• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Continuous but limited.' How far do you agree with this view of changes in state provision for the poor in the period c.1830-1939?

Extracts from this document...


2. 'Continuous but limited.' How far do you agree with this view of changes in state provision for the poor in the period c.1830-1939? To answer this question, we need to assess both the breadth of change which occurred in the period and the process of change itself. We often imagine that progress in a particular area happens smoothly and as a result of a definite plan, but how valid is this view in reality? And if there was continuous change, how far into real social change did it penetrate? If we view the Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834 as the beginning of the period, we have a framework for the treatment of the poor which, if the statement is true, should continue almost constantly to improve, but only in a limited way. To what extent, then, was there continuity after the 1834 Act? There were various modifications to the Poor Law through the latter part of the century, not as part of any grand strategy, but on an ad hoc basis in response to public need and opinion. ...read more.


While they may not have come as a shock in ideological terms (as Progressive Liberalism and the development of Socialism had been leaning towards more State provision for several decades), in terms of actual provision they represented a huge change, acknowledging for the first time that unemployment was sometimes inevitable and not a result of idleness, and providing real protection against sickness and incapacity. This causes problems for our definition of "continuity" - these significant reforms were introduced quickly, so our model of a gradually developing provision breaks down somewhat. As to whether they were limited, of course they were - if we are discussing state provision, everything short of Communism is limited to some extent! However, if "limited" is used with the intention of meaning "limited for their purpose" or "more limited than one would expect", we can consider its relevance to the Liberal Reforms. While they were not "unlimited", I believe that to describe them as limited is to take away from their huge importance, as they arguably paved the way for the Welfare State. ...read more.


It also created labour exchanges and created bodies to oversee the unemployed. Where does this leave our definition of 'continuous but limited'? Continuity had to be interrupted, and limits had to be applied. It would seem that the accuracy of the statement varies across the period, showing that it cannot be completely accurate throughout the timespan. While there were periods of continuity, where State provision seemed to increase incrementally, events such as the Liberal reforms constituted jolts forward, perhaps dragged along by public opinion. Similarly, the emergency circumstances created between the wars left little room for change which was gradual; later, there would be another jolt forward with the creation of the Welfare State. As to how limited or otherwise this change was, I have already discussed the problematic nature of this term, but I think that when applied to how much change there was, it is inaccurate; in 1830 Britain had a system of providing for its poor based on the whims of tyrannical overseers handing out 'outdoor relief' to save the poorest from starvation, and in 1939 we had a centralised, means-tested system well on its way to becoming the State that we know today. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics essays


    The Midlands and the South suffered much less. If one was in employment, one could afford the cheaper food and the 'luxuries' such as vacuum cleaners etc. What measures did the government adopt to deal with the effects of the depression? * A return to protection - tariffs were put on goods coming into the country.

  2. To what extent were the changes in the size of the electorate the key ...

    The industry houses would be purposely tough, with strict discipline and long hours, in the hope of discouraging people from entering in the first place. Given that there would be no outdoor relief; this was intended to encourage people to apply the middle class principle of self help, and to find a means out income beyond poor relief.

  1. How significant was the role of individuals in the changing for the poor between ...

    ideas didn't spread outside of New Lanark, the reason for this is that many business men didn't share his ideas and thought of it as a burden to a business. This shows that his impact was minimal in alleviating poverty within Britain, and I believe that he probably actually had

  2. How did the elderly fare in welfare terms under the English New Poor Law?

    during the 1830's and 1840's would not have existed without the advent of the Industrial Revolution. Poor relief and urbanisation are inseparable; a socio political explosion of the previous centuries of history. As the British social historian Paul Mantoux (1961:477)

  1. "England experienced fundamental changes in the Political and Social life of the Nation" To ...

    Older children were set a maximum of 12-hour days. The Factory Act pressed through government by a combined force of Evangelicals and Utilitarian's was the first step by the British government to educate and protect children and marked a change in attitude toward children with the realisation that they marked the future.

  2. Death is Part of the Process

    She was distraught to find out she could never dance again so she decided to follow in her father's footsteps and become a police trainee. She turned over to read the sports section at the back of the newspaper. A young man with short, light-brown hair and a pleasant, boyish face stared back at her smiling.

  1. Do you agree with the view that the 1934 Poor Law Amendment Act applied ...

    However once the PLAA is introduced in 1934, the cost of Poor Relief reduces significantly, hence again suggesting that the PLAA did apply ‘sound principles’. However after 1844, the cost of Poor Relief rises with average expenditure rising to £5,290,000 and cost per head also increasing to 6s 2d.

  2. What was the impact of the Poor Law Amendment Act on the relief of ...

    It provided payments for a range of needs, or relief in kind such as clothing and food, with the intent of enabling the able-bodied poor to remain at home. The workhouse was described by the Cotton Times (2007) as "a public institution which housed and fed people who were unable to support themselves".

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work