• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Was it right to shoot Candy’s dog?

Extracts from this document...


Was It Right To Shoot Candy's Dog? It is in the second chapter that it is first brought up about Candy's dog being shot. It is Carson that initiates the argument. His first reason for killing Candy's dog was that it smelt saying "it stinks like hell" and "I can smell that dog a mile away." He then backed this up by saying "got no teeth, damn near blind, can't eat." Although Carlson says there are other things in favour of Candy's dog being killed you get the impression that his main reason was that the dog smelt and he wanted it out of the way. One of the ways this is given away is that there is repetition of Carlson complaining about the smell of the dog and the exaggeration of saying "I can smell him for two or three days." This was very selfish of him but did recognise that Candy would miss his dog so Carlson suggested to Slim that he "give him one of those pups to raise up" because Slims dog had just had some pups and he didn't want all of them. ...read more.


He tries to get them off the subject by telling them about their past times which is also used as an argument against killing his dog. He says, "I had him so long...since he was a pup." He is telling them how much he loves his dog and what they have been through together so they will have pity on the dog. This is when Carlson really starts to put pressure on Candy to let them kill his dog, coming up will many reasons why they should do it. Most of these arguments are to make Candy feel bad for keeping the dog alive. He says "this ol' dog jus suffers hisself," "he don't have no fun" and "you ain't bein' king to him keepin' him alive." He tries to guilt him into it. Candy tries to resist by saying, "no, I couldn't do that. I had him too long." It isn't very forceful because he said it softly because they are all against him and are wearing him down. ...read more.


They eventually wore him down because he needed someone to support him because he wasn't strong enough on his own. By convincing Candy to let them kill his dog, Carlson and the other men made Candy like them; having no companion so he is lonely, isolated. In my opinion, I think it was right for his dog to be killed but Candy should have done it himself. I think it was right for the dog because it was suffering due to its rheumatism. It was also nearly blind, it had no teeth so it couldn't eat so there was nothing left for him. Keeping it alive any longer would have been cruel and if Candy had kept it alive because he wanted a companion that would have been selfish because of what the dog would have to go through. They put it out of its misery before it got too bad and the dog would have resented Candy for keeping it alive. Jade McGreevy 11JB ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level John Steinbeck section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level John Steinbeck essays

  1. Of Mice and Men - Full Summary and Analysis

    Lennie grabs Curley's hand and crushes it. He does not let go until George tells him to. Slim tells Curley that he should claim that he got his hand caught in a machine. Nobody will tell what happened unless Curley does. Analysis: This chapter elucidates the story about George and Lennie's escape from their previous workplace that George hints at in the first chapter.

  2. Of Mice and Men: Alternative ending for the final chapter.

    Back inside the office Slim noticed that the time had moved on quite considerably since he had last looked, it was now a quarter past six and the sun was beginning to poke it's proverbial yellow head over the horizon.

  1. The Killing of Candy’s Old Dog For Foreshadowed Lennie’s death. Describe the two killings ...

    Lennie killed Curley's wife accidentally. This happened as she asked him to touch her hair and even put his hands on to it. As Lennie likes to feel soft things he started to stroke her hair harder. Curley's wife started to get angry as the hair was getting messy and

  2. of mice and men

    Lennie isn't interested, though. He asks George how long until they get their place with the rabbits. George tells Lennie again about an idyllic future home-ten acres with orchards, salmon in the river, their own animals to eat-total self-sufficiency. They will have a house with a stove and room for friends, and plenty of space for Lennie's rabbits.

  1. Candy's Dog.

    Carlson is selfish and heartless Carlson is coarse and insensitive. He continually illustrates his lack of concern for or understanding of other people's feelings. Carlson is the one pushing for the killing of Candy's dog. He does so not for the dog's sake, or Candy's, but because the dog's smell and looks offend his own senses.

  2. Of Mice and men - Overall Plot.

    Even when he hears the gunshots he remains quiet. Crooks, the Negro stable buck who lives in a room in the barn, reminds Slim that he has to put tar on a mule's foot, so Slim leaves for the barn.

  1. Loneliness in Of Mice and Men

    'I'd make a will an'leave my share to you guys in case I kick off, 'cause I ain't got no relatives or nothing.' This shows that he has been very lonely for a very long time. He is an old man and must have had younger relatives who may have deserted him, to get on with his own life.

  2. George's first diary

    Met Slim too. Hell of a nice guy, he is. Seems well respected too. Real nice. I do like having nice workmates but it is worrying, knowing that there's an evil bastard lurking 'round too! I've a bad feeling 'bout Curley, its real bad.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work