• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What Comparisons and/or Contrasts can be made between the two short stories, ''Horse Sense'' and ''The Three Sisters''?

Extracts from this document...


What Comparisons and/or Contrasts can be made between the two short stories, ''Horse Sense'' and ''The Three Sisters''? Although ''Horse Sense'' written by Deborah Moggach, and ''The Three Sisters'' written by Jane Austen are both short stories, many comparisons and differences can be seen, one being that the stories were written at different times. ''The Three Sisters'' was written in the late nineteenth century and ''Horse Sense'' was written in the late twentieth century. Time has an immense influence on both stories. The reason for some of the similarities or differences is because of the period in which the stories were written. It can be seen that time is passing in both stories. In ''Horse Sense'' time has passed and this is shown when Eric's neck is ''getting browner'' because the summer is getting even hotter. Time is passing when each of the letters are being written. The day on which the letter is written is shown above the letter therefore, the reader can see how many days have passed between the time when the previous letter was written and the one that is being read. Mary is presented to be very self-centred by Jane Austen. In the first letter from Mary, ''I'' is used repeatedly throughout the letter showing how she is constantly talking about her life to Fanny. Mary does not ask any questions about how Fanny is in her letters. In contrast the narrator in ''Horse Sense'' is not really self-centred, but she is just very insecure and blames herself for everything. The topic of marriage seems to be a natural concept for the characters in both ''The Three Sisters'' and ''Horse Sense'' to discuss. In ''The Three Sisters'' marriage was very important to a girl and her mother. Marriage was the goal of a young lady's life and being provided for. Mary was the ''the happiest creature in the world'' because she had received an offer of marriage from Mr Watts. ...read more.


Ranjit would not really want to handle the narrator very much as he was not attracted to her. The narrator however would not mind if Ranjit conducted some physical touching. Deborah Moggach mentions how the narrator reads Woman's Own and realises that Ranjit only handles her ''infrequently.'' When you read this, the narrator sounds disappointed that her husband does not want to go near her after being married for such a short amount of time. I expect the narrator was hoping once they were married, their relationship would be full of happiness but she has been disappointed and she has no choice but to accept this. She could get a divorce but her family would not forgive her. In the Asian culture, divorce is not a very good option. When two people are married in the Asian culture, everyone expects them to live together for the rest of their lives. If something occurs and they separate many questions are asked by the family. Also when the narrator 'stroke the neck'' of the horse and it ''blew into her hair'' this conveys how she would like Ranjit to contact her in this way but he does not so she receives this comfort from the horse instead. In ''The Three Sisters'' physical touching should only occur after the marriage. It is seen as inappropriate for males to touch females a lot before the marriage at the time, which Jane Austen was writing. In ''The Three Sisters'' once the couples are married, they are supposed to have a close relationship. They should develop a close relationship because everyone expects the couple to have children so there will be an heir. In ''Horse Sense'' I expect Ranjit's family and the narrator's family would like or expect them to have children. In Asian families, having many children is part of the culture, although in modern times, the number of children has decreased. ...read more.


Deborah Moggach uses fool twice i.e. repetition to emphasise that the narrator really does feel a fool and has no self-confidence. She tells us the advantages and disadvantages of her marriage with Ranjit, as she is truthful we tend to believe her. Mary only gives us her point of view about Mr Watts and she is rather foolish and she does not even realise how foolish she really is. Therefore we tend to sympathise more with the narrator in ''Horse Sense'' rather than with Mary in ''The Three Sisters'' due to the way the writers have portrayed the characters. Deborah Moggach has written a more satisfactory conclusion to ''Horse Sense'' because we find out what has happened to her. The narrator goes back to live in London with her sister, where she came from, with her family. She has someone to talk to and she could find herself a job in London and may find some other man to spend the rest of her life with. ''Her head is clear'' and she is relieved because she realises the marriage was not a failure because of her. During the story she was always feeling lonely and depressed. There was not really any humour during the story. Deborah Moggach writes how the narrator's sister would go round the bend just living around cows and the narrator uses humour and says ''it did.'' The narrator nearly thought she was going crazy and needed help but then realised she was not going mad and she could see the funny side of what had happened in her life while being married. In contrast, Jane Austen has not given a satisfactory conclusion. We assume Mary and Mr Watts are going to marry each other because Mr Watts was going to London to ''hasten the preparations for the wedding.'' However, Mary had been changing her mind about the wedding throughout the story, so we will only know if they definitely get married once the day has occurred. Rubarani Balasothy 10A ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Jane Austen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Jane Austen essays

  1. Compare and Contrast 'Teresa's Wedding' by William Trevor and 'The Three Sisters' by Jan ...

    'Teresa's Wedding' and 'The Three Sisters' show similarities of irony occurring through the climax. 'The Three Sisters' shares mixtures of simple, compound, complex and varied sentence structures such as "He said he should come again tomorrow and take my final answer, so I believe I must have him while I can."

  2. What Does the Concept of Dignity mean to Stevens?

    dirtying his shoes because no self-respecting butler would allow that to happen and says, "My footwear is not such as to permit me easily to walk around the perimeter." Stevens gullibly believes that others really care about how he looks and acts, and he must therefore strive to create a good impression and remain dignified.

  1. 'Blackout' is a short story by Roger Mais. It is set in Jamaica and ...

    It is a third person narrative. During the story, we actually empathize with the man. Because of his behavior, there is a certain respect built for him and a sense of antagonism grows for the woman. The main themes of this story are, 'racism' and 'intimacy'.

  2. How does Jane Austen present the themes of love and marriage in the novel ...

    Whatever love the two of them have would be troubled with such difficulties that there is virtually no possibility of success. Emma has no hope that Mr Knightly could be in love with her, and even if it was the case, her father's need for constant attention would prevent marriage.

  1. Compare and contrast the short stories "Mr. Loveday's Little outing" by Evelyn Waugh, and ...

    The second story, "Mr. Loveday's Little outing" opens in a rather different manner, the first phrase "You will not find your father greatly changed,' remarked Lady Moping, as the car turned into the gates of the County Asylum.", introduces us to, yet another rather genteel woman, Lady Moping, who is engaged in conversation with her daughter, Angela.

  2. Argue that the theory of common sense structures provides an important and hitherto unappreciated ...

    latter not merely because it is unscientific but also (with less apparent justification) because it is not itself capable of serving as the object of a scientific treatment. The task of phenomenology, now, Husserl sees as being that of harmonizing the naive and the exact (of understanding the relation between

  1. How and in What Ways does Jane Austen Show the Importance of Money in ...

    John Dashwood was furious that her husband could ever contemplate such a thing. "She begged him to think again on the subject. How could he answer it to himself to rob his child, and his only child too" He pointed out to his selfish wife that they too were

  2. 'Describe the ways in which Wilkie Collins builds up a sense of mystery and ...

    Furthermore they are seen as being untrustworthy; "bad character", "wicked". There is a great sense of mystery surrounding their visit to the cottage, as they give no real reason for being there and Jerry's "leering eyes" give the reader the impression that they have bad intentions.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work