• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why was the battle of the Somme regarded as such a military tradgedy?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Introduction The battle of the Somme was a battle that took place in Eastern France and close to the border of Belgium. The battle of the Somme got its name because it was fought along the valley of the River Somme. The battle of the Somme began on the 1st of July 1916; the aim of the battle was to try and break the stalemate and to help relieve some of the pressure on the French at Verdun. The war was between the allies and Germany. The battle was a British offensive (attack) on the Germans. In this essay I am going to look at cases of bad leadership, Human suffering and Failure in the battle of the Somme to then try and discover 'Why the battle of the Somme was regarded as such a military Tragedy.' Poor Planning & Pressure One major reason for the tragic outcome of the battle of the Somme was due to poor planning and pressure. The preparations for the battle of the Somme were rushed because the French urged the British to start their offensive on Germany earlier than planned to help lift the siege on Verdun and relieve the pressure on the French army at Verdun. The French had lost an enormous amount of men at Verdun and said that they were prepared to "fight to the last man," this is why the French generals kept pressuring the British leaders. This shows evidence of a tragedy because so many men were killed needlessly due to poor planning. The casualties and death total would have been far less if the French didn't rush the British into the battle. Failure of the British Artillery Bombardment The battle of the Somme began with constant artillery bombardment of the German trenches for five days. The aim of this bombardment was to break down the German trenches also to break down the barbed wire protecting the German trenches. ...read more.

Middle

Their own battalion shot many of their men for 'cowardice.' The troops had lost belief in the generals leading them to victory in the war. There was a propaganda film made to try and persuade people into backing the war, people walked out of the film because they knew men that were dying, one woman screamed 'they're dying.' The film damaged the morale on the British mainland showing what was happening in the war. In the First World War men from the same village served in the same battalion. If the battalion were wiped out then there would be no men in many villages, friends and brothers fought side by side and so died side by side. Conditions in the Trenches The conditions in the trenches were horrendous. The worst problems for the troops were the rain and the cold. The artillery bombardment destroyed the drains of the battlefields; this led to the battlefields getting clogged up with mud, which many soldiers drowned in. If you had a small wound it was almost a certainty that you would get blood poisoning, gangrene and leading to death. There were hundreds of human corpses in the trenches, which also made disease a certainty. The rats in the trenches grew fat from all the human flesh. There was constant noise, and a lack of medical supplies with a shortage of food. The dead bodies caused a dreadful smell in the trenches especially in the summer Corporal Joe Hayles said; "There was a terrible smell. It was awful it nearly poisoned you . . . Wicked it was! Bodies all over the place. I'll never forget it. I was only eighteen . . ." The men had to stand in puddles of water in the trenches for hours on the front line, which led to trench foot by the end of the war 75,000 men suffered from trench foot. ...read more.

Conclusion

The tanks were supposed to protect men from machine guns but failed to do this because they broke down, men were also not protected by their own generals because they were naive. The generals didn't try and adapt to the conditions and help their soldiers out of the terrible conditions. Over the battle of the Somme only 6 miles were gained with a high loss of life, which personally I don't think, was worth the life of 1 man never mind thousands. The aims were not met in the battle of the Somme because there was a failure to find a breakthrough and all the high hopes were shattered. Conclusion By the end of the war both sides had suffered the same. I would say the battle of the Somme was an all round 'tragedy' not just military. Nothing was gained but a hell of a lot was lost. Men died for their country, but so many men wouldn't have needed to die if there wasn't such poor quality of leadership and preparation. General Haig tried to justify the amount of men lost by saying that the British won the battle. This is arguable because we lost over 400,000 men and yes the Germans lost more men, but you cannot say who won the battle because how many men they lost for just 6 miles of land. Who knows how many men we would have been lost if it weren't for the fate of the weather, which ended the war due to the horrendous conditions. What the men had to suffer and the amount of deaths shows evidence of a tragedy, but the bad leadership also shows evidence of this, and then there is the fact that we didn't win the battle after all the pain and suffering of the soldiers on both sides. Although Haig thinks 'we won the battle,' in my opinion he couldn't have been more wrong, the battle was a complete failure. Approximately 1,115,000 men died for just 6 miles; did anybody actually win the battle? Lewis Brooks 10GS GCSE History ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level War Poetry essays

  1. The Battle of the Somme - source related study.

    Source B supports the evidence given in Source A because in the picture it relates to Source A, because it shows the men trying to relax after Stand - to, though this would be very difficult because the men are on guard and they are looking for enemy spies trying to approach them.

  2. The Battle of the Somme 1916

    But after careful study of the layout of the trench and the soldiers, I believe it is in fact a captured German trench rather than an Allied one. I believe this because of the positioning of the soldier that looks as if he is on guard duty to the right

  1. The Battle of the Somme 1916 - source related study.

    and be able to see the 'reality' of war, or at least what they thought was reality. Although it seemed real, the video did not show the whole picture of what went on, only showing small pieces of what happened, with the harsh reality of blood and gore unseen by the public.

  2. Were the British Generals like Sir Douglas Haig responsible for the high casualty figures?

    A soldier who survived, George Coppard, said, 'Many died on the enemy wire as on the ground, like fish caught on a net'. This quote tells us that the bombardment just made no mans land harder to cross. Some soldier also referred to the men caught on the barbed wire as ' insects caught on a spiders web'.

  1. The year 1916 was the year of the Battle of the Somme.

    deep and wide and we know that the Germans were the first soldiers to get to the battlefield and create larger trenches. Source A is associated with Source B because it quotes in the extract, "relaxation was difficult". This is linked with the picture because the picture is showing one

  2. Reasons why the satalemate broke

    Also, U-boats, E-boats and aircraft were used to hunt down and destroy the U-boats. By the end of the war Germans themselves called the U-boats coffins. Although the U-boats had an effect on Britain at first but once again they were definitely not a war-winning device.

  1. The significance of the Somme

    This is an extremely small amount of crimes in comparison to the size of the army. In his second source, we can also see that recruiting numbers were extremely high in 1914 with patriotism still strong in the soldiers' minds.

  2. Does the film, 'The battle of the Somme' provide us with a realistic picture ...

    However other sources agree with the images and points put forward in the film. Some sources suggest that the trenches were comfortable and the men were happy to live there, there was a good level of hygiene and the soldiers were enjoying themselves.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work