• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Henry VII's only real achievement was to pass the crown onto his son" ~ How far do you agree with this view?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Henry VII's only real achievement was to pass the crown onto his son" ~ How far do you agree with this view? Henry VII reign as King in Tudor England is often seen as a precarious and unstable one. England was left largely isolated by 1509 and the lack of foreign victories also contributed to Henry becoming unpopular. However, he left the crown solvent, proving stability for Henry VIII and the transition of the crown was both smooth and unquestionable. The reign of Henry VII is seen as a major turning point in English history; the pivot of change between medieval and early modern periods. It is evident that passing the crown onto his son was a major accomplishment and in this essay I will look the significance of this achievement as well as also looking into Henry VII's other achievements and failures throughout his reign. By the beginning of the 16th century, the Henry VII's prestige in Europe and his security at home were assured. He had survived the ambitions of pretenders to the throne and was strong in central government and generally obeyed throughout the realm. He was successful in foreign war even though he wasn't absolutely heroic in the eyes of his subjects. ...read more.

Middle

. Maximilian, annoyed by the Kings treachery in making the Treaty of Etaples without his agreement, also joined Warbeck in his conspiracies against the King to get his own back, but lacked the money to fit out a proper invasion force for Warbeck. Warbeck also gained support from Scotland (James IV). The age-old traditional warfare between neighboring kingdoms was a threat the Tudor monarch could not be ignored. Peasants from the south-west who had been disturbed by the Cornish rebellion in 1497 also supported Warbeck. In 1497 Warbeck was captured, but his influence was immensely strong and reached into the Royal Court. He might have been awarded the same mercy as Simnel (who now worked in the royal kitchens) had he not tried to escape from prison in the Tower. Henry could not afford now to let him live, and he was executed in 1499. As well as the conspiracies made against him, Henry also fought in the Battle of Stoke (1487) to secure the throne. It is the strengths in all these achievements that made it possible for Henry to pass on the throne Passing on the throne was an immense achievement, but Henry VII did also accomplish other achievements of value. ...read more.

Conclusion

The issue of the crown being passed over in such a smooth transition as a huge achievement is also questionable. No other Tudor monarch died without being in debt and yet this had not diminished their reputations. Perhaps Henry was lucky to die when he did. By the end of his reign he was deeply unpopular and the severity of the rebellion was mearly a matter of time. Henry VII was again fortunate that his son was old and wise enough to accept and maintain the throne. It could be debated whether or not Henry VII was a great King, but he was clearly a successful King. He had several goals that he had accomplished by the end of his reign. He had established a new dynasty after 30 years of struggle, he had strengthened the judicial system as well as the treasury and had successfully denied all the other claimants to his throne. The monarchy that he left to his son was a fairly secure one and most definitely a wealthy one. It is clear that Henry VII had to work harder to keep the throne and pass it over than other Kings, and his loyalty and thoroughness were perhaps his personal qualities which allowed him to keep the crown in the Lancastrian dynasty. Francesca Baggs October 2003 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics essays

  1. Essay: How serious was the Yorkist threat to Henry VII?

    Warbeck turned to Margaret of Burgundy, who yet again becomes involved in plots against Henry and she teaches him in the ways of the Yorkists. This already proves to be a very serious threat from the Yorkists as Warbeck has support yet again from Burgundy and foreign support is increased

  2. Assess the validity of the view that the Rump and Barebones parliaments had no ...

    Out of the 211MPs, 50 or so were lawyers. Of the 60-70MPs who attended daily, the main single group to do so was the lawyers. "Such men were naturally reluctant to undertake changes that would weaken their privileges" (Lynch). Thus, such self-interest would undermine the argument that the Rump made any major achievements.

  1. Was Lambert Simnel a greater threat to the security of Henry VII than Perkin ...

    But how Henry reacted with Simnel at the end shows how much of a little threat he was on his own as Henry could afford to be merciful and made Simnel into a turnspit in the kitchen. Even though Simnel on his own and his threat wasn't necessarily a great

  2. Explain why Perkin Warbeck remained a threat to the security of Henry VII for ...

    Threats in military terms from Perkin Warbeck during this period may be largely attributed to foreign support. Indeed, Warbeck potentially had concern also from nobility such as Sir William Stanley, as Margaret of Burgundy, sister of Edward IV, proclaimed him as her long-lost nephew.

  1. Securing the Tudor Dynasty: The Reign of Henry VII.

    "Henry, and his heirs and successors". This supports the statement that Henry is looking out for his Tudor dynasty against threats towards them. d) How useful are these sources to a historian studying the importance of royal marriages to the stability of the monarchy in the reign of Henry VII?

  2. This essay examines the actions of Charles VII in relation to events pertaining to ...

    Motivated by jealousy, they undermined her missions hoping a failure would diminish the threat she presented.4 The Dauphin delayed his departure for Rheims rather than relenting to the wishes of Joan; Charles hoped to appear as though he dominated Joan rather than being the submissive sovereign benefiting from her glory.5

  1. How serious a threat did the pretenders pose to Henry VII's crown?

    of unknown profession, Simnel had a striking resemblance to Richard, Duke of York but with rumours circulating about Edward, Earl of Warwick, Simnel claimed to be him. The idea of becoming a pretender was initially pushed upon Simnel by his teacher Richard Symonds.

  2. Was Henry VII a successful monarch?

    The rebels landed in June 1487 but before they had a chance to consolidate their forces. Henry met and defeated them at the battle of Stoke on 16th June (when the Earl of Lincoln was killed). Four years later, however, a new imposter was put forward.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work