• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing population, globalisation and social justice in Australia and Indonesia

Extracts from this document...


Major Essay - in lieu of exam "Taking the three components of the course title: population, globalisation and social justice, write an essay of 2,000 to 2,500 words comparing their application in Australia and Indonesia". Questions of population, globalisation and social justice are helpful in comparing a wealthy, western country; Australia, and a developing and somewhat poverty-stricken country; Indonesia. By looking at similar problems that both countries share, but also looking at the differences in the problems and also in the way in which the countries handle these problems, one can appreciate the inequalities that exist between developed and developing countries, as well as examine some of the difficulties that face humanity. In recent times issues concerning population have been prevalent in both Indonesia and Australia, especially regarding immigration, refugees, carrying capacity and specifically in Indonesia; transmigration. In Australia, much news has been devoted to issues of race, especially the immigration policy of the Australian government. There seems to have been somewhat of a consensus reached that a population of 23 million is the optimum population that Australia's resources can currently handle, (Foran and Poldy, 2002:12) and given the one to two percent population increase each year and the current large amounts of refugees applying for temporary and permanent residence in Australia, this figure is estimated to be reached by 2010. The Australian government's immigration policy is vitally important as it will play a major role in determining the quality of life of all Australians, however Australia must address the fundamental issue of the ability of the environment and to cope with population increases. ...read more.


New South Wales Premier, Bob Carr says we should actually reduce immigration levels, not that he necessarily agrees with the Federal Coalition but because he thinks Sydney is getting too crowded. With one fifth of Australia's population squeezed into the Sydney basin, it is a legitimate observation and revelas Australia's major social justice issue. People in general and in this case, the Australian people are naturally drawn to centres of economic activity because of the instinctive infrastructure that occurs to support economic and commercial activity. There is also a large market catchment where competition is greater and prices are tailored accordingly. Due to these factors in recent years there has been a continual shift of the population from rural centres to urban regions, that cannot cope with large populations. Australia's rural centres are left small and without; commercial activity or opportunity, centralised skilled workers or competition with a subsequent increase in prices and cost of living. The 'exodus from the bush' as the National Party calls it, whereby young poeple living in rural and regional centres have to realistically look at moving away if they want to get better employment opportunities is also a major problem and similarly adults too are finding they cannot afford to live in the country. As one source argues, "one of the keys to effective decentralisation options is the stimulation and maintenance of economic activity" (Connell, 1998:24). The Australian government can certainly 'kick start' economies and have in the past by injecting larges sums of money. But in the end, Governments cannot continue to spend more than the budget allows and at the moment it is not considered economically of great importance to do so. ...read more.


In both Indonesia and Australia environmental issues must be addressed, however Indonesia has a range of equally if not more important issues such as poverty and the economy to focus on. Herein lies a distinct difference between Indonesia; where poverty is absolute and Australia; where poverty is relative. Due to the arguably affective welfare system in Australia, every person is entitled to some income from the government and has the ability to at least live, in comparison to Indonesia where poverty is life threatening to the weak economy and inability of welfare. In Indonesia and Australia, population issues remain at the forefront of newsand in recent times population problems in Australia have resulted in rural-urban problems, whereas in Indonesia, methods of transmigration have created confusion and accentuated economic and social problems. The impact of globalisation has been far more prominent in Indonesia, in creating social problems and increasing poverty, compared to Australia where globalisation evokes almost completely different emotions, as global interest and activity is vital to the success and well being of the Australian economy. Whilst many Australians benefit from the influence of global companies with resulting lower prices and a competitive market, Indonesians are forced to work often in poor conditions, long hours for little pay and are often forced to move from their agricultural jobs to seek work in the larger factories. Indonesia's economy, devastated by the Asian economic crisis is struggling to grow and raise the currently low standard of living in Indonesia. The issues of population, globalisation and social justice that both countries are confronted with, but also the different problems and methods of resolution sought by the respective governments provides an interesting contrast a wealthy, western country; Australia, and a developing and somewhat poverty-stricken country; Indonesia. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Global Interdependence & Economic Transition section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Global Interdependence & Economic Transition essays

  1. Can developing countries ever catch up with developed countries

    Secondly, a world system, or a desystematised world, constructed outside the present framework would necessarily transform developed as well as underdeveloped societies, not generalise western models.

  2. International Ecotourism Management: Using Australia and Africa as Case Studies.

    To better understand nature-based tourism, scholars propose dimensions of nature-based tourism. These dimensions vary from those of other forms of tourism, such as cultural, sports or religious tourism. Table 1 reveals the dimensions and the type of variation (modified from Valentine, 1992).

  1. The issue of globalization has been an ongoing process that raised many questions in ...

    He sees states converging with the existence of capital accumulation. However, Rostow overlooks the conditions of different countries. He doesn't realize that countries cannot develop the same way because due to various resources and structure. His model is constructed purely upon Western European standards and neglects the fact that different countries have different circumstances.

  2. Sustainable Tourism in Australia

    The Australian federal government addresses policies that are designed to deliver a vibrant tourism industry that's makes a strong contribution to the economy. The broad mission statement of Australia's federal government in relation to tourism policy is to: "Contribute to Australia economic and social well being through The development of

  1. Tourism in LEDC's creates environmental and social problems whilst bringing limited economic benefits. How ...

    This is where the hotels and beaches are owned by multinational companies and most of the profits are taken outside the country. In these circumstances tourism can alienate the local people by drawing them from their traditional agricultural employment but having a negative impact upon their local culture and environment.

  2. 'There is nothing in the Montessori prepared environment that is there by chance.' Discuss.

    - Handbook, page 47. (Social, emotional and spiritual) A pedometer for measuring the children's height when they are standing up and sitting down. * To record and enable the children to have their own individual biographical record. (Social, emotional ) * The children can visualise their growth and development in a scientific way.(Social, emotional )

  1. The Meaning of Globalisation and its Effects

    To preserve the goal of self reliance. MEASURES TAKEN TO ENHANCE PRIVATIZATION To improve the operational efficiency of enterprises and their contribution to the national economy by selling them to private investors. To reduce the burden of parastatals, enterprises to depend on the government budget.

  2. Newly industrialised countries have been, and continue to be, the driving force of globalisation. ...

    This means that compared to countries such as England, the total cost of these employees is considerably less, thus the TNCs can gain more profit for purposes such as advertising. 1. The advantage of using these Eastern countries as locations to expand the businesses of TNCs or other companies is

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work