• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Did the reds win the civil war, or did the whites loose it?

Extracts from this document...


Emma Dwyer Page 1 5/7/2007 Did the reds win the civil war, or did the whites loose it? History tells us the Bolsheviks (reds) did manage to eventually seize power over Russia in October 1920, however the question many historians ask is, 'did the reds win due to their careful planning, strength and unity, or was it purely down to the failures of their opposition, the whites?'. I will be looking at the possible answers to this question in this essay. The red army consisted of many different groups of people, old provisional government supporters, old tsarist soldiers, nationalists and separatists (who wanted independence) and basically anyone who hated the Bolsheviks and their ideas. The only thing they shared was a hatred for the reds, whereas the Bolsheviks all shared the same views. As you can imagine this made the Reds far more unified and a lot stronger than the whites. The whites could not agree on whether they were fighting for monarchism, republicism or for the Constituent Assembly. ...read more.


But with hindsight we realize this was for a reason. Due to the whites being associated with the old system of the tsarist government, who treated the public badly the whites lost the support of the nationalist groups and the peasants. Although the peasants did not have a strong support for either side, Lenin had legitimized their right to the land while the whites made it clear that land would be restored to its former owners. The support of the peasants was crucial since they supplied the main body of soldiers for both sides, so for the whites to loose their support was a large explanation for them eventually loosing the civil war. Another reason why the whites lost was because Denikin, one of the main white leaders did not see how valuable good propaganda was. The Bolsheviks however did, and used propaganda considerably well; they used imaginative and powerful images and played on the weaknesses of the whites that large majorities of the Russian population could identify with. ...read more.


The Bolsheviks obviously had the upper hand as the whites were scattered round the edges of this large area and found it hard to communicate with each other as they didn't have the up to date equipment the reds did. And even if they did often the white generals would not work together as they didn't trust each other or purely didn't like each other, many white generals were suspicious of Kolchak's motives and intentions. I believe this point shows how well organized the reds were in comparison to the whites and this is a good point to show why the reds beat them. I have tried to identify whether it was in fact the whites failures that made them loose the civil war or whether it was in fact purely down to the reds being an extremely good and well organized army. But I have found it impossible to pinpoint exactly which it was, as I believe it was down to many factors on both sides that led to the Bolsheviks gaining power, the geographical factors, unity and organization, leadership skills, and support all played a part into the Bolshevik victory of 1920. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. Why did the Bolsheviks win the Civil War

    would destroy all the achievements of the Revolution, break up the Soviets and bring back the old system. In this way, support for the Bolsheviks was organised and built up successfully. Also, the Bolsheviks were fighting for a very definite cause - the establishment and survival of a Communist Russia.

  2. Why Did the Bolsheviks Win the Russian Civil War?

    They also tried to get support from patriotic Russians by saying that the Whites were controlled by foreign invaders because of the western intervention - which was very important as these people may have been sympathetic towards the Whites because of the opposition to the Brest-Litovsk treaty.

  1. Why Did The Bolsheviks Win The Civil War?

    had favored it, asking how you can have a revolution without shooting people. The Bolsheviks drafted people into their armies, and Trotsky welded the new Red army into a disciplined fighting force. And in their fight against the anti-Bolshevik armies the Bolsheviks benefited from having let the peasants confiscate lands.

  2. Why did the Bolsheviks win the Civil War?

    The Whites had no chance of coming up with a good military strategy. Trotsky made sure that discipline was harsh in the Red Army, conscripts were often put to death for deserting. The soldiers and particularly the leaders were driven to win and only to win, this was achieved by taking their families hostage etc.

  1. Why did the Reds win the Civil War?

    In May, 1918, a group of soldiers in the Legion were falsely accused of killing a man in Chelyabinsk, in Siberia. The rest of the Czech unit marched into town and freed their comrades being held by local Red Guards.

  2. Why did the Bolsheviks win the Russian Civil War

    Against the drive and ruthless energy of the Bolsheviks, their campaigns faltered and they faced defeat and failure. By the end of 1920, the Bolsheviks were close to achieving total victory. There are several reasons for the failure of the White forces.

  1. Why Did The Bolsheviks Win The Civil War?

    He did this by holding their family's hostage. The White Army, because of there diversity wanted different things from this war. Because of this arguments started and they became immobile. The tactics of the Whites were hit them hard and fast in small fractions, this resulted in many hundred of thousands of White soldiers dying.

  2. Why did the reds win the civil war

    As soon as the first units of the Czechs surrendered their weapons, the Red Guards shot them. This was to prove a costly error, as it was obvious that the other men could not trust what Trotsky had promised. The Czech Legion was made up of experienced soldiers with plenty of fighting experience.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work