• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Modernisation Theory is the only accurate way of defining development. Assess the arguments for and against this argument.

Extracts from this document...


The Modernisation Theory is the only accurate way of defining development. Assess the arguments for and against this argument. The modernisation theory argues that development is a evolutionary process that countries progress through; seeks to explain why poorer, traditional societies have failed to develop into modern ones. However, immediately it could be argued that this argument is flawed, because there is much debate over what development is and how it should be defined. For example, whether it is economic measures such as GDP or GNP should be used, or whether it should be social measures such as HDI. Nevertheless, the modernisation theory needs to be exhausted, to assess whether it accurately defines development, or whether other theories offer a better explanation. As Europe revolutionised, sociologists began explaining how societies began to develop. Early modernisation theorists such as Comte and Durkheim believed that more advance societies had evolved from agricultural ones; eventually all societies would follow along this evolutionary path. After WW2, policy makers began to put in place the aims of the modernisation theory. The modernisation theory assumed that poorer traditional societies had failed to develop because they had not industrialised, in addition to the lack of individualism, capitalism and science. Moreover, the modernisation theory offers several explanations for LEDC poverty. ...read more.


However, it can be argued that the mode theory is being ethnocentric: arguing that the LEDCs are lacking is some respect, and they have "deficit model" of development. Moreover, it can be argued that some MEDCs retain their traditional values, this is especially visible in the newly industrialised countries such as India and China. The dependency theory would argue that this process of development would exploit the LEDCs; and bring upon them a new form of Western imperialism. Frank argues that this would create a "chain of dependency" , between the core (MEDCs) and periphery (LEDCs).The worlds system theory (Wallerstein) would look at this on a global scale and argue that the MEDCs would use this system to exploit the LEDCs. What' more, the neo-liberals would be critical of so much government intervention. It is evident, that Rostows process of development offers a optimistic outlook for LEDCs, however, it is ethnocentric. It is evident that countries can retain traditional values and modernise. What's more, it mostly looks at economic factors whereas, other modernisation theorist believe cultural factors to be more important, therefore giving the theory a more whole and accurate definition of development. Some aspects of the modernisation theory looks more at cultural factors to explain poverty in LEDCs. For example, Parsons argued that LEDCs are dominated by traditional religious beliefs which prevent development and make them fatalistic about their future. ...read more.


One, could argue that the modernisation theory has a optimistic outlook on the development of LEDCs, however, they assume LEDCs need subservient their culture and tradition to achieve modernity. The dependency theory would argue that the "motors", driven by the West, serve to take control and exploit the LEDCs. Putting them under a new form of economic and Western imperialism. In addition, the neo-liberals would discourage such intervention, and favour the free market and competition as being the best way for LEDCs to develop. Overall, it is evident that the modernisation theory can provide a fairly accurate view of development in the world today. However, it assumes that traditional values and norms of the LEDCcs hold them back, making their argument ethnocentric. In addition, the modernisation theory is too simplistic, and overlooks many factors. For example, the dependency theory would argue that the core (MEDCS), simply hold and exploit the peripheries (LEDCs)., via "neo-colonialism. What's more, the world systems theory would arguer that the whole global system needs to be examined, with a focus on economics. Yet, despite the criticisms- neo-modernisation theorist's have hit back. Modernisation theorist's such as Eisenstadht and Dahrendorf have come to different conclusions from the earlier theorist's - Parsons and Rostow. They argue that Modernisation can be used with local traditions rather than just looking at Western models, with a more value-based approach. Together, they offer a much more accurate definition of development, than the simplistic modernisation theory alone. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Global Interdependence & Economic Transition section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Global Interdependence & Economic Transition essays

  1. Consider the Defining Features of Dependency Theory and distinguish its Major Variants. Discuss the ...

    These considerations stress that dependent capitalistic economies are not identical to central capitalistic economies. A real process of dependent development exists in some Latin American countries. Development in this context is referring to 'capitalist development'. This form of development, in the periphery as well as the centre, produces as it

  2. Core and periphery of Brazil

    The Core has its Problems too, overcrowding of people and competition for business, resulted in the core overheating. People move to the Southeast to improve their quality of life. However so many people now live and work in the big cities of the core that this begins to create its own problems.

  1. Development of the leisure and recreation industry

    Award The mission statement and objectives for this authority in relation to the provisions to the community is : To provide relevant, affordable, accessible leisure services to the people of Knowsley and to contribute to the Councils other strategic objectives of economic development, education and health so as to improve the quality of life in the Borough.

  2. Explain how HDI is determined.

    this is inhibited by high rates of infant mortality rates, lower levels of life expectancy and low levels of female participation in education.

  1. Tourism in LEDC's creates environmental and social problems whilst bringing limited economic benefits. How ...

    The vast gap in wealth between the tourists and the residents causes considerable resentment and as a result tourists are often targets for theft and crime. The behaviour of tourists can also prompt attacks at popular clubbing destinations. Tourists often become drunk and are offensive to residents, starting fights and

  2. The use of trade is the most important tool to achieve economic growth in ...

    And finally, they believe that trade only benefits the wealthy members of society and that the wealth doesn't 'trickle down' to the majority of the population, resulting in the gap between rich and poor widening. Whilst trade must be promoted in LDCs, it is just as, if not more important, to preach free trade and fair trade in developed countries.

  1. Current development issues in Brazil

    is expected to increase from $8.1 billion in 2000 to $18.5 billion by 2010.8 Yet it is important to focus on environmentally friendly technologies and accommodation for visitors in order to fully capitalize on the potential of ecotourism. Environmental threats facing Brazil(Table 1, Annex 1 summarizes the major environmental threats in Brazil.)

  2. What is Dependency Theory and how does it apply to development?

    The dependent states are countries that have low GNPs (Gross National Product) and which rely a lot on the export of a single resource. These dependent states belong mostly to Latin America, Asia and Africa. Secondly, the dominant states influence the dependent states through multinational corporations within the developing states.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work