• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Does the film 'The Battle of The Somme' provide us with a realistic picture of what it was like to be a British soldier in the trenches?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Does the film 'The Battle of The Somme' provide us with a realistic picture of what it was like to be a British soldier in the trenches? The film 'The Battle of The Somme' was released in London on the 10th of August 1916, it was a famous documentary that was filmed by Geoffrey Malins and J.B. McDowell. They were one of the first groups of cameramen to film the British soldiers on the Battlefields of the Western Front. They helped the government to produce a video, to show people that War wasn't as bad as it seemed. It was however a silent film and so captions had to be use to explain what the next section of the film was going to show. The film gave us an insight into what the life of a soldier would be like. Many historians have argued over whether this video is an accurate and reliable source of information and hopefully this will be resolved. The film however may not be reliable and trustworthy because the shots may have been fixed and set-up, they were also the opinions of only one person, so if they felt that everything was great, this would then show in what they took pictures of. ...read more.

Middle

Some sources also imply that the British tactics worked well because in the information gathered from Newspapers it shows that many parts of the German trenches were destroyed by heavy gunners. However, other sources challenge the images put forward in the film. Many sources imply that the tactics used by the Brits were useless because they killed their own men, for example many British soldiers and civilians were killed when the gas attack on the Germans went wrong, they didn't plan for the the wind direction changing. In addition some sources state that many soldiers were killed because gunners had made the wire in front of the trenches even worse by firing the wrong type of shells, this shows bad leadership and using very poor tactics, thus the troops couldn't get over the barbed wire into the trenches. Overall I believe that the evidence indicates that the film provides an unrealistic picture of how well the British tactics worked. This is mainly due to the fact that several sources mention that the British tactics didn't work and that many men were slaughtered by the Germans. However these sources may not have been reliable as they could have only given the view of one person. ...read more.

Conclusion

The tactics generally worked although many British soldiers died, generally everything ran smoothly. Some of the sources I don't feel are totally trustworthy such as the information that is given by Newspapers and Photographs as these were both sets of information that the government controlled, they gave information to the Newspapers so that they could write their articles, however the government may have not given all the information to the Newspaper companies. The Newspapers also would write anything to make the paper sell to the public. Many of the Photographs look like they may have been staged or set up, so these two sources are rather unreliable. Life in the trenches appears to be pretty gruesome because there are dead bodies lying around and massive War going on outside, there is the fear that you will never see your family and friends again. Historians have been arguing for years over whether or not the film 'The Battle of the Somme' is a realistic view of what actually happened in World War I. There has been no outright decision to whether it is a realistic view or not, and historians will continue to debate over whether or not it is a reliable source to show what life was like for the British soldiers in the trenches. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

The author makes a thorough examination of the film here and compares it with a wide range of other sources. At times, more knowledge using examples and statistics would have enabled the author to judge accuracy more. The conclusion could be more definite.

Marked by teacher Natalya Luck 10/04/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Why did the U.S lose the Vietnam War?

    This had huge effects on the American people and this sparked a massive outrage among the U.S citizens and 400 more protests/strikes took place across the United States and universities. The public opinion of war became more intense on the president when many started to refuse to fight in Vietnam.

  2. Creative Writing - War.

    It was on its way to a Japanese base. The jungle provided an excellent division between us; a marvellous camouflage for them. I wasn't na�ve in thinking that these Japs pitied me. They hadn't killed me, because they desired to execute all of us, one by one at their headquarters.

  1. How was civilian life affected by WW1?

    bill was passed allowing women over the age of 33 the right to vote. In 1916, the government passed another law known as 'the military service act' this made all men between 18 and 40 eligible for active service. This was due to the decreasing amount of people volunteering to enlist in the war.

  2. Can War Be Justified?

    war must be a last resort; that war cannot only be waged to do a moral deed such as saving the innocent, but it must be done for the right motives too; that the evils a war is fighting must be bad enough to justify killing; and that it is

  1. What were the Causes and Consequences of the Crimean War?

    For the other countries the consequences varied, Napoleon's prestige was enhanced and the French became directly involved in with Italian unification but they overlooked the expansion of Prussia, also the number of casualties for the French lost 95,0002. Russia were lucky as they escaped quite lightly merely because of the sheer size of the country.

  2. To what extent did the foreign intervention influence the outcome of the Spanish Civil ...

    Throughout the regions in Spain, there were many differences such as differences between traditions and dialect, which caused tensions between people from the different regions. However, the most important crosscurrents were between the archbishops and priests in the Church and the officers and soldiers in the army.

  1. Who was responsible for the start of the Cold war?

    policy was affected by the Atomic bomb and as a result this synopsis is debatable. The nuclear attack on Japan did ultimately create new tensions between East and West yet to many historians for instance Francis Fukuyama, the Cold war is seen not as a war in conventional terms but

  2. Could the American War of Independence Have Been Avoided?

    Many of these limitations led to other long-term grievances within the individual colonies, each colony was used by Britain for different purposes and objected to the treatment they received. New England resented being made a dumping ground for British produce.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work