• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In what ways did the careers of Stalin and Trotsky differ in the years 1917 to 1924?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Ben Allmond 2nd GCSE 2004 History Coursework Question 1 Subject: In what ways did the careers of Stalin and Trotsky differ in the years 1917 to 1924? Between 1917 and 1924 there was political unrest and uprisings all over Russia. Two main figures in these conflicts were Trotsky and Stalin. Trotsky was in New York, where he wrote for a Menshevik newspaper, when the March revolution of 1917 started. Stalin had always been in Russia and he was editing a Bolshevik newspaper called "Pravda" (meaning truth in Russian). At this point both of these men did not have greatly different job, they were both working in Russian newspaper companies. When Trotsky arrived back in Russia in May 1917, he quickly assumed leadership of the independent Left Social-Democratic Interdistrict Group, and joined the Petrograd Soviet. Within weeks, he had gained great popularity as the most eloquent agitator of the Soviet left. Stalin came into the limelight on the 12 of March 1917 when the Russian Bureau of the Central Committee co-opted him as one of their members. They only gave him a consulting vote because they thought that he was a rough diamond, just as Lenin believed and wrote in his "Testament". ...read more.

Middle

Later he became the commissar of war where he directed the Red Army to a great victory in the civil war and saved the revolution. Appointed by Lenin, Stalin became the commissariat for nationality affairs. This brought him to the same level of power as Trotsky. In April, Stalin was elected, alongside Yakov Sverdlov, Trotsky and Lenin, to the Central Committee of the Party where he helped Lenin decide all emergency issues in the first period of the civil war. Stalin was then at the exact same level as Trotsky, all that he had to do now was to become greater than Trotsky. Stalin's popularity started to increase because of his devotion to administrative tasks. In 1922 he reached his crucial stage in his fight against Trotsky - he became the secretary-general of the Party. Stalin quickly converted his position into a source of power, which no one had thought of previously, and so fulfilled his goal to become greater than Trotsky. Before his death Lenin realised, all to late, that Stalin did not know how to use his great power to sufficient caution and he wrote this in his "Testament". He wanted the removal of Stalin from his present position. ...read more.

Conclusion

Trotsky had important government posts but he did not have a power base because he was too complacent. Lenin was the one who helped him and made sure that he was not attacked. People mistrusted Trotsky because they thought that he went where the power was and so they could not count on him in hard times. He readily alienated people, which others didn't want and he was still regarded by many as an outsider. Trotsky made many mistakes throughout his career and Stalin benefited from these. He did not turn up at Lenin's funeral because he had a mystery illness. And for the same reason he could not attend important meetings held by Lenin. This meant that Stalin could say, and said that Trotsky did not care about Lenin and this made Trotsky loose his main support. This left Trotsky completely vulnerable. When Lenin was ill Trotsky, for an unknown reason, did not want to make the main speech in Lenin's place and so Stalin took this opportunity. Stalin could therefor say what he wanted and control the congress. People feared that Trotsky, with his leadership of the Red Army might take of the country and lead a military dictatorship. Stalin had a stronger position in the Party for all of these reasons and finally it brought him out on top of Trotsky. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. Stalin and Trotsky

    This revolution was intended to eliminate the problems of the middle class workers who were seen as a problem within the ideology of Stalin and Trotsky. Also, the philosophy of Trotsky is supportive of the phrase 'the end justifies the means' because he was willing to reach his primary goals

  2. How effective was Lenin at establishing control in Russia between 1917 and 1924?

    Even though this method of establishing control was effective in seizing power from the Provisional Government, after this revolution Lenin only had power in Petrograd and not the rest of Russia. To gain this control of Petrograd though, Lenin was willing to use a level of force, like the Red

  1. How Did Trotsky Contribute To

    In Russia he once again found trouble and was arrested for his involvement in the attempt to overthrow the provisional government in place. This Plot was called 'The July Day's'. He was imprisoned for a short period, He then became the chairman of the Petrograd Soviet.

  2. The enormous role that Trotsky played in the success of the Bolsheviks up until ...

    Foreign troops were also sent over to join them from the US, Japan, France and Britain, who wanted Russia back in the war as well as wanting to prevent its formation into a communist state. They were known as 'the Whites'.

  1. How did the Bolsheviks consolidate their power: 1917 - 1924?

    Lenin knew that for now the peasants must be controlled and what better way than to give them land whilst continuing the policy of Marx. The legal system was abolished, giving the Bolshevik's the freedom to continue their consolidation of power without the fear of legal problems.

  2. Stalin Vs. Trotsky.

    In one raid in Tifiis a squad seized ad quarter of a million rubles. This is the basis of the legend that Stalin was a bank robber. But he did not act as gunman, and he did not pocket the proceeds.

  1. The Impact of Stalins Leadership in the USSR, 1924 1941. Extensive notes

    The failures in the plan were mainly due to the higher priority increasingly given to defence. The Stakhanovite movement: On 30 August 1935, Alexi Stkhanov did a five-hour shift, cutting 102 tonnes of coal with his pick. This was 16 times the average a shift.

  2. How significant was Lenin between the years 1902-1918 to the formation of the Bolshevik ...

    and ?the truth about these events is uncertain?20 as the historian Oxley put it. Nevertheless, in order to defend the city, a council was set up by the central executive committee; including Bolshevik representatives released from prison.21 Lenin was not among them, but was watching events unfold from Finland.22 He

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work