• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the nature-nurture debate in relation to individual development

Extracts from this document...


BND Health and Social Care Unit 4- Development Through The Life Stages P4- Describe the two theories of ageing M3- Use examples to compare two major theories of ageing D2-Evaluate the influence of two major theories of ageing on health and social care provision In this assignment I am going to be writing about the two theories of the ageing process of an individual. These two theories are called the disengagement theory and the activity theory. Disengagement Theory The disengagement theory was a theory, introduced by two authors called Cuming and Henry (1961), which suggested that as we get older, we will naturally make positive effort to withdraw from life as a response to their lessening physical, intellectual, emotional and social skills and abilities, diminishing interests and expectations of how they should behave. The reason for this is because older people will disengage due to reduced physical health and loss of social opportunities. (B.Stretch, 2007) There are many problems or issues that have a tendency to limit social interactions, which could potentially be a reason why older people tend to disengage more. ...read more.


However, as people grow older, some life events which include retirement and bereavement cause people to loose contact and get rid of their social networks and cut down on the amount of social contacts they have. This theory suggests that by interacting in new and alternative activities that promote and add to their relationship, gives the elderly the sense of achievement which can cause them to have full interest in their lives. (B.Stretch, 2007) Activity theory is basic perspective which suggests that elderly people will important benefits and they will be able to make meaningful contributions to other people's lives if they are involved in activities. Studies which have been taken out have shown that elder adults do indeed benefit from activities that make them feel like they that they accomplishing something. Doing an activity for the sake of doing it can have negative consequences. Therefore doing an activity of some sort which the person is interested in can have some positive effects. So therefore they should take something like gardening, visiting art galleries, walking or going to the theatre. This can improve an individuals wellbeing and keep them health. ...read more.


That eases the physical and social limitations that naturally accompany aging. (www.health.howstuffworks.com/life-stages/aging/disengagement-theory2) Disengagement is a two-way process. The individual progressively disengages from their general involvement with society (retirement and so forth) and society, in turn, starts to disengage from the individual (people interact socially with the elderly on fewer and fewer occasions). Criticisms of this theory that we could note here are that: 1. Disengagement is not a progressive, inevitable, consequence of growing old (few people are always actively engaged in the society to which they belong, for example). On this basis we could justify discriminatory measures against, for example, the unemployed, on the basis that they have disengaged themselves from a normal, central, activity in society. 2. Secondly, as the unemployment example shows, disengagement is not simply a matter of choice - the old have disengagement forced upon them. This theory ignores the role of cultural values and economic structures in the active creation of disengagement. The main conclusion for this is that when it is considered in earlier life it is referred to & discussed as development and later in life when change is considered it is referred to as aging. Also that none of the theories mentioned above can claim sufficient evidence to account for the aging effects that are witnessed & experienced in humans. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Healthcare section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

This essay aimed to discuss two theories of aging. The student met P4 by giving details of activity theory and disengagement theory.
The descriptions of the theories were very good. However poor grammar made some of the ideas difficult to understand.

I would have liked to have seen the student use a wider range of care settings, with regards to meeting D2.
Remember to include a list of references at the end of the work.
There were several spelling & grammar errors which could be minimised by careful proof-reading.

Marked by teacher Debbie Apeah-Kubi 24/05/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Healthcare essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Describe the physical, intellectual, emotional and social development for each of the life stages ...

    3 star(s)

    All we know is that both play a huge role in making us who we are today and both have a big impact on us. One of the topics argued in the nature-nurture debate is whether being straight, gay or bisexual is inherited by our parents or influenced by our environment.

  2. Personal & professional development in Health & Social care.n this assignment I am going ...

    Waltham Forest College, Forest Road, Walthamstow, London, E17 4JB Date: 10th May 2010 till 24th May 2010- 2 Weeks. Job duties, Teachers assistant; * supporting the students with their work, activities and etc * communicating with the students * going on outings together with the students and staff * writing

  1. Describe 4 examples of discriminatory practice

    A person with low self-esteem before they start using health and social care services. A person who has low self-esteem will experience negative self-identity, which brings a feeling of worthlessness and depression. The health and social care workers need to ensure that the individual's self-esteem is maintained or raised, to help the person cope with their situation.

  2. Unit 21 Nutrition for health and social care

    Iodine is important for normal growth and development of the baby. Iodine supplements are often advised during pregnancy to meet the increased needs as food sources (such as seafood, iodised salt and bread) are unlikely to provide enough iodine.

  1. Explain the concept of Equality, Diversity and Rights in relation to health and social ...

    There could also be written, there the person would want write things down, due to lack of understanding or English might not be their first language. E.g. someone could be going to an interview in an organisation; they might prefer to have an interpreter to translate the English into their preferred language.

  2. Explain the sequence and rate of each aspect of development from birth to 19 ...

    and plays group games, needs structure and routing to feel safe, when behaviour is over the top they need limits to be set. Intellectual Development: Begin to understand about sameness and difference in various aspects of life, can begin to understand that differences can exist side by side.

  1. Outline current legislation, guidelines policies and procedure within own UK Home Nation affecting the ...

    when escorting a child to the toilet or a child needs to be undressed due to any accident, it is vital that another member of staff or child is present as to not allow any allegations of misconduct. Physical contact between child and adult is important for building caring

  2. Evaluate the long term effects of physical and emotion abuse on the individual experiencing ...

    Lack of sleep can affect the body by affecting your mental processes. Mood is diminished and you feel sluggish. Thinking is slower, it's harder to concentrate and there's a feeling of mental fogginess.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work