• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'It was the strength and efficiency of the RAF which frustrated the German attempts to defeat Britain in 1940'. How far do you agree with the statement?

Extracts from this document...


Sarah Lister 13KW 'It was the strength and efficiency of the RAF which frustrated the German attempts to defeat Britain in 1940'. How far do you agree with the statement? The question suggests that the RAF was strong and efficient and this is the reason why the Germans were defeated in the Battle of Britain. However, it is clear to see that the RAF and the British military were actually very close to defeat at some stages throughout the Battle of Britain. The victory of the island in the Battle of Britain cannot be reduced to one common factor but involves emphasis on other ideas such as the role of the Navy in comparison with the Kriegsmarine, the events of Dunkirk and the role of certain personalities throughout 1940. Germany had many options in the Summer of 1940 and it is questionable as to whether a 'Strategic Air War' was the route that should have been taken. Similarly, it is debatable as to whether the success of Britain was due to the faults of the enemy or the strength of the RAF. However, overall it is important to realise that one of the reasons why the German attempts to defeat Britain were 'frustrated' was because Germany made several mistakes during 1940. ...read more.


This strategic mistake may have cause hostility between the Kriegsmarine and Hitler and delayed decisive strategic planning for Operation Sealion. Arguments between the Navy and the Army continued for months and could have been a potential reason as to why contemplating their attack had taken so long. It is also questionable as to why Hitler chose a strategic air war to attack Britain. By the summer of 1940, Germany had several options yet a route was taken to attack the RAF: the force which had kept the Luftwaffe away from the soldiers at Dunkirk. Goering was over-confident, with an arrogant belief that Britain could be brought 'down on its knees' by any simulacrum of a 'hard blow' that he directed against it, and the Luftwaffe had never been designed for strategic, sustained and especially not independent aerial warfare. The previous successes of the Luftwaffe had been of the Blitzkrieg type only and the bombers had not been designed to 'Carpet Bomb' large areas. Therefore, the impact that the Bombers could have on Britain was limited, particularly when fuel supplies only allowed brief combat. An important mistake that Goering made was to underestimate the importance of radar. ...read more.


Yet, they did not. Instead they chose to attack from the skies, where the RAF, at this stage 'ruled the skies'. They took too long to decide their attack, giving their enemy time to rearm. Instead of attacking when they were weak this lull in attack allowed Britain to strengthen their troops. When Germany did decide to attack, they withdrew from offensive when their enemy was at it's weakest and underestimated what was possibly Britain's most valuable tool: radar. It may be possible to say that the RAF played a major contributing in the eventual defeat of Germany in 1945, but the Nazi's could have had victory overall and at a much earlier stage in 1940. However, Germany's mistakes, underestimations and delays prevented this and hindered the efforts of many millions of German servicemen. The strategic decision of an attack via air may not have been the initially mistake as by the beginning of September, the Germans were winning. The downfall in Nazi strategic planning fell in the actions and tactics during the battle and therefore, whilst the RAF fought courageously and kept with technological advances, this did not serve to save Britain. Indeed, the factor, which saved Britain and consequently frustrated German attempts to defeat her, was in fact their own strategic mistakes. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. "Mussolini was an all powerful dictator" - How accurate is this statement?

    The mafia did not accompany the fascist party and instead replaced in rural independent parts of southern Italy. Although Mussolini did not mind this because the area was so poor, not very populated and not industrialised and he neglected it.

  2. Hitlers Germany

    Nazi officeholders, made Hitler a state councilor, a position that automatically bestowed German citizenship upon him. Despite an intensive and exhausting campaign, Hitler gained only 30 percent of the vote. But since Hindenburg failed to gain an absolute majority (he had 49.45 percent of the vote), a second ballot was

  1. Why did the Franco-Prussian war happen and why were the Prussians able to defeat ...

    therefore relations between France and Prussia had deteriorated and therefore made the Spanish Succession Crisis more of danger because there was no love loss between France and Prussia by 1869. Bismarck's aims for southern Germany is also a cause of the Franco-Prussian war because Bismarck aimed to incorporate the Southern

  2. Reasons for Napoleon's Success (to 1807).

    So he decided on a head-on attack. The battle lasted 10 hours. Casualties were huge on ech side: the Russians lost 40,000 and the French 28,0000. * Napoleon could claim a win because the Russians retreated. Kutuzov also claimed a victory because he was able to escape with only 700 taken prisoners.

  1. How did Britain Survive (June 1940-1943)?

    The German bombing of London was apparently accidental. Towards the end of the Battle of Britain a German Bomber flew over a 'Blacked out' London and not realising he was over London he ditched his bombs onto the city below. Britain retaliated by bombing Berlin (something Hitler had sworn would never happen)

  2. Why was Germany unable to defeat Britain by 1941?

    The next key event is the blitz. The Germans attempted to bomb London into submission. The theory was that that the population, would be in constant fear of a sudden and violent death, would put pressure on their government to surrender and accept defeat. The attacks started on September 7th 1940 in Coventry and continued to May 1941.

  1. Assess the relative importance of the reasons why the July 1944 Bomb Plot to ...

    Goebbels telephoned Hitler at the Wolfsschanze and got him to speak to Remer to confirm that he was still alive and to give Remer order to deploy his troops in Berlin under Goebbel's command. As a result, the conspirators were arrested and to seize government and other key buildings.4 The

  2. Albert Speers Role as German Armaments Minister during the War

    in March 1933, when Speer arrived back in Berlin he discovered Goebbels had had the building redecorated. Speer?s next challenge was set to him by Hanke (now Goebbels? secretary). After seeing the plans for the first May night rally, Speer remarked that ?those look like decorations for a rifle club

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work