• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the view that the holocaust was due to a long term plan of Hitler

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Assess the view that the holocaust was due to a long term plan of Hitler's? Due to a formulated and structured plan? Or due to incontrollable influence of conflicting events? The extermination of the Jews was however not initial but took a gradualism approach. Whether this was planned is a subject of disputation and controversy .Functionalist historians state that it resulted from increasing radicalisation. They agree it was an accumulation of events which led to the "final solution" and due to other governmental direction such ad Heydrich or Himmler. Another school of thought however find significant evidence apparent in Mein Kempth of Hitler's determination and desperation to "eradicate" the Jewish race. Thus exemplifying the conception that the Holocaust was part of a "long term ideal" [Interpretation C] of Hitler's deep in the book, something which the intentionalists credit Daniel Jonah Goldhagen said it was a long held ideal Hitler had clear and direct goals it was designed to look like a gradual growth e.g. Night of Broken Glass completely contradicting with [Interpretation A]which argues the extermination of the Jews was due to "subsequent escalation". Daniel Jonah Goldhagen of [Interpretation C] states the regime was "determined and not linear and unambiguous". ...read more.

Middle

it also agrees with [Interpretation D] "there were measures taken against the Jews".However the view of [Interpretation A] disagrees and states "They were determined to exclude the jews from society but little thought had been given to how thius was to to be achieved" adds the extra bit of information that the Jews extermination was spontaneous .ity has the implication that Hitler didn't know the ultimate direction beforehand . "this is not to imply the inventors the inventors of the final solution had a clear idea" On the other hand [Interpretation C] says the ideas were"clear".Two conflicting arguments .Hitler spoke of the importance of"the extermination of the peoples devil".The view is argued by Trevor Roper that Mein Kampf was "a complete blueprint of his intended achievements" On the contrary Hitler has been seen to be by many as an "weak dictator". Interpretation D states that "heydrich ws more than happy to use Hitlers blanket of authoritization"This reveals to us of Hitlers possible lack of dedication towards the cause. That he preffered for work to be done on his behalf.Hitler was not the one who orchestrated the holocaust advocated by Dick Geary "the absence of clear lines of authority".This links with as [Inteprtation B] Which agrees that nazi organisation was in line with atrocities . ...read more.

Conclusion

The eradication of the Jews was ahead of a "long list" Further evidence suggests of Hitlers premeditation about the holocaust about the holocaust " but the final objective must be the complete removal /Entferning of the Jews".The letter was written in 1919 to his military superior Adolf Gemlich This written eveidence as Hitler states "final objective" meaning the same thing as the final solution .It can therefore be argued he had intentional goals that were preplanned .This also highlights the fact that Hitler gave orders to his officals and they knew his core intentions years in advance ."Heydrich was more than happy to use Hitlers blanket of auauthorosiationto expand killing into the overall programme of Europe under genocide".Top offocials such as Heydrich and Himmler took matters into their own hands .This view is complemented by historian Fritz Redlich who states "at times Hitler proposed less radical measurses than other Nationalists Socialists such as Heydrich and Himmler This implies that although Hitlers undisputable anti-Semitism both historians stress his small role in the the Genocide . On the other hand [Interpretation c] disagrees with this and says Hitler was "determined to undertake a task" .This point is strenghed historian Fritz Redlich as he says "obviously only he could undertake a task" and "he had helpers to...execute his wishes".Not leaders as [Interpretation D] suggests ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. This essay will examine the rise of anti-Semitism from ancient times to the Holocaust ...

    The Munich Agreement of September 1938, made to appease Hitler's threats to takeover Czechoslovakia, ceded the Sudeten area of the country to Germany. This was part of the Nazi Lebensraum policy to provide living space for the Aryan nation and resulted in the Jews living in these countries being stripped of their possessions and jobs, and resettled in ghettos.

  2. How far was the holocaust a long term plan of nazi racial policy?

    " The Fuhrer's prophecy is coming true in the most terrible way"7, suggests that Hitler's will was taken by the Hitler's followers and then turned into coherent policy. In order for the holocaust to have occurred someone must have initially listened to Hitler's speech, concocted a plan of action and

  1. The Wannsee Conference was entirely responsible for the Holocaust. How valid is this assessment ...

    It suggests Jews were content to watch the German people suffering. This cartoon is a cover from Der Sturmer a well known Nazi newspaper that was created by Julius Strecher, who was one of Hitler's earliest followers. The cartoon was published in August 1930.

  2. What in your view was the short term significance of the Decembrist Revolt?

    The formation and growth of the"Westernisers", deeply cynical of autocracy, can largely be attributed to the Decembrists, as they were the first group to challenge autocracy in such a way with aims to replace it with liberal systems of the west, they also posed questions to how a revolution could

  1. The Holocaust

    Jews are to be defined solely on the basis of race, and not of the basis of religion" (Cohn-Sherbok, D., 2003. pp 273-274). This marked a turning point in the rise of anti-Semitism as the persecution was no longer based on religion, but race.

  2. Hitler's Willing Executioners - The role of Ordinary Germans during the Holocaust

    He believed in "international Jewry" as an actually existing political subject with vast power that was hostile to Germany. He also believed that a Jewish international conspiracy was intent on exterminating Germany and the Germans. Therefore Hitler portrayed the Holocaust as a defensive act, a necessary move to destroy the Jews before they destroyed Germany.

  1. Assess the view that the Holocaust was mainly a result of a long term ...

    The wording of this account is enlightening in regard to a "plan" as the author uses the phrase "long term" on three occasions, but never "plan"; rather "goals", "intentions" and "ideal". This draws our attention to the other key word "eliminate", because the meaning of this was never clarified.

  2. The Holocaust was the result of Hitlers long held grand design to pursue a ...

    Intentionalism can be seen as almost a reactionary view. German people needed to place blame, and thus, it was easier to place blame upon individuals than to condemn an entire nation; the Nuremburg trails unsuccessfully attempted to prosecute the main perpetrators, key individuals rather than Germany as a nation, a demonstration of this idea.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work