• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"It was not so much that Labour won the General Election of 1945, but that Churchill and the Conservatives lost it." Assess the validity of this view.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"It was not so much that Labour won the General Election of 1945, but that Churchill and the Conservatives lost it." Assess the validity of this view. The question of who "won" or "lost" the election is essentially a question of whether the election result was more of a failure of the Conservative party, or a success of the Labour party. Although it could be argued, as in source C, that "Labour's campaign had a much more modern look to it with a much wider appeal to the community as a whole", and so Labour were more successful at capturing the support of voters than the Conservatives, one could also argue that the election was really the Conservatives' to lose (they were widely seen as "the natural party of government", and had Winston Churchill, an extremely popular wartime Prime Minister, to their credit), and their various failures at campaigning and appeal were their undoing. The Labour Party had many positive advantages over the Conservatives, as listed in source B, the first being "the wartime experience". ...read more.

Middle

Overall, then, it is arguable that the 1945 election result was generally reflective of a positive swell of support for Labour than a negative reaction to a Conservative failure. It is worth noting that many of those who voted in the 1945 election were new voters who only became eligible to vote after the last election (which was ten years before in 1935). Thus much of the voting population were not habitual voters for any party, and it could be said that the result merely illustrated the gradual change which had taken place in the ten years between the two elections (the swing was in fact less pronounced than it seemed - Labour had been leading in polls for many years preceding the elections). The Conservatives, in contrast, had been damaged in a number of ways by the war. The party machinery, previously well-oiled and efficient, had been allowed to disintegrate - the Party did not hold annual conferences throughout the war coalition, and many of those who would run the local party branches (who in the Conservatives' case were often middle class and in non-reserved occupations) ...read more.

Conclusion

Finally, the proportion of votes to seats was very skewed in favour of Labour, making the victory appear more overwhelming than it was. The Conservatives still gained ten million votes (source A shows) to Labour's twelve million, so it was not the case that the Conservatives had lost a great deal of support by the end of the war - it was more the case that Labour had gained more support; the Conservatives had not been resoundingly defeated - Labour had just managed to beat them. Overall, then, the factors contributing to the 1945 election result can more easily support an opposite view to the one presented, because they portray the vote as a positive one for Labour rather than a negative one for the Conservatives. However, there is no reason why the election could not have been both won by Labour and lost by the Conservatives - indeed, it is hard to see how it could not have been both. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics essays

  1. Why did Labour win the 1945 election and lose in the 1951 election?

    A defeated conservative MP at the time, Macmillan, claimed that "It was not Churchill who lost the 1945 election, it was the ghost of Neville Chamberlain". Chamberlain's actions before the war had indeed lost the Conservatives much respect and had made them look weak to many people who saw Labour as the only reliable alternative.

  2. Account for the crushing defeat of the Conservatives in the general election of 1906

    Some English Non Conformists refused to pay their taxes, in Wales a whole campaign was set up by David Lloyd George, a Liberal MP, to oppose the 1902 education act. In 1904 the licensing act also angered the Non Conformist voters.

  1. Sir Winston Churchill

    Again, in 1908, they met again at a dinner party hosted by Lady St. Helier. This time, the two hit it off and began a lifelong romance. On August 10, 1908, Winston proposed to Clementine during a house party in Blenheim.

  2. Assess the validity of the view that the Rump and Barebones parliaments had no ...

    The majority within the Rump are now considered, due to Underdown and Worden, not as ideological republicans with the most startling illustration of this being that 22/41 members of the Council of State in 1649 would not take an oath which declared they approved of the regicide.

  1. The Successes of Labour from 1945

    to run his NHS effectively. The BMA were opposed to doctors being salaried State employees, fearing that this would weaken their professional status and their independence. Some doctors and most consultants wanted to continue with private practice as well as working in the NHS.

  2. how successful was the labour govt 1945 - 51?

    However, there were problems with this scheme. Benefit levels that had been agreed could not support people as much as they needed. This was due to the flat rate contribution system which kept the benefit level to that of the lowest paid.

  1. Why did The Labour Party win the General Election in 1945?

    Even though it was written in 1942, The Labour Party was very much associated with the report with it, with their slogan "Freedom From Want". The Conservatives were less associated with the report and by 1945, were still associated with those who did well out of society.

  2. Why did the Conservatives lose the 1929 election?

    The Conservatives could have used Chamberlains extensive programme of slum clearance, de-rating and local government reform policies in the election. The Conservatives also could have used Davidsons plan to introduce a large scale policy of colonial development in order to stimulate industry and employment, create new markets and show that Conservatives were still full of energy.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work