• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Critically assess the extent to which the concept of the rural idyll is relevant to an understanding of contemporary rural identities'.

Extracts from this document...


Contested Countryside - Assignment 1 'Critically assess the extent to which the concept of the rural idyll is relevant to an understanding of contemporary rural identities'. The concept of 'rural idyll' with reference to the countryside can be described as a representation of 'an ideal society which is orderly, harmonious, healthy, secure, peaceful and a refuge from modernity.' (Ilbery, 1998). Ilbery suggests in this statement that there is a clear contrast drawn between the countryside or the 'rural idyll' and modernity, a representation of modern urban identity. This idea is supported by Phillips (1984) describing rural idyll as 'A positive image which is seen as opposing the uncertainty and confusion of the city and which creates a rural identity that is timeless'. Whilst the common conception is to define the two extremes of rural and urban, there is great inconsistency and preciseness in the exact definition of the term 'rural'. Halfacree (1993) suggests that 'the quest for any single, all embracing definition of the rural is neither desirable or feasible'. Despite the category itself having an influence upon behaviour and decision making. ...read more.


Those who live in rural areas are likely to do so because they desire what is often termed a romantic and idealistic setting in the countryside - away from urban areas, which are not settings of desire. This of course is the view of those who desire the countryside. Their view will of course differ from those who desire the city, those who will look upon urban settings as objects of disgust. There are of course extenuating circumstances such as the convenience of site and situation, particularly with relation to employment and services which form an importance in many people's lives. Many of those who live in urban environments do at some point, chose to migrate to the countryside either as a status of class and/or wealth, or as an escape from an undesirable setting. In which case, there are those who live in rural areas which view migration from towns and cities as a threat to an unspoilt and idyllic setting. A setting, which once was safe and distant from the contrast of urbanised areas, could be considered to be under threat, particularly with the movement of industrial centres to out-of-town settings. ...read more.


As is the case with the concept of the rural idyll, rural identities are very much socialistically defined and are person-specific. The idea that the countryside is timeless, unchanged or romantic is considered by many geographers to be nothing more than a myth, but many believe it to be the case. The concept of rural idyll itself is in question because of the dynamic structure of both rural and urban settings. Contemporary rural identities can be defined by many techniques such as census data but the relevance of the concept of rural idyll has to be brought into question, particularly as the concept itself is considered by many to be a myth. Even if such a perception were to be accepted, definition would be difficult, particularly to produce a widely accepted classification. The varied and incomprehensive definitions of the terms 'rural idyll' and 'contemporary rural identities' are under such scrutiny and are determined by dynamic factors. Such a circumstance does not make establishing the relevance of the former to the latter easy or clear-cut. For this reason it is sensible to suggest that the concept of the rural idyll, as an idealistic and theoretical approach is permissible, but the relevance to understanding contemporary (modern) rural identities is not feasible in dynamically structured settings such as rural and urban areas. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Population & Settlement section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Population & Settlement essays

  1. Geography revision - flooding - Urbanisation - Population problems

    altitude (height above or below sea level,) geology (firm, or well drained,) water supply (free from flooding & water supply,) soil (fertile or infertile,) shelter (from the wind,) and space (room for expansion.) Situation Position in relation to surroundings (eg major roads, railways, and towns.) Urban Large settlements such as cities or towns with cathedrals, large populations,

  2. Case Study of Deprivation in a Rural Area - Cornwall

    geographers talk of the post-production countryside, just like 'post-industrial' is used for towns and cities. 3. The Eden Project Many benefits compared to problems. Benefits: * Many visitors - 750,000 each year. 1.9 million In the first year and 6 million the past 4 years.

  1. The rural aftermath - The effects of the plagues.

    The next batch of plagues, however, hit the children of the survivors and this had a significant knock on effect for the regeneration of the population. At first sight this might seem to have alleviated the pressure on land before 1348.

  2. "What is the relation between the image of the 'rural' and the idea of ...

    The image of the rural, as seen in terms of their work is primitive and largely agricultural. The rural people are seen to live in a less sophisticated habitat, boarding rooms and lodges; also small farming cottages are often the main perceptions of rural habitats.

  1. Road Traffic Accidents

    the even of fire or theft of the vehicle The Road Traffic Act requires all motorists to be insured against their liability for any injuries to others and any damages to other people's property resulting from using their vehicle on a road or other public places A motorist's insurance premium

  2. Explain why urban-industrialization in China during the central planning period deprived the rural sector.

    rate to the government, as a means of financing national development plans (see price-scissors policy). "Urban dwellers enjoy a range of social, economic and cultural benefits while peasants, the majority of the Chinese population, are treated as second-class citizens.5 The Hukou system also imposed strict controls on internal migration.

  1. Data Interpretation (assignment 1)

    The grand total of burglary offences between April 03' and Mar 04' is 1,950. The total amount of burglary offences per 1000 population in Ipswich is 16.7 and the total amount per 1000 population for England / Wales is 15.6.

  2. geographical understanding

    There are many reasons why a certain site might be chosen for the development of a settlement. Some factors will be more important than others. If we group and classify a number of settlements according to their size the result is called a settlement hierarchy.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work