• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critical analysis of journalist's work.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Critical analysis of journalist's work. The two pieces of journalism chosen for this analysis are Jeremy Clarkson's report on a short visit to Iraq 18 months on from the supposed end of the war there in 2003, and John Pilger's article concerning his arrival in, and initial experience of, Saigon during the Vietnam war in 1966. These two reports, and reporters, make a handy comparison. Although Jeremy Clarkson is viewed principally as motoring journalist he has the ability to adapt his journalistic skills to a range of subjects, some far removed from cars. For his motoring column in the Sunday Times Clarkson's style is humorous bordering on sarcasm, which works well and this style translates well to the subject of the controversial war in Iraq. The Sunday Times is a quality broadsheet newspaper aimed at the upper end of Britain's readership and is a market leader with an average Sunday sale of 1,395,046 copies, which represents a 50.58% share of this area of the market. Clarkson, being an out and out Conservative, is immediately identifiable with the readership of the Sunday Times, and his 'overgrown schoolboy' approach presents as a welcome relief amongst the principally serious editorials of the papers other journalists. ...read more.

Middle

At the same time the political background is also put into context in the same way, by mention of such nouns as Baghdad, Mr Blair, Gordon Brown, Mr Bush, Ramadan, Muslim. Comparison is made to previous conflicts by mention of Vietnam, another war of insurgency. At this point comparison can also be made of another journalists work in a similar field. John Pilger's report 'Dreamland', describing that journalist's arrival in Saigon during the conflict in Vietnam in 1966, makes a good parallel with Clarkson's description of his arrival in Baghdad. Again, the use of proper nouns gives context to the report, Caravelle, Chicago, Chevy's, Detroit, Ford, and Pontiac combine with Saigon, Vietnamese, Tan Son Nhut and Renault and Colonial piles to give an image of a country that has struggled to free itself from its colonial past only to be immersed in a 'war' which has become Americanised. The title, Dreamland, also has a double meaning. The Vietnamese that have succumbed to the dream of America's 'Coca-cola' society and capitalist prosperity, dream of becoming a part of the American 'dream', whilst the American military dream that they are winning. ...read more.

Conclusion

Compare these with Pilger's arrival in Saigon's "metallic jungle" in the "flaking Caravelle" to an airport outside of which "fat Fords" with their Vietnamese drivers barely visible and the two very different styles of journalism can be seen to follow at least some of the same formula. Both conflicts were dominated by American involvement; this is most evident in Vietnam but perhaps not so obvious with Iraq. Perhaps to emphasise this point Clarkson's report is, as previously mentioned, littered with connotations to America, a lot of which derogatory in response to the understanding that the United Kingdom was dragged into involvement in Iraq by the U.S., this is substantiated by such statements as: "Knuckle-dragging one eyed swamp-man from Buttsville, Iowa" or "Turbine powered gas (Americanisation of the word fuel) hogs" as well as the more obvious references to things that are immediately identifiable with America, items, such as Coca-cola or Marlboro reds. Attention is also drawn to the poor state of the military equipment or the quality of the personnel with comments such as: "...the tannoy system had obviously been salvaged from one of the railway stations Beeching closed down in 1963" and "...an adenoidal teenager" who "...said I didn't have a pass, and then failed to do anything about it". ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Explain how the Schlieffen Plan was meant to work?

    This could mean that in source I he might just be saying nice thing because he wants Haig's support; to back him for Prime Minister. Source J is written in the 1930's, by this time Lloyd George is retired and Haig has died; so he doesn't need anyone's support anymore and can say what he wants as Haig is dead.

  2. Moon Landing: Conspiracy or Reality?

    Even though, as shown in the previous paragraphs, conspiracy theorists have used many of these Apollo photos as examples of anomalies, every photo has a legitimate explanation. The skeptics ignore science and logic. With a better understanding of the moon and some basic photographic information, however, all these "errors" can be explained.

  1. Journalism - Two generations of the journalists - Soviet and the post-Soviet - make ...

    ...When a media-centred paradigm is replaced by a citizen-centred paradigm, one is also moving away from a functional approach to a critical (neo-Weberian) approach. ... More fundamentally, however, it was a paradigm shift away from an approach which understands media and journalists as the owners of communication rights and freedoms

  2. Political Analysis.

    were lying in wait for Britain, thus Britain faced an imminent danger which nearly destroyed her had America not come to her rescue by entering the Second World War. However, this time America did not enter the war to help Britain, but rather to colonise the world.

  1. Battle Analysis - Dong Ap Bia (Hamburger Hill).

    The Americans however had not been in Vietnam and had to adopt new tactics and doctrine to their war fighting. The U.S. had an alliance with South Vietnam during the war. Americans and South Vietnamese fought side by side in many of its battles.

  2. Why did Iraq invade Kuwait?

    Attacks on naval crafts continued throughout the war. A large number of Iraqi ships were sunk by Sea Skua missiles fired from Royal Navy Lynx helicopters. All the Kuwaiti patrol boats captured by the Iraqis were also destroyed. The Lynx/Sea Skua combination was very successful during this period.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work