• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluate the view that overproduction of goods was the most important reason for the collapse in US economy from October 1929

Extracts from this document...


Evaluate the view that overproduction of goods was the most important reason for the collapse in US economy from October 1929 On October 24th 1929 the share stock exchanged fell and the American economy faced its most serious economic obstacle. The traditional view of the event is that the Wall Street Crash caused the depression, however there are other interpretations which suggest otherwise. There is evidence which proves that the economy started to crumble much earlier than October 1929. America had other serious social and economic problems which were responsible for the collapse. The period of 1920s was well known for its rapid boom in the economy and in industry, which caused a change in the American life style. However, closer analysis of the decade reveals many difficulties, which America failed to solve. The overproduction of goods in the country was very significant as it was linked with other problems, however it was directly dependant on other factors, such as the set up of the banking system and the widely available buying on credit, which both largely contributed to the crash in 1929. There are other schools of thoughts which suggest that it was the widely popular speculation on the market which was responsible. ...read more.


.Economic historians, like JK Galbraith, support this view and argue that the republicans were mishandling the economy. The government allowed banks too much freedom and had no real way of controlling the transactions that took place. As a result the authorities had a limited idea of what was happening in the economy. The government also took some fatal steps, like introducing the Daws plan in 1924and Young plan 1929 which reduced the amount of reparations that Germany had to pay back. As result less money was being pumped back to America. Lack of effective government actions is the most significant reason for the collapse of the economy, because it failed to solve many problems and caused new ones, which also had damaging effects on the economy. The set up of the backing system and the new availability of loans fueled the increase of the value of the stock market, but at the same time also contributed to its collapse. Although the government was partially responsible for regulating the system, a Federal Reserve board was set up which was to ensure efficient control of the transactions. The setup of the banking finances was flawed. The federal banks were joined together and prepared to support each other in a crisis; however the smaller state banks, used by the majority of the population, did not co-operate. ...read more.


Hoover failed to effectively address the question of overproduction. Therefore, Hoover's actions had two different sides to them, they were intending to help but at the same time were an important reason for the collapse of the economy in 1929. Overall, historical evidence presents us with various reasons for the crash in October. Although some historians agree that overproduction was an important reason for the collapse of the economy, it was the lack of effective governmental control which was more crucial. Even though, overproduction was a serious problem, it was dependent on other factors, hence making it less important. As argued by Tindal and Shi, as well as JK Galbraith government misguided the population about the state of the economy and allowed banks too much freedom, which led to to other problems. Had the government introduced more regulations for the banking system, the rapid raise of use of the hire-purchase scheme would not have been possible, and overproduction would not have been encouraged so extensively. In addition, if less credit, allowed by government, was offered by the banks, less people would have bought on the margin and the value of the economy would have been more accurate. This demonstrates that although numerous aspects contributed to collapse of the economy, the involvement of government, or perhaps the lack of it, was at the centre of it all, making it the most important reason. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level History of the USA, 1840-1968 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level History of the USA, 1840-1968 essays

  1. "Poland was the most important factor in the deteriorating US-Soviet relations"

    Due to the upcoming American election in 1944, Roosevelt advocated democracy to appeal to the American public and tried to retrieve what had been given to Stalin at previous meetings at Yalta. Furthermore, he misled his nation into thinking that Stalin had consent to a democratic state of Poland.

  2. a) "How far do these sources support the view expressed in source one that, ...

    The primary sources (source two, four, and five), overall, have an unbalanced view of William I and his tactics for establishing peace in England. The main drawback to most of the sources is the lack of facts during the years 1065 and 1075.

  1. End of a tragedy - The road to Appomattox.

    The controversy would be short lived as no proof would ever be presented. So with Columbia, Charleston, and Augusta all fallen, Sherman would continue his drive north toward Goldsboro. On the way, his progress would be stalled not by the Confederate army but by runaway slaves.

  2. The Great Depression, causes and effects.

    After the war the Treaty of Versailles was formed which stated Germany must pay war reparation, however it was unable to do so and so the major industrial area, the Ruhr Valley was taken over by France. The French eventually moved out after pressure was placed to do so, USA leant the German government money to rebuild their economy.

  1. To what extent do you agree with the statement that The US Economic Boom ...

    Harding and Coolidge increased the profits that the wealthy had to invest in future development - providing more jobs and therefore reigniting the American economy. The declaration of the Fordney-MCumber tariff, reinforced the idea of Protectionism and therefore in the short - term could be viewed to have contributed to

  2. President Hoover and the Great Depression

    He saw the Great Depression as an opportunity for 'priming the pump'. He sought to achieve economic restoration through policies that, he initially hoped, would maintain purchasing power. The ramifications of this would be to preserve and nourish demand in the long-term, thereby preventing the repetition of economic crashes and downturns.

  1. The USA was hit by the Great Depression in 1929 because of increasing restrictions ...

    Therefore, once the remaining 40% had bought all the goods they wished to buy there would be no one left to sell to, which in return would result in a downward spiral throughout the USA of a lack of spending and thus unemployment causing the US to hit the Great Depression.

  2. Prohibition - The Importance of January 16th 1920 to the US.

    The weaknesses would cause nationwide infringements of the Volstead Act and drive the industry of alcohol into back corners and basements, later known as ?Speakeasies and bootleggers? (National Archives). After the 18th amendment and Volstead Act were passed, oppositions were rolling through the courts with numerous cases in regards to prohibition.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work