Anti-Semitism vs. Anti-Americanism.

Authors Avatar

Roumyana Mihailova 11/2

 7th December 2003

Anti-Semitism vs. Anti-Americanism

At first sight it seems that anti-Semitism and anti-Americanism are too different to be compared. According to the Torah, Jews are a nation that shares the same religion and history (Tracey npag). For more than two thousand years Jews have been spread all over the world and still have kept their identity (Stefanov npag). On the other hand, America incorporates people of different religions and races and is one of the world powers. So, if anti-Semitism is an attitude against a nation, anti-Americanism is hatred of a prosperous country. However, it turns out that both Americans and Jews have been subjects of disdain. Furthermore, they both have been accused of a determination to dominate the world. The last common element of anti-Semitism and anti-Americanism is religious hatred.

The term anti-Semitism originated in 1879 as a result of a theory, stating that Jews are inferior to people of the Aryan race (Glatzer npag). However, discrimination of Jews existed long before 1879. In the Roman Empire, most Jews were not given Roman citizenship (Glatzer npag). Even though according to the Torah the Jews are not a race, in Nazis Germany exactly the theory that Jewish race is inferior to the Aryan race was used as an excuse for persecutions of Jews. That idea became popular and the French “diplomat and social philosopher Comte Joseph Arthur de Gobineau”, as well as the “German philosopher and economist Karl Dühring” accepted it and wrote anti-Semitic books (Glatzer npag). Sir Oswald Mosley, a leader of the British Union of Fascist, was famous for his “acts of violence against Jews, and steady incitement to Jew-baiting” (Pryce-Jones npag).  Anti-Semitism was a global phenomenon.

Join now!

So is Anti-Americanism. According to the British historian Paul Johnson, anti-Americanism is “a function of cultural racism” (Johnson, npag). One of the arguments by which many Europeans try to prove their cultural superiority to Americans is that European civilizations existed long before the USA.   Europeans share “spectacular and splendid accounts of the past, (…) similar institutions and ideas, and an enormous confidence in the superior manipulative power of their culture” (Roberts, p.171). Before the Great War Europe was a leading industrial power. And suddenly, after the First World War, this position was taken by the USA. Once lost their ...

This is a preview of the whole essay