• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically contrast the approach to organisations of the classical management theorists with that of the contingency theorists. Which do you think has had the greatest impact on management today and why?

Extracts from this document...


Topic: Critically contrast the approach to organisations of the classical management theorists with that of the contingency theorists. Which do you think has had the greatest impact on management today and why? The management field is characterised by a wide variety of theories, schools and directions. This essay examines the classical and contingency schools of thought -- the approaches to organization that have had the greatest impact on management today. Firstly the essay delineates and criticises the important theories propounded by classical writers. The essay continues with an account of the contingency school, and finally evaluates its impacts on managerial thought. Up until about the late 1950s academic writing about organisational structure was dominated by the classical management school. This held that there was a single organisational structure that was effective in all organisations. (Clegg & Handy, 1999). According to Holt (1999), the classical school is characterised by "being highly structured, with emphasis on the formal organisation with clearly defined functions and detailed rules, autocratic leadership, a rigid chain of command and control by superiors" (Holt, 1999, p.137). The three greatest proponents of classical theory were Taylor, Fayol, and Weber. Each identifies detailed principles and methods through which this kind of organisation could be achieved. Taylor (1947) developed a systematic approach to called 'Scientific Management', which focused on efficient production. ...read more.


emphasised that Chandler's theory has some distinct restrictions. First, Chandler looked only at very large and powerful industrial business firms which dominated their industries. Whether Chandler's findings would be applicable to small-and medium-sized organisations, service companies or those in the public sector could not be answered in this sample. Second, when Chandler used the term 'strategy', he really meant 'growh' strategy. His definition of strategy, based on product differentiation, is far from all-inclusive. Another critique on the strategy imperative lies in questioning the degree of discretionary latitude that managers actually have. The impact of strategy would be greater in the early development period of an organisation. Once a firm becomes established, it cannot change easily. Moreover, the strategy imperative deals with a lag factor: when management implements a new strategy, there is often no immediate change in structure (Robbins and Barnwell, 2002). The other thorists who focus on strategy-structure relationship is Bartlett and Ghoshal (1991) who proposed that each of these strategies required specific organisational structural characteristics to be effective. To be successful, they not only had to have an appropriate strategy for their product but they also needed a structure that fitted the strategy. Ghoshal put forward the transnational organisation concept as a managerially sophitisicated ideal type towards which cross-national organisations will have to develop in order to obtain and retain global competitiveness. ...read more.


In the Chandler's typology, it was similar to an organisation with a single-product strategy. However, expanding their product lines to such things as personal computers and mobile phones, and their business market worldwide, Sanyo confronted the need for organisational change. In 1999, Sanyo introduced the Company System into their management replacing the existing department system. After this structural change, Sanyo's organisation structure turned into a more divisional structure. Each of the five "companies" (Industrial System, Multimedia, Home appliance, Semi Conductor, Soft Energy) has great autonomy and independence from its management. This transformation could be described as a move towards a multi product strategy. In the contingency view, Sanyo is a company that skilfully manages its organisational change in accordance with their managerial strategy. This kind of transformation based on the contingency approach can be frequently seen in today's activities of global firms. From this perspective, it can be concluded that a contingency theory of organisation had a great impact on management today. Ketchen (2003) points out that firms become more "organic" (flexible in their structure and operations). While some firms prospered in the new environment by creating highly flexible structures and processes, others fail. This implies each organisation should consider the necessary actions taking into account various contingency factors, and, as a living organism, have the capacity to change its structure appropriately to the environment. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Environmental Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Environmental Management essays

  1. Topic: Critically contrast the approach to organisations of the classical management theorists with that ...

    While Scientific Management took a micro approach, Fayol saw the macro concepts, a body of knowledge which emphasised broad administrative principles applicable to large organizations. In Fayol's account, management is conceptualised as consisting of five elements, namely planning, organizing, command, co-ordination, and control.

  2. Managing change by managing risk

    Risk management as a shared or centralized activity must accomplish the following tasks: * Identity concerns * Identify risks & risk owners * Evaluate the risks as to likelihood and consequences * Assess the options for accommodating the risks * Prioritize the risk management efforts * Develop risk management plans

  1. The Impact of Man on the Environment.

    Though deforestation rates have slowed a bit in recent years, financial realities make this unlikely to occur. A more workable solution is to carefully manage forest resources by eliminating clear-cutting to make sure that forest environments remain intact. The cutting that does occur should be balanced by the planting of

  2. To what extent are cold environments fragile environments and how far does this affect ...

    At the moment approximately 15-20% of the arctic's wilderness is affected by infrastructure, and we are threatening the natural equilibrium of the environment.

  1. Why, despite its relevance in today's world, is management development so problematical in its ...

    as the key influencers of management development strategy in companies, this influencing role was closely linked to organizational size. Top executives were more likely to have a major influence in smaller companies, whereas in medium size organizations, the key influencers were also likely to be Human Resource practitioners.

  2. Sustainability and Wilderness Environments

    The patrols are led by one of the government Protect area staff, accompanied by five or six Eco-guards and porters who know the local area. If these patrols apprehend poachers, there are several sanctions available, depending on the severity of the situation.

  1. Christian teachings on stewardship and creation.

    There are many advantages of using renewable sources and many disadvantages from the effects of using non-renewable sources. The effects have been and do cause problems to the environment. Many people already try to help the environment but who does the responsibility of the environment fall upon?

  2. Land Management

    Land degradation is one of Australia's greatest environmental and economic problems. As a result the land is less able to produce crops, feed animals, or renew natural vegetation. Land degradation is usually caused when humans misuse the land. The following causes Australia's soil degradation: Overgrazing 79%, deforestation 12%, cropping 8% and industrialisation 1%.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work