• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare The Political Leadership Of Lincoln and Davis.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare The Political Leadership Of Lincoln and Davis It may seem self- evident that Lincoln was the greater political leader; Lincoln led the winning side while Davis was defeated. It has though, been thought that once the Northern advantages and Southern disadvantages have been considered, that it is possible, that almost anyone could have led the North to victory. If this is so, was it Davis's strong leadership, which ensured that the confederacy survived as long as it did? Davis's government has inevitably been blamed for the way it ran the war. Certainly it made mistakes. But arguably it was no more mistake prone than Lincoln's government. Nor were the Southerners less dedicated than the Yankees. Most Southerners fought long and hard for their new nation, enduring far greater suffering and hardship than Northerners. The reality was that the South simply has less room for error. ...read more.

Middle

Most Northerners supported Lincoln and determined to see the war to a victorious conclusion. With fewer people, far less in the way of industrial capacity, a less well-developed railway system, and with a Northern blockade disrupting trade with Europe, the odds were stacked highly against the Confederacy from start. Moreover, while Lincoln took over a 'going' concern in Washington, Jefferson Davis's administration had to build the confederate government from scratch. To fight- let alone to win- the war, Southerners would need to make a far greater sacrifice than the Northerners. Ultimately the efforts of the Confederate government and the Southern people were in vain. The collapse of Northern morale was the South's best hope of victory. The North on the other hand, with its greater manpower and resources, was always favourite to win the civil war. ...read more.

Conclusion

Lincoln is generally seen as more successful in communicating with the people, more skilful in keeping political factions working together for a common goal, and better able to endure criticism and work with his critics. He is lauded for keeping all his commanders (including Grant) on a leash, for appointing the final winning military team, for picking able administrative subordinates, and for knowing how to delegate. Davis, on the other hand is often seen as austere, rigid, humourless and prone to making enemies: his feuds with two of his top generals, Beauregard and Joe Johnston, undoubtedly harmed the Southern war effort. Lincoln's superiority to Davis might seem self- evident. But Lee could think of no Confederate leader who had done a better job than Davis. And Lincoln did make mistakes. He went through six failures as commanders in the Virginia theatre before he found the right general. Some of his other military appointments and strategic decisions can also be criticised. It is worth remembering Wendell Phillips' view of him: 'He is a first-rate, second-rate man'. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level History of the USA, 1840-1968 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level History of the USA, 1840-1968 essays

  1. Lincoln vs. Davis in the Civil War

    Neither president made vastly better appointments than the other but the difference between them was that Lincoln was ruthless enough to sack his bad appointments whilst Davis could not bring himself to do so. Furthermore, Davis' relationship with his Vice President, Alexander Stephens was catastrophic; Davis and Stephens conflicted in personality and ideology.

  2. Abraham Lincoln.

    On Election Day November 8 Lincoln won the presidency and celebrated in the white house. That night his friend Ward Lamon ( U.S. Marshall for Washington) slept outside of Lincoln's room in fear of him being assassinated. W. T. Sherman devised a plan (The Sherman Plan)

  1. Does Abraham Lincoln deserve his reputation as one of the greatest of American presidents?

    This act allowed poor people in the East to obtain land in the West. The Homestead Act declared that any citizen or future citizen could claim 160 acres of surveyed government land. It was agreed that any citizen claiming the land must improve the area with a house and plot.

  2. How far was the decision to rollback past the 38th parallel a military and ...

    civil war between North Korea and South Korea, especially because the North Koreans started the fight. For this reason the decision to rollback was effective. As well as this, holding North Korea would be extremely helpful geographically; this is because it is closer to China, who have recently turned communist.

  1. "How Did The Election of Abraham Lincoln in 1860 lead to the Secession of ...

    Due to the fact that Sewell is an American historian means that one may have to be cautious in his viewpoint in that he tends defend the South a lot in his book. Thus, it may appear he is a Southern historian.

  2. To what extent do you agree with Abraham Lincoln that slavery was 'somehow the ...

    So in this way nationalism became a central issue to causing the Civil War. Most South even still saw themselves as loyal Americans and before 1860 the fire eaters who had been arguing for secession were the minority. They saw themselves in this way as most South still saw themselves as loyal Americans even though they had left the Union.

  1. Why were the Liberals defeated in the general election of 1874?

    What this Act did was to increase the number of voters based on certain qualifications. (Hopkins, 2000, pp.1- 5) While this Act gave the right to vote to every male householder in the boroughs, who had occupied a house with a rental value of at least �10 (Disraeli, 1998, p.

  2. Jefferson Davis

    Beauregard demanded that Major Robert Anderson surrender Ft. Sumter in Charleston harbor. Anderson replied that he would be willing to leave the fort in 2 days when his supplies were exhausted. Beauregard rejected this offer and ordered his Confederate troops to open fire. After 34 hours of bombardment the Fort was severely damaged and Anderson was forced to surrender.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work