Text 17 (Food Glorious Food Anthology)

    ?close up of Nigella chopping the ingredients?) allowing readers of the transcript to understand both the visuals presented to the camera and the speech used. The text ends with details of Nigella eating the meal she has prepared, to highlight it?s ?tastiness?, the audience should feel more confident in the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work