• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Whether the spirit of greatness or woman reigns most in her, I know not, but it shows a fearful madness. I owe her much of pity" (I.i. 492)How far do you agree with Cariola's lines as a summary of the Duchess?

Extracts from this document...


"Whether the spirit of greatness or woman reigns most in her, I know not, but it shows a fearful madness. I owe her much of pity" (I.i. 492) How far do you agree with Cariola's lines as a summary of the Duchess? You should base your answer on an examination of two or more appropriate sequences of your choice. The Duchess certainly has the spirit of greatness in her, as she shows in her death scene, where her nobility and courage are proved. However, she is also subject to the 'spirit of woman', shown in the scene where she woos Antonio, as it is essentially this which leads to her downfall and can be seen as her hermatia, her fatal mistake which was part of the typical structure of a revenge tragedy. It is her longing for a loving relationship regardless of her public responsibilities, a completely new philosophy in the Jacobean time, and her blindness to the impossibility of what she is trying to achieve (the separation of her private and public bodies), which lead to her death. Cariola's lines are a fair assessment of the Duchess, who has both the spirit of greatness and woman in her, although I think that by the end of the play her spirit of greatness certainly reigns most in her. ...read more.


reasoning as men, (a contrast can be drawn between the Duchess, a female tragic hero, who spends little time in reflection of her actions, and male tragic heroes of the Sixteenth Century such as Hamlet and Macbeth who think deeply about themselves and constantly rationalise and reason about their actions). Another of the Duchess' perhaps 'female' flaws, is her vulnerability to the misjudgement of people, such as her dismissal of her brothers' potential cruelty and her mislead trust for Bosola in Act III Scene II, where she na�vely reveals that Antonio is her husband. Bosola completely over-flatters Antonio to the Duchess, 'He was an excellent courtier', 'His breast was filled with perfection', yet she is deceived by his false charm and exposes Antonio, 'This good one you speak of is my husband'. This can also be interpreted as the Duchess' hermatia, rather than her earlier decision to marry a man of unworthy parentage; it is a fatal mistake (although more in the short term) and more directly leads to her death. It is an error seemingly showing the spirit of woman reigning most in her, and it seems it is not until after these two enormous misjudgements that her spirit of greatness actually shines through. ...read more.


The difference between the Duchess and almost all the other characters can be seen in Webster's use of animal imagery. While characters like Julia and the Cardinal are likened to hawks and toads, the 'flatter'ing sychophants' to insects and Ferdinand to a spider with a 'foul black cobweb', the Duchess is, throughout the play, described as small birds, specifically a lark, nightingale, and robin redbreast, 'Didst thou ever see a lark in a cage'. This affiliates the Duchess with the more beautiful and good side of nature rather than the other characters. This again emphasises the idea of the Duchess' as a great and noble character, who is trapped among these nasty corrupt characters. The Duchess does have the spirit of woman in her, essentially shown by her longing for safety and love and her misjudged fatal mistakes in the first half of the play, which I think are due to her feminine weaknesses and underestimations of the inhumane cruelty of her brothers, and society. However, following her hermatia, she seems to become wiser, and perhaps realises the impossibility of her desire to have a separate, private family unit away from her public body as the sovereign of Malfi. Her nobility in death fully exposes her 'spirit of greatness' and proves that it reigns most in her. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level John Webster section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level John Webster essays

  1. Explore the ways in which Webster introduces his characters and themes in the play ...

    They are the "flatt'ring panders" that Bosola refers to. Equally, Bosola exposes himself as a less than perfect character.

  2. How effective is "The Duchess of Malfi" as a Jacobean Revenge Tragedy?

    In a ceremony in Loretto, the Cardinal resigns from his role as Cardinal and, although he continues to be referred to as the cardinal, he effectively becomes secular again. In "The Duchess of Malfi" Webster draws the idea of religion and politics closely together.

  1. In The Duchess of Malfi, Act II Scene I, Bosola says to the Old ...

    He likes to stay in the background and uses the Church to hide behind, something which he accuses the Duchess of doing: 'Doth she hide behind religion?' The Cardinal speaks of Julia in terms of sickness; he is 'sick of her' and wants rid of her.

  2. How and where does the Duchess distinguish herself as a very remarkable woman in ...

    Similarly, notice how it is the Duchess, not Antonio, who later makes the plans for their escape. The Duchess is a very human figure who the audience can relate to much more easily than to the insecure megalomaniac Ferdinand or the cowardly Cardinal who carefully plots people's death.

  1. Attitudes to women in "The White Devil" in Acts I and II

    The audience then sympathises even more with her when she is so greatly and easily insulted by her husband, who exclaims "O your breath!" and further rejects her, saying "I'll never lie with thee". Their relationship clearly portrays Brachiano as a dominant man over submissive husband, something which was thought

  2. What impression does Webster create of courtly life in Malfi? How would a contemporary ...

    The idea of entrapment and confinement is represented throughout the play and within the court. The patriarchal oppression confines and cocoons her despite her defiance. By hiring Bosola to spy on the Duchess, the Cardinal and Ferdinand set a trap to ensnare the Duchess as men set traps to capture wild creatures in order to kill them.

  1. By close consideration of two extracts of your choice, assess the importance of the ...

    pretence that she "may... depart [her] country with more honour, and [her] flight Will seem a princely progress, retaining [Her] usual train about [her]" (ll.308-311). In fact, we know that, on arriving in Loretto, where the Cardinal, by design, awaits her, she is shamefully stripped of her princedom, as is Antonio of his lands (III.iv.5ff esp.

  2. Consider the relative merits of each of these judgements of Act 5: The Duchess ...

    Thus, the spectators will recognise a visual parallel with the death of the Duchess, who in contrast, dies with an elaborate speech. She wishes to have her 'throat cut with diamonds.' On the other hand, the characterisation of Ferdinand is so extreme that it we can catagorise him as 'hateful' but not a mere 'leftover.'

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work