• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Asses the Elizabeth's priorities in formulating the Church Settlement of 1559

Extracts from this document...


Asses the Elizabeth's priorities in formulating the Church Settlement of 1559. Over the years there has been much debate amongst different historians as to what were Elizabeth I's priorities in formulating the Church Settlement of 1559. There are three main schools of thought. First one, represented by orthodox historian, J. Neale, assumes that Elizabeth I wanted a Henrican Settlement, in which she would be a head of the church rather than the Pope. Revisionist school, however, represented by Jones, argues that Queen wanted extreme Protestant Settlement similar to the 1552 Prayer Book. The last one, Post-Revisionist school, can be divided into two groups. First group assumes that Queen was weak and therefore manipulated by her the Council, which was in charge of Cecil. Second group, however, argues that Elizabeth was a strong Queen who got what she wanted by good management and control of her parliament. The traditional interpretation of the events of 1559 was provided by Sir John Neale, who argued that Elizabeth I preferred a restoration of her father's church- Catholicism without the Pope. ...read more.


In their eyes "only Christ was head of the Church." However, Sir John Neale's interpretation has been criticised by several historians. The historian who, more than any other, led the criticism of John Neale's view is Norman Jones. This Revisionist historian argues that Neale's view is to narrow and lack depth. He argued that "Elizabeth I and her advisers established a religion settlement which reflected their own religious views." Opposition to this settlement, according to Jones, came from Catholics in the House of Lords, not radical Protestants in the House of Commons, who in Jones opinion never existed. What is more Jones proved, that Neale's "puritan group", could not consist of Marian exiles, who could not have been elected in time to the parliament. What is more, Jones believed that Elizabeth planned to re-establish Royal Supremacy over the Church and to reintroduce the Book of Common Prayer of 1552. "The main opposition of these proposals came from Catholics Bishops in the House of Lords." As Jones noted in his essay "Elizabeth's First Year" in Christopher Heigh's "The Reign of Elizabeth I" "By the 23rd March the Queen and Cecil, having badly miscalculated the strength of resistance to religious change in the Lords, found themselves in a difficult position". ...read more.


As she goes on, "Elizabeth used her opposition wisely to achieve her objectives." Susan and Guy agree on the causes which affected the result of the Settlement of 1559. They believe that "Via Media" was chosen by the king because of Catholic pressure, however Guy argues that it was because Queen was weak and influenced by her Council, whereas Doran believes that Queen decided to choose "Middle Way" on her own because it was the best solution not only for her, but also for the state. It is clear that the most important single factor in explaining the settlement is the Queen herself. It was Protestant settlement rather than a Catholic one reflected her religious views as well as those of her most loyal supporters. What is important to mention, is that Elizabeth consistently used the Church with political concerns uppermost in her mind. One can argue that Elizabeth was forced by Catholics and Puritans to choose the "via media" option. This, however, can be argued by more likely theory that she simply reviewed her priorities in forming the Religious Settlement of 1559 and chose the middle way to maintain the peace within the state. ?? ?? ?? ?? Elizabeth I Church Settlement of 1559 30.01.2006 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How serious a threat did the Puritans pose to Elizabeth I and her Church?

    4 star(s)

    However, Doran argues that 'most of the clergy who attended such classes were probably not committed to a Presbyterian system...but simply wanted to meet like minded brethren to discuss the Prayer Book and reach decisions on day-to-day parochial concerns'. This is indeed the more likely explanation because if it really

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Elizabeth I: There is much debate amongst historians concerning the religious priorities of Elizabeth ...

    4 star(s)

    There is a danger when trying to ascertain Elizabeth's own personal beliefs, as much were dictated by political considerations and so cannot be considered her own personal preferences. Indeed, revisionist historians have rejected Neale's view as the existence of the 'Puritan Choir' has been disproved, in fact Norman Jones showed

  1. Explain the factors which shaped the Elizabethan Religious Settlement reached in 1559

    Cecil than Elizabeth, then her religious convictions were obviously not as strong as is previously believed. The influence of Cecil is no doubt evident in the final religious settlement. However, it is important to consider to what extent and how the Privy Council and Cecil had an effect on Elizabeth.

  2. To what extent was the Elizabethan Church Settlement of 1559 - 66 motivated more ...

    There was also an order that Church ornamentation be as laid down in the 1549 Prayer Book which pleased the majority of Catholics and made it look like that Elizabeth chose their faith as equally compared to Protestantism. The Black Rubric was completely removed in the Royal Junctions of 1559 which forbade kneeling at communion service.

  1. 'A religious settlement of her own choosing'. How far is this an accurate view ...

    One of the things which was to enrage extreme Protestants but give them hope in the years to come was a line which stated that priestly vestments should be as they were in the second year of Edward VI's reign, until the Queen decrees otherwise.

  2. Using all the sources, and your own knowledge, assess to what extent the Church ...

    she and not a foreign power would have control in 'all things religious and spiritual' in the country. Source 3 suggests that the church was 'greatly influenced by practical political considerations' and this certainly seemed to be the case. This can be supported by source 1 where when praying Elizabeth

  1. What considerations influenced the framing of the church settlement of 1559?

    She pursued this plan by retaining certain aspects of the traditional Catholic Church. On the other hand, she still showed signs of Protestant settlement, as she had recalled her papal ambassador and had formed alliance with strongly Protestant German princes.

  2. Asses the main influences which determined the Elizabethan Church Settlement in 1559

    Yet, even if she was slightly more sympathetic towards the Protestants, it was clear that she intended to unite ?the people of this realm into a uniform order of religion?[4] To do so, it is undeniable that she would have to compromise her own religious beliefs to satisfy as many of the public and Parliament as possible.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work