• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Does Peter I of Russia deserve the title 'The Great'?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Does Peter I of Russia deserve the title 'The Great'? Peter I of Russia was bestowed with the title 'The Great' in 1721 by Chancellor Golovkin. There are only three examples in European history of contemporaries being offered the same title: the Great Elector after he resurrected Brandenburg-Prussia from the Thirty Years War; Frederick the Great who turned Prussia into a European force and Catherine who built on Peter's progress, transforming Russia into the predominant power of Europe. Opinions as to whether Peter also deserve the title ' Great' has remained largely polarised. Lindey Hughes and Alex de Jonge argue that, on the whole, Peter does deserve the prestigious title. Anderson and Kliuchevsky disagree saying that Peter was largely a favour. This essay will argue that Peter does, in some respects, deserve the title whereas in others he does not, based on an examination of the different factors that could make a monarch 'Great': the grandeur of royalty, large scale political changes, the quality of his domestic rule, his popularity, military achievements and whether his reputation lasted. ...read more.

Middle

If he never used Frederick the Great's phrase 'the first servant of the state', he came very close t it when he struck out 'the interests of his Tsarist Majestry' from a draft decree and replaced it with 'the interests of the state' as a proper object of a soldier's loyalty. However, the statement of Peter being an enlightened monarch must be with caution. The Enlightenment is argued my some as not having met him and many of his reforms were generally introduced as a result of immediate necessity, rather than as part of a rational plan. The popularity of a monarch is regarded by some as being a prerequisite for being given the title 'Great'. Peter recognised that he lacked this, saying to a foreign ambassador 'I am represented as a cruel tyrant'. Traditional clergy saw Peter as an anti-Christ, while in the church in general there was distrust of his anti-clerical measures, secularization and westernisation program. The traditional nobility were alienated by the introduction of state service by the cost of war with Sweden and by the apparent westernization. ...read more.

Conclusion

Lastly, Peter's gain of the Baltic also resulted in the demise of Russia's traditional enemy, Sweden. Lastly, a monarch's 'greatness' can be found by assessing whether their reputation lasted after their death. At first he was the subject of a cult, proliferated by Feofan Prokopovich and later figures including Catherine the Great. During the nineteenth century views began to polarise. He was either the source of all Russian progress or a destroyer of tradition and culture. During the twentieth century views became even more ambivalent, he was portrayed on the one hand as the ultimate representative of the exploitative western system and on the other as one of the great heroes of Russian history who personally worked alongside his compatriots. Therefore, the impact of Peter the Great on Russian society and imagination is unbroken, his only serious rival being Lenin. Like Peter, Lenin's reputation was launched by the creation of a personality cult. But Lenin's cult was destroyed by the collapse of the ideology to which it was tied. Peter has now re-emerged as the key figure in Russian history as point symbolised in 1991 by the restoration to Leningrad of its original name, St Petersburg. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Historical Periods section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Historical Periods essays

  1. What was the impact of the Norman Conquest

    However, the Barons were not able to grant all the knights themselves, therefore they too shared their land, and gave a fraction of plots (manors) towards men who promised to serve as knights. The Baron often lived in a castle at the centre of his estates on his own province (demesne), whilst the knights stayed in their manors.

  2. The Enlightenment Essay

    "Francis Bacon is known for his association with empiricism, experiment and induction. He made careful observation of the natural world and collected as much data as possible and then he would draw conclusions or general laws" (Norton). Descartes' method took the opposite approach.

  1. Explain why peter the great wanted a window to the west

    Russia was in economic backwardness and by establishing a window to the west Peter would be able to learn western culture and change Russia for the better. Peter's window to the west would also bring in cultures such as shaving off of his nobles beards, this showed them that there

  2. The First English Civil War

    the field armies, being again face to face, and free to move. There followed a series of skilful manoeuvres in the Severn and Avon valleys. At the end, the Parliamentary army gained a long start on its homeward road via Cricklade, Hungerford and Reading.

  1. Why Was King Alfred So Great?

    He primarily looked to strengthen the Navy so as to ensure protection from any potential invaders, as well as discouraging any raids from Northumbrian Vikings. Alfred in fact, designed and implemented the construction of an innovative style of ship that was 'swifter, steadier and also more responsive than the others'3.

  2. Kit Kittredge and the great depression

    Because her father owned a car dealership and they lived in a beautiful house in Cincinnati, Ohio, Kit felt as if life during the Great Depression would not affect her that much. Kit wasn't as right as she thought she was.

  1. Assess the political, social and cultural significance of Versailles in the reign of Louis ...

    everything at Versailles evolved around Louis), and designed to accommodate enormous crowds of people who came to witness his lever and coucher. Behind all of this was one gigantic propaganda machine at work. The machine performed one function: to make people respect Louis.

  2. To What Extent Was Russia Modernised During the Personal Reign of Peter the Great? ...

    Russian Orthodox Church says that if men allow their beards to grow they look more like Jesus and therefore devoted to God, they also believed that by shaving off your beard you were quite feminine. To try and get the Russian people to conform to this reform Peter began to

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work