• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

With detailed reference to their words and actions, consider whom you find the more attractive character – Hal or Hotspur

Extracts from this document...


With detailed reference to their words and actions, consider whom you find the more attractive character - Hal or Hotspur Hal and Hotspur have what is probably the strongest rivalry in this play. The word attractive can have many meanings but I will interpret it as being the person who comes across as being the one who really appeals to the audience through their strong and weak points. In real life Hal and Hotspur were not even of the same generation, let alone the same age. Shakespeare has changed the age of Hotspur to make him the same age as Hal. This allows him to compare the two characters and to build up a strong rivalry between them. Shakespeare also uses Hotspur to make Hal's character appear more attractive and to show that he is actually very suited to the throne. Prince Hal is a character who, at the start of the play, appears to be riotous and disobedient. However, Hal does possess many appealing qualities and as the play goes on, we start to see that the time Hal spends in the tavern is part of his learning experience and he is learning to be able to function at any level to help him become an effective and successful king. We learn this from Hal's soliloquy when he says, "He may be more wondered at, by breaking through the foul and ugly mists" (by which he means the world of the tavern and in particular, Falstaff). ...read more.


When he says "Where shall we take a purse tomorrow, Jack?" he shows that he isn't just being led into crime by Falstaff but he is actually wanting to be involved. Some qualities which Hal has are seen as unattractive but are actually necessary for him to become a successful king. One example of this is Hal's hard headedness when it comes to politics. Hal appears to be using Falstaff for his own gain and even though he seems to enjoy having a laugh with him, when it comes to throwing him off he doesn't show any remorse. It is possible that Hal didn't like Falstaff in the first place but this seems to be unlikely due to the amount of time he spends joking with him. The way in which Hal discards Falstaff doesn't reflect well on his personality but it is necessary if he is to become successful in his kingship. Hotspur also has attractive and unattractive qualities. The first we hear of him in the play is when he is being praised by the king. The king even goes so far as to say "That some night-tripping fairy had exchanged in cradle clothes our children" meaning that he wishes that he could prove that a fairy had exchanged his son with Hotspur when they were babies. This makes us think that if the king wishes Hotspur was his son then he must be a much better person than Hal and thus be the obvious choice for the most attractive character. ...read more.


When the rebels hold an important meeting Hotspur is given the job of bringing the map be he manages to forget this simple task as the line "A plague upon it! I have forgot the map!" shows. As Hotspur is supposed to have a claim to being future king even a small problem like this could prove fatal should he become king and forget something important. When these two very important characters are being compared together we can get a clearer idea as to who stands out as being the most 'attractive' character. Hotspur's greatest attribute is his skill in battle and he often shows off how good a warrior he is but when they actually meet in battle Hal comes out on top and he kills Hotspur. At the start of the play Henry IV says that he wishes Hotspur was prince instead of Hal but as the play does on we start to see Hotspur's less attractive qualities come to light as we see Hal's attractive qualities. Then, by the end of the play we discover that actually Hal will be a better prince than Hotspur could be. Although, at the start of the play it is Hotspur who comes across as being the most attractive character, a combination of strong and weak qualities which both Hal and Hotspur possess make us change our minds as the play goes on and at the end of the play it is Hal who stands out as being the most attractive character. Iain Robertson ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Henry V section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Henry V essays

  1. Media Comparative Essay: (in the medium of film) concerning the 2 well known film ...

    A camera technique Branagh makes use of persistently is the concentrated close-up shots of Williams filling most of the screen. The shot plays onto Branagh's emotional theme, revealing characters' expressions of fear and anger. Olivier has directed this scene in many ways to his own interest.

  2. English/ English Literature Joint Coursework Folder

    This is creative on Branagh's part in composing an extra-script character to create dramatic irony in what he is to discuss in his argument further on. Sequentially another point to acknowledge is the stepping on a twig, gathering attention from the other characters - an obvious film cliché.

  1. The Subplot: Consider the significance of the subplot and examine Shakespeare's dramatic use of ...

    plays a trick on Williams, this also gives the character of henry a human side by showing that he seeks humour. We see the characters of the sub plot linked with Henry in their reason for going to war, Henry goes to gain land and returns with a wife.

  2. Media Comparative Essay: Concerning the 2 well known film versions of Shakespeare's Henry V ...

    The second point that explains Branagh's use of music is through creativity. The effect in adding a special underlying sound mix to the speech is an emotionally attractive quality for modern film and audience. The background music clearly sets the tone and mood, which the words attempt to do.

  1. Explore how Shakespeare creates humour for the audience in the scenes in which the ...

    The character of Falstaff is thought to have been created by Shakespeare on request of Queen Elizabeth I who supposedly commanded Shakespeare to write a play with Falstaff as the central character, after seeing the history plays, in which Falstaff appeared.

  2. Does Henry V offer a patriotic version of Henry's campaigns on the surface while ...

    This is in stark contrast to the lines in the chorus speech which I made reference to earlier. The king has not comforted his troops at all but annoyed one of them and does not call all his troops countrymen as the speech suggests but actually when it comes one

  1. Explore Shakespeare's presentation of Hal and Falstaff in the tavern in Act II Scene ...

    This could parallel King Henry IV and Hotspur trying to outdo each other, with Falstaff paralleling Hotspur, and Hal paralleling his father. This links the Sub-Plot to the main plot. I would direct this line with Hal saying it with self-satisfaction, and Hal sounding clever and smart.

  2. "Falstaff is a dreadful character in every way yet the audience cannot help but ...

    Using people is one of Falstaff's main faults, he has an almost father/son relationship with Hal. However this relationship is not filled with mutual respect, no doubt Falstaff hopes that his fraternizing with the young Prince will mean a pay-off in titles, money, and prestige when Hal comes into power.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work