• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

By 1890 Bismarck Had Achieved A Unified But Not UnitedGermany - How Far Do You Agree With This Statement

Extracts from this document...


"By 1890 Bismarck Had Achieved A Unified But Not United Germany." - How Far Do You Agree With This Statement? In January 1871, as the Franco-Prussian war neared its end, King William I of Prussia was announced as the Emperor of the Second Empire (or Reich), with Otto Von Bismarck as his Chancellor, in the Palace of Versailles. From this point Bismarck had led a once weak nation into achieving his acclaimed 'master plan': to become the most dominant power in Europe, this was then confirmed ten days later with the defeat of the French army; to united all German speaking nations, excluding Austria, where Prussia was the dominant power; and to obtain political and military victories over Austria. However, although this was undeniably achieved, were the peoples and leaders of the Second Reich united in aim and feeling? The theory of unification was all very well, but each of the 25 states (now excluding Austria and Prussia annexations from the German Confederation) had its own traditions and ethos, so to unite the people in fact, as the nations had been, proved more complex than anticipated. Although the aim of the liberals of 1849 had been achieved, they were displeased by the manner in which unification had been imposed from above, rather than through popular national movement. The German Empire also ensured Prussian dominance in the Reich, with both the Emperor and Chancellor being Prussian as well as Prussia having the large majority in both the Reichstag and the Budesrat, with 17 out of the 58 votes. ...read more.


Having said this the demise of the National Liberals in the process of the tariff introductions allowed Bismarck to once more stress national interests to the population and strengthen the idea of a German identity throughout the Reich. For Bismarck's part, he viewed the Catholics as the major cause of disunity in his Protestant, Prussianized government he had so carefully set up, and so saw them as a threat to the peace, and believed they were plotting Prussia's downfall. Catholic dominated countries surrounded the borders of the Empire and even the south German states still associated with the Austrians, a Catholic country, rather than the Prussians. This fact alone is yet another sign of already instituted disloyalty within the Union, meaning that it would take a lot to unite such a diversity of people in national objective and attitude. This led Bismarck to believe that to attack the Catholics would weaken, and hopefully destroy, one of the main causes of hostility in the Empire. Nevertheless, the states involved in the North German Confederation had been largely Protestant, leaving the Catholics as a minority culture. The policy he launched became known as the 'Kulturkampf', translated as 'struggle for culture', and represented the struggle for power between the protestant Bismarck and the Roman Catholic Church. Yet this threat was only bought to light by the success of the Catholic Centre Party in the 1871. ...read more.


As Bismarck himself said: "Whoever has a pension fro his old age, he is much more content and easier to handle than the person who has no prospects." Furthermore, Bismarck also built on the economic prosperity of Prussia. He kept the standards of living in Prussia exceptionally high, and the economic prosperity and standard of living contented the potentially explosive elements of middle-class Germany. In this way Bismarck removed the threat of the revolution predicted by Karl Marx. In conclusion to this, although the people of the German Empire were not all united in aim as Bismarck had hoped, this was always an unlikely dream as even in modern society there are different political parties representing the different views the nation holds. It could even be said that his obsessive views of nationalism leading to the persecution of what he saw as minority groups set a basis for the extreme views and beliefs seen in Germany prior to the Second World War. Having said this, Bismarck did more in terms of state welfare for the nation than any other country had even began to anticipate, although perhaps not for the right reasons, this fact cannot be overruled. Therefore, despite not achieving unity within the united states making up the German Empire, or achieving his objective in the discrimination of such groups as the Socialists, Bismarck lay down the founding feelings of nationalism for future generations as well as leading the way in welfare reform for other countries to follow. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. "Italy Unified Itself". To what extent is this statement true?

    His efforts, along with the previous revolutionaries, proved that the Italians themselves possessed the willfulness to unify Italy, although they did not directly contribute to unification. Their achievements were solely symbolic and had no real practical success. Pope Pius IX was elected for papacy in 1846, and differed from the

  2. "In the period 1871-1890 Bismarck was better at crushing his opponents than at producing ...

    Many German landowners and businessmen asked the same of Bismarck. He agreed with the idea but the National Liberals were strongly opposed. In the 1878 election they lost 29 seats. Bismarck saw his chance to kick them while they were down.

  1. Hitlers Germany

    his friends who thought Britain and France were sincere in the negotiations which were taking place. The British and French did not exhibit any hastiness, at any rate. When they sent a military mission to Moscow in August, it went by leisurely boat.

  2. How Effectively Did Irish Catholic and Nationalist Leaders Advance Their Cause 1801-1921 ?

    and confident party with a large majority in the House of Commons." 17 Therefore Peel took a strong stance on response to O'Connell's repeal campaign, successfully calling O'Connell's bluff over the Clontarf meeting, meaning O'Connell's repeal campaign failed. The strength of government can be seen when in 1865 they responded

  1. How far had Hitler achieved his Third Reich?

    Hitler was influenced by the ideas of Eugenics, so by separating the 'undesirables', he felt he could 'selectively breed' a superior race and mould a greater Germany for the future. Eintopf and Winterhilf are two Nazi policies which highlight the helpfulness of Volksgemeinshaft.

  2. To what extent did the increase in the persecution of witches in Europe from ...

    This is why I believe that rather than arguing that these persecutions were a straight forward attack on women by sadistic and misogynistic men, we must ask why women appeared to be such a significant threat to society that they were consistently used as scapegoats across an entire continent for

  1. How far can the impact of the depression be seen as a key turning ...

    creation of a large fleet of battleships capable of challenging the British navy which made the rest of Europe uneasy, and by about 1907 German policy makers had succeeded in creating Bismarck's nightmare: a Germany surrounded by an alliance of hostile neighbours--in this case Russia, France, and Britain--in an alliance

  2. British dominance was unrivalled during the period of 1850-1929. How far do you agree ...

    Although the thriving situation within both the population and economic status seemed to express inevitable dominance for a healthy period of time, by the time the twentieth century took its toll, Britain?s economic position was no longer appearing to contract the stability it once obtained, and it was certainly not remaining unrivalled for much longer.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work