• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Australian church groups have found the destruction of old growth forests as unethical. Father Paul Collins, a catholic priest, said according to (The age, 1995) that "To totally destroy some of the most extraordinary

Extracts from this document...


"Woodchipping in Australia, an environmental disaster, or a major source of economic revenue? Australia's native forests have been the scene of a hard fought debate between the woodchip industry and environmentalists; it's a battle that has proved to be a win-lose situation. On one hand is the forestry industry, and its need to harvest woodchips, for the lifestyle of workers and sustain a liable revenue for the economy, on the other, determined environmentalists hoping to put an end to what they believe is an unsustainable, ruthless industry, for the sake of keeping the environment and it's creature intact for future generations. This essay will look at the forestry industry and the environmentalists and there contrasting views on the issue of woodchipping and furthermore what the Catholic Church has to say on the issue. The fiery debate between the forestry workers and those concerned with the environment, really took off in 1995, when the issue was brought up by the government. (The age, 1995, pg 3) reports that a proposal was set forth by the Australian government to expand the woodchip industry by granting two more woodchip licenses to companies, thus meaning that 'gross export would rise to 6.7 million tonnes a year'�. ...read more.


the form of a worker or the family of the worker and the closing down of the mill will force workers to look elsewhere for work, this may prove to a problem for the worker especially if they have no experience of anything outside of forestry, hence jeopardising the future of the worker and their family, "We must pay more attention to the one who works than to what the worker does. The self-realization of the human person is the measure of what is right and wrong". (On human work, Donders translation #6). Many sawmills have been owned and run by families for many generations and if they were to lose this source of income, it would mean the end of a long tradition and may spell the end of a small town that relies on forestry. "The worker must be paid, to support him and his family" (The fortieth year, #71) The industry also claims that timber harvesting is carefully managed� with streamside vegetation kept in tact to avoid erosion of creeks and rivers, and most harvested areas are regenerated to attract birds and animals back. "To commit oneself to the promotion of a sound and healthy environment for all is to follow God's plan for creation, a plan entrusted to us from the beginning." ...read more.


(Economic Justice for all, #34). Conservationists argue that woodchipping is not a sustainable industry and that chips are low value exports at only $80 a tonne?. The revenue from the felling of publicly-owned timber was far less than the administration costs Many of the trees that meet the needs of the woodchip industry are usually centuries old, and may have developed hollows splits and rotten centres, which are the characteristics of a perfect habitat for many birds and animals. Timber harvesting reduces water quality and quantity. During rain storms tonnes of earth from logging coupes are washed into streams, causing silitation, which in turn kills many fish and aquatic species. "To commit oneself to the promotion of a sound and healthy environment for all is to follow God's plan for creation, a plan entrusted to us from the beginning." (Sister Marjorie Keenan) In conclusion it is evident that both sides voice a strong opinion for their side of the story, but the churches view aslso has to be taken into consideration. There is enough evidence that the church does support various aspects of both sides of the issues. However the church teachings because the environmentalists make up scientists and importantly the general public as appose to the industry which mostly makes up forestry workers and owners. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Global Interdependence & Economic Transition section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Global Interdependence & Economic Transition essays

  1. The Growth of Dubai

    2000 Early Growth Was Centred Around Dubai Creek Foreign Workers in Dubai Dubai's growth and development has depended on its ability to attract settlers and workers from both the nearby regions and from further away. Immigrant workers of many levels and from many countries make up a large percentage of the population.

  2. Economic Growth & Development Questions and answers.

    GDP per capita income also doesn't take into account the distribution of income, and therefore may show a distorted figure when the majority of the figure is composed of a few wealthy people (e.g. Saudi Arabia and the Royal Families), rather than of the country as a whole.

  1. International Ecotourism Management: Using Australia and Africa as Case Studies.

    Ecotourism is one of these submarkets, with adventure tourism, wilderness use and car camping also important (Eagles, 1995a). Research shows that park visitors' satisfaction with their visit is not directly correlated with use density or gross numbers. Satisfaction is more closely correlated with environmental quality, the adequacy of facilities and programs and the accuracy of expectations (Graefe et.

  2. Different types of travel destination. Study of Cardiff and Barcelona as travel destinations.

    The Table opposite shows the expenditure on different types of business in Cardiff. It covers all main types of income for the city. As we can see from the graph it shows that all areas rose with Transport rising by the highest at an 11% increase.

  1. Development of the leisure and recreation industry

    2596843 1241382 1355461 70-74 2339231 1059151 1280080 75-79 1966929 817711 1149218 80-84 1966929 482697 830850 85-89 752787 226833 525954 90 and over 371269 83202 288067 Totals 58789194 28581233 30207961 Percentage 100 48.616% 51.384% Source National Statistics Website These statistics were retrieved from the ONS website.

  2. Leisure and Recreation Industry.

    Pubs and clubs are very big in entertainment, providing informal and easy accessible facilities which are used daily by different groups of people. Theatres range in popularity. The big shows in London book out months in advance and have no trouble generating income but there are also smaller theatres which can often struggle.

  1. Environmental Terrorists (Development or Destruction?) - A proposal for a 40 minute documentary.

    However on the evening of Sunday 2nd November the waters began to rise sharply, giving some people precious seconds to get onto higher grounds. For most people, however, there was no time to escape. A torrent of water came flooding down mixed with debris and uprooted trees from the constant illegal logging in the jungle, leaving the village in ruins.

  2. Comparing population, globalisation and social justice in Australia and Indonesia

    The transmigration program brought to the surface issues of indigenous control and assimilation and many saw transmigration as 'forced assimilation' and a violation of customary land rights (Adhiati, 2001). Many also saw the transmigration program as simply a redistribution of poverty and failing to alleviate it in any way.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work