• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How important was Lenin in bringing about the Bolshevik revolution of November 1917?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How important was Lenin in bringing about the Bolshevik revolution of November 1917? After March 1917, the Russian revolution was yet to be completed. The Tsar had been overthrown, the power and responsibility of the government of Russia had been passed on 'duelly' to the Provincial Government and the workers Soviet, the most powerful Soviet in Petrograd. In November 1917, the second revolution was planned, a Bolshevik revolution. Evidence around the Bolshevik revolution is not completely reliable, but it is widely agreed that events in November 1917 were not as the Bolsheviks later described and boasted. Soviet censored films, art and literature after 1917 record an incredibly contradictory image of the November revolution than the picture that is the truth. In Eisenstein's film 'October' that was made in 1927, the storming of the Winter Palace where the Provincial Government were, was shown as a heroic, brave, but a violent struggle of the Russian masses overcoming a government that they thought had no interest in the people's wishes. The film portrays the Russian spirit standing up against hunger, war and laws that prevented peasants from owning land, and how it was by their sheer will and force that the government was overthrown. This myth perhaps continues into the role of Lenin in the Bolshevik revolution. In the film 'October', Lenin is portrayed as an inspiring, courageous, all great leader who was followed by thousands of Russians. This is simply not the complete real case. As one witness describes; "I heard shouting in the street of Lenin! Lenin!, but we had no idea who this Lenin was." ...read more.

Middle

First of all, they decided to continue the War against Germany; a War that Russia was already loosing badly in. Minister's thought if better managed, the War could swing in their favour, but they were wrong. In June, Kerensky ordered a new Offensive, continuing the concentration of factories on producing ammunitions, not food. People in the cities and all over Russia had to live with increasing food shortages and inflation was high, as it had been just before the Tsar was taken from power. Conditions were worse than ever. The June Offensive turned into a military disaster and thousands of discontented soldiers - urged by Bolsheviks - left the front and returned home. People hence rejected Kerensky and turned to other parties, such as the Bolsheviks that promised reliable conditions and food. The second main mistake was the decision by the Provincial Government to disallow land reform. All over Russia, peasants were taking advantage of the messy and uncoordinated political circumstances by taking land and property from the rich nobles, as much as they could. The government refused to make this legal, claiming they did not have the right as they didn't belong to an elected institution. However if they had recognised the mobs of peasants, then Russia might have fallen into an unlawful chaotic riotous country. The decision to not make land reforms legal gave more reasons for soldiers to desert at the front, most of them were peasants, and claim their own land. It also made the Provincial Government very unpopular with the slowly starving peasants, whose mass made up nearly all of the Russian population. ...read more.

Conclusion

He was only involved in the revolution after he returned from exile in April, given pass by the Germans who thought he might be able to overthrow the Provincial Government. He was organised and knew what he wanted and was encircled by loyal followers like Trotsky who proved invaluable. It is true that some main ideas came from other men, but Lenin was ultimately responsible for his Party and its actions. He was in exile for some months of 1917, and the circumstances that Russia was facing gave the Bolshevik party a huge boost. It was Lenin though who insisted that they had to overthrow the Provincial government by force and that they do it soon. It was Lenin's April Theses, for a while unsupported, that outlined in the end how the Bolsheviks gained a lot of support. I believe however, it was not just Lenin and Trotsky that brought around the Bolshevik revolution. The Provincial Government helped the Bolsheviks gain support by their mistakes and gave the Bolsheviks fuel to use against them. Other parties were disorganised and the people were induring food shortages and bad conditions, they had little else to turn to. On the night of the November revolution there was little resistance and only 1 in 600 Russians supported the Bolsheviks. However, it remains that Lenin knew he was going to die and he wanted to be alive to see the revolution. It was Lenin who insisted and pushed the Bolsheviks into motion. I think he was an important factor in the November 1917 revolution, but there were many other factors that allowed the Bolshevik revolution to take place. Alone he could not have made the revolution happen, but it was all other contributing events that brought the revolution together. Alice Gibbs 11N History Coursework 27/9/01 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. Lenin and the Bolshevik revolution.

    He occupied no state office, and thus was unprotected from competition. At any rate, his own abrupt seizure of power from Kerensky demonstrates that the occupation of state office was a small enough protection in those turbulent days. Lenin did occupy an important party office, which did amount to a

  2. Russia 1905-1941 'Explain how the unpopularity of the Provisional Government contributed to the Bolshevik ...

    The Provisional Government was on the brink of losing all support to the Bolsheviks. Karl Marx the idealist in whom Marxism evolved from believed in three different forms of society in which Russian society would be based upon. The first was the feudal system which was prominent in Russian society.

  1. Russian Revolution Sources Questions

    Therefore the source would not be totally trustworthy as Trotsky's opinion would be biased and keen to frame Stalin in a bad light. Source K is part of a biography written about Stalin in the 1970s. The source states, 'What was striking about the General Secretary was that there was nothing striking about him'.

  2. Assess the reasons why the Russian Revolution of 1917 ended in victory for the ...

    They knew that they may lose in the upcoming election and so, in order to maintain the government's authority, they continued with Russia's participation in the great war. They did nothing to improve Russia's condition except for a few issues such as released the political prisoners and, freedom of speech and religion.

  1. How realistic are POW films?

    This also seems very realistic as in source A1 it describes the clothes as 'dirty' I know that POW amps had many shortages such as toilet paper, anaesthetic, be clothing and everyday clothing, showing that it would be unlikely to have more than one set of clothing.

  2. Assess the importance of the Soviets to the Bolshevik seizure of power in 1917.

    such as 'peace, land and bread', in the April Theses which naturally appealed to the peasants and the workers welcomed the Bolsheviks' slogan 'All power to the Soviets'. We see them gaining support as the member of the party increase from 10,000 in February to 200,000 in October.

  1. Europe In revolution

    That's where the people start thinking of nationalism and liberalism as the wanted reform. There were the political ideas which led to revolutions in Europe. Nationalist demanded that people which shared a common culture based on language, race or religion should have their own unification or independent nationalist wars and

  2. How significant was Lenin between the years 1902-1918 to the formation of the Bolshevik ...

    who were manifested within the Bolsheviks.17 It was claimed at the time, by Kerensky, that Kornilov wished to set up a military dictatorship and this was just his cover. However, Kornilov maintained that it?s his ?job?to save Russia (from the Bolsheviks and Germany)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work