• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How successful was Charles I as king of Spain?

Extracts from this document...


How successful was Charles I as king of Spain? It is difficult to judge the success of Charles on the overall governing of Spain, as many decisive factors including the amount of land gained and loss as well as the financial situation and the degree of opposition and how it was dealt with, are all important to consider in answering this statement and all do vary to certain extents throughout his reign. Religious unity in Spain as well as the marriage alliances formed in this period should be taken into account when forming a thorough conclusion and also the variation in activity over the years of his rule The absence of social political and religious conflict is striking in the context of European history of the time and at certain times in Charles' reign this does seem to have been the case. Historians often focus more on dramatic upheaval and disturbance in the past and less on stability and peace. However, a balanced assessment of Charles's reign as King of Spain must explore the origins of Spain's political stability and Charles's contribution to it. In Charles early years as king he faced many serious revolts and the period from 1516-1522 is commonly regarded by historians as a critical period in the reign of the Emperor Charles V as King Charles I of Spain. However he did manage to preserve his authority and much of his land suggesting that Charles government at least at this time and in this aspect was quite successful. ...read more.


Finally, the Crown tried to ensure the loyalty of the representatives of the towns at the Cortes by bestowing upon them favours and patronage. It can be argued, therefore, that an important factor in explaining Spain's political stability after 1522 was the triumph of royal authority over the Castilian towns and over the Castilian Cortes. This was, perhaps, the most important legacy of the Comuneros revolt. it has been argued that Charles's partnership with the Castilian nobility- was one of the major pillars of his success in ruling Spain. The Castilian nobility enjoyed substantial advantages under Charles. Their pride was flattered and their self-interest satisfied as Charles increasingly loosened his ties with his Burgundian lands and put Spain at the centre of his empire. Castilian nobles found lucrative employment in the running of Charles's empire. In addition, Charles exempted the nobilities- from the heaviest tax burdens. The absenteeism of the monarch also provided opportunities for the nobility to consolidate and advance their own interests. During the Comuneros revolt the nobility had proved their value to the Crown in the maintenance of effective royal government. In its aftermath, Charles was careful to avoid offending them. But the victory of the nobility over the Comuneros rebels brought them into a longer-term alliance with a monarchy much strengthened in its own right. Success and stability in Spain depended also on the absence of religious division. Under Charles, Spain presented a unified Church, committed to Catholic orthodoxy. ...read more.


Like the alcabala, this was to be a tax on consumers payable by all. A general Cortes was called at which the Castilian nobility as well as the towns were represented. The nobility refused to approve the new tax. Charles dropped the sisa, aware of the value of a loyal nobility to the successful governing of his kingdom. Charles was constantly spending more than he received on revenues and an increasing proportion of his revenues had to used to finance his debts and this was the state that his royal finances remained in until the end of his reign and by the year 1557, the year after his ascension, Philip II was forced to suspend all payments from the Castilian treasury and to convert the Crowns debts into juros. Spain, and in particular Castile, paid a heavy price for Charles's financial administration. This extensive borrowing caused enormous damage to the Spanish economy in the longer term and fed price inflation. It can perhaps be concluded that although many he faced many difficulties and there is a degree of failure in some aspects of his ruling, e.g. the financial depression he left Spain in, and the delegation of authority to his deputies, he maintained a considerable degree of personal control and that he did succeed in enlarging his power during his time as king of Spain. He experienced his greatest success when he was able to work with political elites, and, in particular with the Spanish nobility and overall his governing in most areas of his rule was largely successful. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics essays

  1. This essay examines the actions of Charles VII in relation to events pertaining to ...

    career as well as a tool in grasping the idea of the war as a whole. The results of Joan's victories are slightly touched upon, but not with much depth. Perroy, Edouard. The Hundred Years War. New York: Capricorn Books, 1965.

  2. Was Charles I Trying to Establish Royal Absolutism during his Personal Rule?

    It is unfair to say that Arminianism in the 1630s was completely Catholic: it was not "Catholicism under another name". Rather, it was a balance between the established Church of England and Catholicism. For instance, when the later duke of Newcastle, William Cavendish, broke his horse's neck when riding on

  1. How was Isabella able to secure her succession to the Castilian throne in 1469-1479?

    Therefore, before even becoming Queen, it was imperative that she had them on her side, away from Joanna. Originally, only a few grandee families supported Isabella's cause. It was not until 1470, four years before Isabella became Queen, that opinion switched.

  2. Edward Woodstock, Lanuedoc and Poitiers campaigns.

    The betrayal by Navarre also set back Lancaster's attack in Normandy until the following year.

  1. Warner Bros.' GoodFellas (1990) is director Martin Scorsese's stylistic masterpiece - a follow-up film ...

    You don't know who he's with...Normal people don't act like this." ["Leader of the Pack," performed by The Shangri-Las.] At a party hosted by Jimmy's wife Mickey (Julie Garfield), Karen grasps how different and exclusive is the world she has married and entered into.

  2. The revolt of the Comuneros had more to do with the historical internal divisions ...

    An increase of taxes took place, which together with their unequal incidence among different classes, was to have bad effects in the long run. The increase in governmental activity brought the growth of a bureaucracy with the abuses inherent in such bodies.

  1. Why was Religion not a Major Problem for Charles I as Ruler Of Spain ...

    The interests of Spain and the Holy Roman Empire did not always relate and the reason that religion was not much of a problem for Spain between 1516 - 1558 was distance. The German struggle with Protestants seemed a distant threat and would never corrupt Spain.

  2. Assess the significance of Owain Glyndwr's revolt

    Henry IV so it?s argued that these recognition treaties are worthless without the acknowledgement of the English King. One thing that is clear from studying the events of Owain Glyndwr?s rebellion is that it paved the way for Lancastrian dominance.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work