Compare the sources B and D for the reaction to the licensing act of 1872
Compare the sources B and D for the reaction to the licensing act of 1872
The two sources B and D have similar points and different points at the same time. Source B is a newspaper report where as source D is William Magee speaking in the House of Lords.
The first point, which the two sources agree with, are, they both condemn the reform bill meaning they disagree with the licensing bill on how people were not allowed to tamper with beer and pubs would reduce there opening hours. As it says, source B, ‘Government has offered… a wretched abortion called a silencing bill’. This gives the impression the newspaper is against the reform bill and believes that it is an extremely bad bill trying to prevent alcohol. As like source B, source D is the same it says ‘ strongest dislike’ meaning that William Magee (Bishop of Peterborough) disagrees strongly about the reform bill.