• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany as totalitarian states. (1996)

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and contrast Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany as totalitarian states. (1996) A totalitarian state refers to a country in which the central government exercises total control over all aspects of people's life. Main features include an infallible leader, one-party rule, strict party discipline, elitism, planned economy, an official doctrine, absolute obedience of individuals to the State, nationalism and usually an expansionist foreign policy. Up to these criteria, both Fascist Italy (1922-43) and Nazi Germany (1933-45) could be deemed totalitarian states to a large extent. Chaotic situation, irrationality and national humiliation often lead to totalitarianism. Both the Fascist and Nazi regimes owed their rise to the people's disillusionment with the Paris Peace Settlement and postwar difficulties. Though being a victorious power in World War One, Italy could not get all she wanted on the Paris Peace Conference. Especially Fiume was given to Yugoslavia, Italy's rival in Adriatic. As the major defeated power, Germany was punished heavily by the Treaty of Versailles. She was to pay a huge indemnity, cede traditional territories, lose all overseas possessions, accept almost total disarmament and the "war-guilt" clause, etc. Both Italy and Germany had unsuccessful democratic experiment. The coalition party governments in both countries had been incompetent in restoring national pride and getting rid of massive unemployment and hyper-inflation. Thus, a strong leader and efficient one-party rule were accepted in both Italy and Germany. However, Hitler came to power constitutionally while Mussolini staged a coup d'etat, i.e. the March on Rome. ...read more.

Middle

In 1933-45 about two-third of European Jews were killed. Nazism was supreme in Germany. There was no religious tolerance. All kinds of religions and churches were suppressed. Priests and pastors were exiled or sent to concentration camps. There was only Hitler's Reich Church. Pope Pius XI named him the "enemy of Christ and his Church". By contrast, Mussolini kept a peaceful and amicable relation with the Roman Catholic Church though he disliked Christianity. By the Lateran Treaty of 1929 Mussolini recognized Catholicism as the state religion and made the Vatican City independent. Again this showed that Mussolini was not the supreme in Italy. In a totalitarian state all the means of communication such as radio and newspapers are controlled by the government to glorify the State, attack the enemies and call on people to work for a noble future. Mass rallies are used to uplift people's spirit. Frequent meetings for the masses on-the-job or in local organizations let party members exhort the people. Education is also manipulated in the form of indoctrination. In both Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany substantial examples included revision of school curricula, inclusion of nationalism and official doctrines in textbooks, and forced allegiance to the State on teachers. In short, the State shaped people's thoughts and minds. In Germany, for example, Goebbel, Minister of Propaganda, was very good at tasks of Nazi indoctrination. ...read more.

Conclusion

There was rigid control of foreign exchange, allocation of raw materials, guided investment and disciplined regulations of labour, wages, farming, prices and profit. Nazis even ran some enterprises. Production was at Nazi disposal. Industries and agriculture were subsidized. Farmers' holdings were protected. Full employment was achieved by 1936 with such a planned economy, in addition to the massive rearmament and public works programmes. Workers even enjoyed such fringe benefits as subsidized holidays, cheap theatre and rent control, etc. Yet Alan Bullock argues that full employment and prosperity could not last unless Germany expanded. A totalitarian state often adopts an expansionist foreign policy to seek national glory. Both Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany built up formidable armaments. Before 1935 Mussolini posed to be a pacifist and anti-Nazi. Seeing the fragility of the Stresa Front, Mussolini joined Hitler subsequently in territorial expansion. There saw Italian invasion of Abyssinia and Albania. Mussolini's foreign policy was inconsistent and opportunistic. Hitler never hid his territorial ambitions. He aimed at complete reversal of the Treaty of Versailles, seeking "living space" for Germany and satisfying the popular nostalgic hankering of the return of German greatness. Hitler carried out conscription and full-scale rearmament, annexed Austria, Czechoslovakia and invaded Poland. They even formed the Axis and withdrew from the League of Nations. Both were accountable for the outbreak of World War Two. In a nutshell, we may say that both Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany were totalitarian states though there were some differences. 1 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. To what extent was Nazi Germany a totalitarian state before 1939?

    of politics, but he soon broke it and when the Catholics protested, their schools were closed down and thousands of priests and nuns were sent to concentration camps. The church's opposition is quite good proof that the Nazi's weren't completely successful in forming a totalitarian state: from the very beginning

  2. Hitler and the Nazi Regime - revision sheet.

    1939=25,000 prisoners and 6 camps. Extent of terror o "terror is the most effective instrument" - Hitler o SS limited pre 1939 o Concentration camps not extermination camps pre 1939 o Gestapo = understaffed = inefficient without the help of citizens o Emigration permitted D.

  1. Why did Mussolini's Fascist Party become popular in Italy after the First World War?

    In 1929 Mussolini even managed to make an agreement with the Pope called the Lateran Treaties. This settled an argument between the Italian Government and the Pope that had been going on for nearly sixty years.

  2. Causes of show trials + purges of 1930s.

    the Provisional government in the form of two Socialist Revolutionary ministers, two Menshevik ministers and two independent socialist ministers, the government was still headed by Prince L'vov. This was a significant event when the concept of dual power is being considered because it brought the socialist leaders of the Soviets

  1. 'Was Germany a totalitarian state'?

    It was the reports given by the people of Germany that allowed the Gestapo to make arrests and maintain effective repression. Through encouraging the unsubstantiated gossip that spreads in any community and taking this as concrete evidence, the Nazi party and more particularly the Gestapo were able to maintain a degree of control over people's everyday lives.

  2. How totalitarian was fascist Italy?

    Instead of dismissing Mussolini, the King allowed Mussolini to remain as Prime Minister, because he saw Mussolini as easy to control because he was already in trouble. Mussolini took full advantage of the lack of co-ordinated opposition and moved to suspend constitutional government and establish a totalitarian regime.

  1. Life in Nazi Germany, 1933-1945

    the memoirs value in revealing the success of the Nazi youth policies. However, its content should not be completely discarded, as the 'increasing demoralisation of youth' described did exist, but not on the scale suggested. Source D also does suggest this demoralisation did exist during the second half of the 1930s.

  2. To what extent was Germany a totalitarian state during the Third Reich.

    It was the reports given by the people of Germany that allowed the Gestapo to make arrests and maintain effective repression. Through encouraging the unsubstantiated gossip that spreads in any community and taking this as concrete evidence, the Nazi party and more particularly the Gestapo were able to maintain a degree of control over people's everyday lives.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work