• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Both sources A and B are interpretations by historians attempting to explain the Long March - They disagree on what they tell us. Why is this the case?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

History Coursework Assignment Year 11 CHINA IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY Question 1 Both sources A and B are interpretations by historians attempting to explain the Long March. They disagree on what they tell us. Why is this the case? Explain your answer using Sources A and B and your own knowledge. [10 marks] (500 words) Source A's interpretation of the Long March makes the Red Army seem heroic. The commitment and sheer determination that enabled the several hundred thousand men to cover 6000 miles in a year is aimed to amaze the audience. The three Chinese historians say that the 'Red Army defeated all KMT attempts to overtake, surround and destroy it.' This is an exaggeration from the authors, as they do not mention that the Red Army suffered losses of over 80%. They have decided not to mention this fact intentionally as the purpose of this source is to present the Red Army as a success. Many people supported the Chinese Communist Party however in the source they say 'it received support of people all along its route and victoriously completed its historic mission.' This statement I feel is extravagant to persuade the reader of the Red Army's qualities. I can see why the three Chinese historians have used the word 'unconquerable'. In 1937 when Japan began a full-scale invasion of China it bought terrible hardship to the people. ...read more.

Middle

It is really during the Long March that a large portion of Chinese population first encountered and subsequently adopted the Marxist beliefs. Nevertheless, the Chinese Communist Party suffered heavy casualties. From the 100 000 members who departed only 20 000 arrived at destination, including the newcomers recruited along the way. The Long March was probably the key event that brought the Chinese Communist Party to power. The success of this first step yielded a formula that greatly influenced the upcoming events in communist China. The Long March is still seen as one of the most important events in China's history for the following effects: 1) It kept Communism alive in China (LT) 2) It was a huge practical and propagandist victory. The soldiers were marching through the countryside spreading the ideas of communism. Soon everybody was talking about Mao Tse- tung and the fantastic story of human determination. (ST) 3) This march established Mao Tse-tung as the main leader of the Chinese Communist Party. (ST) The 1911 Revolution of the Double Tenth overthrew the old imperial regime and a period of Nationalist government of China began. This was the end of 4,000 years of the hated Manchu Dynasty. China was ruled by the Kuomintang, under Dr Sun Yat- Sen. The new government faced threats from local warlords and the Japanese. ...read more.

Conclusion

A long-term effect of the Long March is that people did not have any freedom of thought because they had to follow Communist rules and were subjected to endless propaganda. Both the Tiananmen Square massacre and Long March had a high death toll, which had a dramatic short-term effect. However the Long March resulted in victory for communism and defeat for the pro democratic demonstrations. The victory from the Long March however had a greater impact on Chinese history as it had a long term effect on society as communist ideas were put in place whereas at the Tiananman Square massacre nothing was achieved only lives were lost. Conclusion The commitment and sheer determination that enabled the remaining troops to survive the Long March helped the Chinese Communists establish themselves as the future leaders of China. Mao Tse- tung's strategic genius helped establish the Chinese Communist Party as indestructible. Because of his guerrilla warfare tactics during the campaigns and his ability to know what the Kuomintang and Chiang Kai-shek were going to do, he brought a sense of mystery and power to his Party. From comparing the Long March against other events in the Twentieth Century such as the 1911 Revolution and the Tiananmen Square massacre I can see that the Long March had the greatest impact on Chinese history. Had the Long March never occurred, it is quite possible that China would be today under Japanese rule. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. American History.

    It destroyed Indian resistance [Tecumseh died], leading to American? expansion to the South and West [but not into Canada]. It exposed American militarily weakness and made clear the importance of? better transportation systems, which then made improving those two items nat'l priorities.

  2. The Tiananmen Square incident, 4 June 1989 Sources Question

    But because they were American they may have bent the truth a bit to make the Chinese look worse e.g. where they add the phrase "though this figure may well be too low." This phrase is not a fact it is the writer's opinion, which would be biased against the Chinese.

  1. The Long March is embedded deep in the psychology of the Chinese communist party. ...

    Around 7 percent of China's inhabitants are not ethnically Han Chinese. It's not a great proportion when you compare them to the minorities of other countries but nearly 80 million people in absolute terms - enough to form several states of their own.

  2. Russia: a Century of Upheaval.

    This was the beginning of a new era in Russian history. So, It is quite easy to see that Russia's relationship developed dramatically over the space of half a century, to such an extent did the social order of Russia change that often people did not know what to think.

  1. The government in China today is communist.

    This means that there would be democracy for most but dictatorship for those that didn't comply with Communist rule (reactionaries). The Communists faced many problems when they came to power before they could unite China. Civil war had caused a reduction in agricultural output and increases in population put strains on the few resources they did have.

  2. Evaluation of key sources to address the question of increased tension

    The plane is a 'spy' plane, designed by the US to covertly photograph the Soviet Union, this shows little trust and an obvious increase in tension, America was invading Soviet airspace without permission. One flight by a U2 spy plane was unsuccessful.

  1. How has Chinese FP change since Mao and how important are economics…?

    and an approach to what can be called the "Period of Cooperation" (2,pp280) with America. One of China's major advantages during the Cold War was the ability to choose between the two super-powers of the era. The build up of both Chinese and soviet troops on the border "(6, Liu

  2. "The unpredictable events in China during the 20th Century make the future of Hong ...

    The small scale cottage industry collapsed and led to a famine that killed millions of people. The relations with USSR were becoming bitter, as promises of nuclear weapons were not met. The Communist Government was also becoming corrupt, more concerned with lining their own pockets than meet the demands of the people.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work