• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Population policies

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'Population policies create more problems than they solve'. With reference to pro-natalist, anti-natalist and migration policies assess the validity of the statement. China is suffering from a rapidly increasing population and on the other side of the spectrum; Russia is suffering from a decreasing population. Both countries have implemented population policies to try and tackle there problems. But do these policies really help? Or do they create more problems than they solve? In this essay, I shall look at both Russia's pro-natalist policies and then china's anti-natalist policies and I will be assessing their effects. Firstly, I am going to define what pro and anti-natalist means; Pro-natalist - Encourage couples to have more children and thus increase the population. E.g. Russia Anti-natalist - Dissuade couples from having more children and thus reduce fertility. Emphasis on family planning. E.g. China Russia has pro-natalist policies, it is the largest country in the world, is facing a demographic crisis; poverty and infertility has lowered birth rates to about 9.95 per 1,000 people and poor health care and alcoholic problems have increased death rates to 14.65 deaths per 1,000. Poverty and lack of opportunities are encouraging people to leave the country in search of a better life; 100,000 people are leaving Russia every year while only about 70,000 immigrants enter. ...read more.

Middle

Offered lot of prizes to women who give birth on the Russian national unity day. These policies don't actually tackle the real problems, people aren't going to have children for a few gifts and they're not going to half children because they have a day off of work either. The real problem lies with poverty, giving $9,200 is only going to help in the short term, but the kids need to be clothed and fed for 18 years. This money would be better spent creating jobs that will increase wealth and make people want to have children as opposed to encouraging them to have children when they don't want to. The money spent trying to encourage people to have children could be spent reducing the death rates, this is something Russia isn't doing very well; 35,000 people die every year from alcohol, Russia needs to reduce this problem and also improve the health care system, this will increase life expectancy and improve the economy, which would have a multiplier effect as it would improve the economy and allow more people to have children. China has anti-natalist policies; with just over 1.3 billion people it is the world's most populous country. ...read more.

Conclusion

China has now stopped forcing abortions and instead has tried to educate them through family planning schemes, these organisations were once feared however they're now offering advice and are decreasing birth rates without force. Even with it's problems, 75% Chinese people agree with this one child policy and there is no doubt that it has decreased Chinas population growth, however, I think that because the child policy was implemented to remove negative externalities, it shouldn't create more of them. Instead of forcing people to have one child, they should have identified the reasons why people had a lot of children and made it easier for them to have one children by tackling those reasons. They should have created more jobs and increased pensions so that the people wouldn't need to rely on their children to look after them in the world age. Out of the two countries, I think the anti-natalist policies that china has implemented have been more successful; they have decreased population growth which was a huge problem for china. Russia on the other hand, hasn't really increased its population and is wasting a lot of money providing short solution to the problem; they need use this money to create more jobs and to improve the healthcare system. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Population & Settlement section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Population & Settlement essays

  1. Geography revision - flooding - Urbanisation - Population problems

    International loans to Brazil allow Brazil to control forestry. Emillio manages an area sustainable, every tree cut down in replaced, and only small strips are deforested, which allow reseeding. Oxen are used for transportation as they cause less damage, and all the wood is used, producing 250 cubic metres of wood per hectare (compared with average 3-5.)

  2. An Overview of Immigration to Australia

    From 1788, they were shipped here, and from the early 1790s, free immigrants were joined. The period between 1851 and 1860 was a peak with 50,000 people a year at the early migration stage. The world wars influenced migration: resettling of refugees and young people.

  1. Does a population hierarchy exist on the Ards Peninsula?

    the ferry and of the time it would take to get there. Table 2 also shows that Downpatrick is the least popular destination in competition with Newtownards and Belfast. It is interesting that although Belfast is the capital city and therefore more likely to have a greater variety of shops and services, that more people would travel to Newtownards.

  2. Migration: Russia

    This is because of the lack of a state program for distributing forced migrants, and so they choose destinations due to their accessibility from their starting point and the location of relatives. The break up of the Soviet Union had a large impact on migration into Russia.

  1. To What Extent did the Gradual Abandonment of the Maoist Development Paradigm Between the ...

    What happened to the people's pride in their nation, and did the disbanding of the communes lead to a fall in social cohesion and the breaking of social ties? All these factors and more will be examined, and from that analysis should emerge an objective picture of the peasants' welfare.

  2. POPULATION GROWTH - China

    They raise crops and sometimes keep flocks and herds. The Miao-Yao branch, with their major concentration in Kweichow, are distributed throughout the central south and south-western provinces and are found also in some small areas in east China. They are subdivided into many rather distinct groupings. Most of them have now lost their traditional tribal traits through the influence

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work