• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Domestic pressure rather than events in Asia governed the USA's intervention in, and conduct of, the conflict in Korea

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Domestic pressure rather than events in Asia governed the USA's intervention in, and conduct of, the conflict in Korea." How far do you agree with this view? On the 25th of June 1950, the communist North Korea (Democratic Peoples Republic of Korea) invaded the capitalist South Korea (Republic of Korea). Within two days, USA, the world's most powerful country, became involved in a civil war of a small Asiatic country. One of the main reasons USA became involved in the war were the domestic pressures Truman administration was under. However, other factors, such as events in Asia, international pressure and the concept of the Cold war context governed USA's involvement and conduct of the war. After the World War Two, America found itself in ideological and economic conflict with its one time ally, Russia. Nazism was replaced with Communism, and Stalin replaced Hitler. American propaganda vilified communism to the maximum, and the Truman administration was under pressure not to appear "soft on communism". This was especially true due to the repeated attacks by the Republicans on Truman. Spy scandals such as Algar Hiss case and the Rosenberger's added to general paranoia created by Senator McCarthy, a Republican. Truman was determined not become a victim of McCarthyism and to appear decisive in the war against communism. ...read more.

Middle

He also learned that appeasing aggressors never worked, and in his eyes Kim Il Sung was nothing more than Stalin's puppet. And that, arguably, is the most important reason why USA became involved. Americans saw Korean War in the Cold war context. To them everything that happened in the world was the result of the conflict between capitalist and communist. Due to their monolithic view of Communism, they were convinced that Kim was fighting on the orders of Stalin. Because of this they could not afford to lose anything - cold war was zero-sum game. Losing Korea would be unacceptable if they wanted to win the Cold war. Domestic pressures and events in Asia, as well influencing USA's decision to become involved in the war, had a tremendous impact on the conduct of the war. Although the expedition to Korea was nominally UN venture, the armed forces were dominantly American under the command of General MacArthur. As such, majority of the decisions were American. Previous events in Asia affected the opening stages of the war. Truman distrusted Sigmund Rhee, president of the Republic of Korea, and as such refused to give military weapons and support to Korea. USSR reinforced DPRK army had no problem in driving poorly armed ROK back into the Posen pocket. ...read more.

Conclusion

However, in addition to these arguments, there is strong indication that the Cold War context played a significant role in the conduct of the war. This is demonstrated by the continuing argument between the USA and Chinese forces over the treatment of Prisoners of War. Under Geneva convection, after cease of hostilities, all PoWs were to be returned to their forces. USA however, found that many Chinese and North Korean soldiers did not wish to return. They considered this a major propaganda victory if it can be used. As such, they refused to surrender all the PoWs, resulting in continuing of hostilities long after it was necessary. This event indicates that American's considered Korea just a steppingstone in the Cold war. To them, the propaganda victory was more important than ending the war. They wanted to win the Cold War, not so much the Korean War. From all the different factors, it can be determined that although domestic pressure had a great deal of influence over America's involvement and conduct of Korean War, it was not a prevailing factor. And, in spite of their importance, were the events in Asia. It was the Cold War context under which USA regarded the Korean War that was the primary influence on the USA behaviour. USA was aiming to win the cold war, and behaved with that aim in mind. ?? ?? ?? ?? Maja Jovanovski 07/05/2007 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Why did North Korea invade South Korea in June 1950, and why did USA ...

    USSR's and China's alignment was due to shared Communist ideology and also to increasing confrontation with USA. In August 1949, Stalin sent experts to China to advise in economic reconstruction and military expansionism. Stalin offered the PRC $300 million in loans.

  2. Korean propaganda during the Second World War and the Korean War had a different ...

    The words and actions of communism don't follow through. Independence, freedom, individualism, will build a stronger society. With the sixteen countries on our side to fight communism, we can defeat communism from spreading. These were basically the two sides of argument between the two Koreas that were causing friction.

  1. North Korea and South Korea after the Korean war.

    This along with the kidnapping of Kim Dae-Jung by the ROK intelligence service severd contact between the North and South until 1984.8 However, in 1984 when the South Korean experience tremendous flooding the North offered flood relief, igniting the flame of unification once more.

  2. Free essay

    The Korean War represented total defeat for the Truman Doctrine? H. Brogan. How far ...

    The Korean Military Advisory Group (KMAG) was established in the US in 1949, and although initially the US were unwilling to give up large quantities of weapons, in 1950 South Korea had 14 planes, a large army and 500 KMAG troops.

  1. The Arab-Israeli conflict.

    However western government could not just wait in the hope for oil to be in its normal price, but had to start looking at substitute sources of energy. Coal, gas, hydroelectricity and nuclear power came to be dependable on, though the oil weapon had not completely lost its value.

  2. Free essay

    Do you consider military intervention in Africa as successful? Focus on the policies in ...

    The war in Mozambique, unlike that in Namibia, was a classic example of the extremely muddled kind of conflict, part domestic, part international, part ethnic, part ideological, and militarily irresolvable. It should have given way to a peace settlement which, no matter how fragile it may be, has so far

  1. The Korean war and the conflict between North and South.

    division.3 The Russians, who moved into North Korea were seen as liberators, after Japan's 36 year rule of the land. On,August,26, 1945, the Japanese officially surrendered in North Korea and power was handed over to the provincial people's committee which had emerged in Korea.4The Russians didn't seek to rule Korea directly but through this comitee.

  2. Red Scare and USA domestic policy in the 50´s.

    Furthermore, American spies reported to President Truman that Stalin was using the Cominform to help communists gain power in Malaya, Indonesia, Burma, the Philippines and Korea. Truman and the Americans watched this with increasing anxiety. They thought that communist countries were acting together to spread communism.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work