• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Does the demographic transition model still provide a 21st century framework for looking at demographical change in countries which are experiencing development? To what extent is the tool really useful or should we make it obsolete?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Does the DTM still provide a 21st century framework for looking at demographical change in countries which are experiencing development? To what extent is the tool really useful or should we make it obsolete? The demographic transition model is a means to calculate how countries will move from having high birth and death rates to low birth and death rates. It should allow us to predict the stages a developing country will have to pass through before it is fully industrialised. These changes are dependant on an array of social and economic factors for instance improved education, changes to women's roles (e.g. emancipation), better diet and enhanced healthcare. The demographic transition model is the result of compiled data, such as, birth rate, death rate and population from industrialised countries (mainly Europe and America). The DTM consists of 5 sections; there were originally 4 stages but the 5th was recently added when countries that were already considered to be fully developed continued to develop and change, making it necessary to modify and update the model. In stage 1 birth and death rates fluctuate at a high level (about 35 per 1000) giving a small population growth. Stage 2 is characterised by high birth rates but rapidly falling death rate to about 20 per 1000 people giving a rapid population growth. ...read more.

Middle

were imported from colonising countries and so arrived far more quickly than in Europe. This means that it was not a necessity for countries to industrialise to lower the death rate and so whilst the country might, technically, be progressing through the model, it is not industrialising. Similarly the model assumed that stage 3 followed several decades after stage 2 and that death rate fell as a consequence of changes brought about by changes in the birth rate. This has often not been the case. In some countries the onset of stage 3 was held back by the population's attitudes to family size, birth control, status, women (many believe that emancipation is necessary for industrialisation and socioeconomic change), religion etc. In other cases the fall was speeded by government intervention such as China's one child per family policy and some of it's subsequent population policies. The original model had had to be adapted to include a 5th stage. This seemed to happening in some countries of Western Europe and in Japan in the late 20th century. It is now clearly seen in some countries in east and central Europe, where death rate exceeds the birth rate. As one stage had to be added, is it not feasible that a 6th or even a 7th stage be added at some stage in the future? ...read more.

Conclusion

However, when applied to countries that are still developing it has very limited use. It cannot be used for countries that are growing as a result of immigration as it does not account for this, this adds to the idea that the DTM cannot be used as a general tool for all countries. An unforeseen lethal disease renders it useless. Not all countries choose to industrialise which means that their demographic transition will either stay in stage 1 or the countries will import the factors needed to progress, hence still not following the model though still, possibly, reaching the same end. Also it could be argued that countries in Europe and the US are still developing and we have no data available to make projections about our future. The tool is not entirely obsolete, it can be used to look at the past, but has limited use for the future, though it must be said that with any model a demographer could not hope to make predictions but merely projections. It seems likely that as more data is made available for the demographic change of countries outside of the western world, the DTM will have to be added to and changed, or maybe a new one will have to be formulated to work beside the old one, to compensate for the limitations that must be present in all models. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Population & Settlement section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

A good review of the strengths and limitations of the DTM. This essay could be further strengthened through incorporation of specific examples and data as evidence for the points being made.
4 stars.

Marked by teacher Molly Reynolds 20/08/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Population & Settlement essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    For my Travel and Tourism coursework I have chosen Marbella as my European destination ...

    4 star(s)

    - One of the most famous resorts within Costa del Sol region and the Mediterranean * Benalmadena (36km North East along the coast) - A popular tourist resort * Puerto Banus (7km West) - Known for its rich lifestyle and harbour this is an area within Marbella that attracts many more tourists to the resort * Gibraltar (58km South West)

  2. Free essay

    Factors affecting birth rates in countries with different levels of development.

    In less developed countries, children are seen as part of the work force and therefore sometimes contribute to the family through work as young as 3years old. This then results in a large number of births. In developed countries, there is a difference of opinion and women are seen as a financial burden.

  1. Explain why development is a complex term to measure and define

    or gross national product (GNP). Both are given in US dollars so that comparisons can be made between countries more easily, and are usually given as GDP/GNP per capita to account for differences in population. However, there are several problems with this measurement.

  2. Population Distribution in China.

    Since 1980 Shenzen has become a major industrial centre increasing its population from 30 thousand to 3 million people. The work opportunities drawing in people from the surrounding Guangdong Province and other ports of China. Here is a list of factors along with a description that have effected population growth...

  1. London Docklands Case Study.

    of waterfront accessible in 1981, 31 miles (50 km) in 1998 - with lots of bridges. Water sports facilities have been or are being provided in every dock. An ecology park was created at Bow Creek and a wildfowl sanctuary at East India Dock Basin.

  2. How relevant is the Demographic Transition Model?

    This was true for the MEDCs of today, as, in the 19th Century, many went through an industrial revolution and gained a lot of money from it. This led top better medical care, clean water and a good food supply that resulted in a drop in the death rate, followed by a drop in the birth rates.

  1. Does quality of life increase as one moves away from CBD of Swansea?

    life as there is a place for leisure activities and provides an attractive impression of the area (this can be seen in the figure 20). Figure 19: A photograph of a typical large detached house in the Newton area. Figure 20: A photograph example of the open and well-presented space.

  2. Are the ideas of Thomas Malthus relevant to the early twenty-first century?

    and birth rates falling (preventative). Malthus believed these 'checks' would take place due to the world having a carrying capacity. This meaning that our planet had finite resources, which will only support a number of people.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work