• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In both world wars, many enemy aliens were interned in Australia

Extracts from this document...


In both world wars, many enemy aliens were interned in Australia. Were the Australian Governments in each war responding to real threats of internal subversion and spying or were these Governments responding to the surge in narrow race patriotism and the fears of the general community? Your answer must make reference to examples from both world wars. At the outbreak of both World Wars many people of an alien nature in Australia were interned into protective custody. As an example during the First World War 6,890 Germans were interned, of whom 4,500 were Australian residents before 1914; the rest were sailors from German navy ships or merchant ships who were arrested while in Australian ports when the war broke out, or German citizens living in British territories in South-East Asia and transported to Australia at the request of the British Government. Some internees were temporary visitors trapped here when the war began. About 1,100 of the total were Austro-Hungarians, and of those around 700 were Serbs, Croats and Dalmatians from within the Austro-Hungarian Empire who were working in mines in Western Australia. The government's overriding rhetoric for this action was the social cohesion of Australian society in a time of war1. Both Pam MacLean2 and Kate Darian-Smith3 argue that the early responses of government were for conformity and a united goal in a time of war, termed 'equality of sacrifice' and 'equality of service'. Darian-Smith4 commenting on the Second World War further states that that this conformity was achieved through censorship, coercion, sweeping legislative powers contained in the Commonwealth War Book and enforced through National Security Regulations, and propaganda. One facet of the propaganda used was the circulating of warnings that there was an enemy within our society; the spy, the saboteur, the secret agent. ...read more.


It is the contention of this paper that the super structure needing to mobilise its war effort resorted to the use of the xenophobic nature of the Australian populace to maintain social control. This point is supported by Gerhard Fischer when he states, "The internment system thus developed into a tool of social control"16. He argues that internment procedures had surpassed its original ideal of National Security during the Great War, and had now taken on the form of social manipulation by the super structure. We see the social control tool at work when in the early years of the war destitute enemy aliens males could give themselves up if without prospect of finding any way to pay for their livelihood. The super structure had manipulated societal expectation and tolerances to force naturalised German/Australians to the point of destitution; and hence it controlled not only the aliens, but had diverted attention from the pressing social issues facing Australia during this epoch of history. The 'social control tool' was now used to segregate this component of Australian society. This segregation continued after the war, as Fischer argues, it was used to "...exclude undesirables residents not only because of their ethnic origin but also because of their socio-economic status"17. People were now being interned due to their employment status or their need to receive charity. Others were interned due to their perceived mental faculties, or previous criminal records. As Fischer argues, "...these immigrants were not at fault. Their lack of success...was entirely due to the war which had changed their status and their chances overnight"18. The question remains as to why these people were treated without compassion? ...read more.


So it is my contention that the 'enemy in our midst' was in fact a fabricated enemy. The governments of the day were quick to seize upon the fact that Australian society maintained an undercurrent of racist ideology, and by playing upon this shortcoming of the Australian psyche they were able to divert the attention of the populace from the pressing social issues that were eroding the social fabric of the time and at the same time the super structure had a control mechanism in which it controlled not only the alien but the general populace as well. 1 www.teachers.ash.org.au/dnutting/germanaustralia/e/internment.htm. accessed on the 7/10/2004 2 Pam MacLean: War and Australian Society, in Joan Beaumont (ed), Australia's War 1914-1918, Allen and Unwin, St Leonards, NSW, Australia, 1995, p69 3 Kate Darian-Smith: War and Australian Society, in Joan Beaumont (ed), Australia's War 1939-45, Allen and Unwin, St Leonards, NSW, Australia, 2000, p55-9 4 Op cit, MacLean, p55. 5 Gerhard Fischer, Enemy Aliens: Internment and the Homefront Experience in Australia, 1914-1920, St. Lucia, Qld: University of Queensland Press, 1989. p 3-4 6 Edward W. Said, Orientalism, London : Penguin, 1991, c1978 7 David Dutton. One of Us? : A Century of Australian Citizenship. Sydney, UNSW Press, 2002 p45. 8 Ibid. p45. 9 Op cit, Dutton. p92 10 Ibid. p92 11 Ibid. p95 12 Op cit, MacLean, p70-1 13 Op cit, MacLean. p71. 14 Op Cit, Darian-Smith, p55 15 Kay Saunders and Roger Daniels, ed. Alien Justice: Wartime Internment in Australia and North America. St Lucia, Qld. : Queensland University Press, 2000 p114-5 16 Op cit, Fischer, p85. 17 Op cit, Fischer, p85 18 Ibid. p85 19 Op cit, Fischer, p47 20 Op cit, Darian-Smith, p56-57 21 Ibid, p57-58 22 Kay Saunders, Ethnic and Racial Studies, April 1994 v17 n2 p325(17) 23 Op cit, Darian-Smith, p58 ?? ?? ?? ?? Alan Torcello 100179737 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Why did tension increase in Europe between 1900 and 1914?

    He needed investment, new technology, but most of all arms agreements which would allow him to reduce the Soviet Union's massive defence spending. Gorbachev knew that the Soviet Union was bankrupt. Why was it bankrupt? * For forty years it had supported Communist regimes around the world through COMECON.

  2. An Investigation Into the Way in Which Sir Winston Churchill Used Rhetoric During the ...

    We must go on." Like a chameleon, Churchill adjusts to the background of his audience. Several of his sayings make reference to the history of the United States, and he borrows a couple of lines from American rhetoric. Churchill's phrase "let us go forward with malice to none and good will to all" is

  1. Many peoples have contributed to the development of the United States of America, a ...

    Americans, who found it difficult to retain enough cash to purchase necessary goods. In 1772 the crown, having earlier declared its right to dismiss colonial judges at its pleasure, stated its intention to pay directly the salaries of governors and judges in Massachusetts.

  2. Describe the ways that propaganda was used to mobilise theminds of the nation towards ...

    contributions to the war effort by handing in pot and pans, etc. The British government also used propaganda to encourage the buying of war bonds as a method of fundraising. The government did not only want to influence the views of Britain, but also those of friends and enemies abroad.

  1. History of the United States

    Shortly thereafter, Churchill warned of the "iron curtain" that had descended across the middle of Europe. The COLD WAR had begun. In March 1947, Truman asked Congress for funds to shore up Turkey and Greece, both under Soviet pressure, and announced the Truman Doctrine: that "it must be the policy

  2. It has been years, but I am still unable to forget the most gruesome ...

    We felt extremely blessed and lucky. Barely able to walk, being weighed down with fear if the next few bombs would hit us, the pain our wounds exploded with made us feel like we rather die than live. However, this war was about survival and we were going to do just that.

  1. Describe the ways that propaganda was used to mobilise the minds of the nation ...

    This poster, like many others, made people feel hatred towards the enemy and also guilt, as the Britons were living in safe places, where children were free to play outside. They would also feel guilty because our soldiers were out there; fighting off the enemy, preventing our streets from being

  2. Introduction - US policy to Southeast Asia in general

    The French had their own internal "Cold War", the French Communist Party winning 26% of the vote in November 1946 elections.30 The French government needed to be handled carefully. But despite Dutch domestic politics showing stability, Petra Groen argues that the Dutch economy certainly did not, stating that in 1947

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work