• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Keith Sinclair has labelled New Zealanders the

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Marine Laouchez HIST 362: 20th Century New Zealand Social History Tutor: Megan Woods. Tutorial: Tuesdays 11-12. Due: Friday 16 August 2002 Essay 1 Keith Sinclair has labelled New Zealanders the "Prussians of the Pacific". How far does this claim that New Zealanders were highly militaristic fit their response to the First World War and the Second World War? The two World Wars, and especially the Second one, are said to be "total wars", which implies that countries were fully engaged in them, with all the means they could control. New Zealand, small country at the antipodes of the world, had to face it as well. Would its behaviour confirm Keith Sinclair's opinion of New Zealanders as "the Prussians of the Pacific", i.e. them being highly militaristic? Indeed the New Zealand society was asked to contribute to the war effort, led by a state eager to rationalize its warfare organisation. However, there is a difference between answering quickly and efficiently to a war declaration and organising and thinking life in constant reference to war. In the first part it is necessary to look at the different definitions of "militarism". Indeed it will imply that the New Zealand response to World War One and Two can be seen as militaristic. ...read more.

Middle

The Home Front was also very committed. Social unity was promoted. After 1939, workers and management staff, especially in industries like woollen mills, clothing or boot making, were asked to do more. Rationing was accepted. Many associations affirmed their support to the war, from the New Zealand Bowling Association to the Associated Chambers of Commerce. There was a real exclusion of those who did not volunteer. The associations related to warfare became very active. In 1905, the National Defence League counted already more than 7,000 members. From 1936, the Defence League is recorded as educating public opinion towards increased defence measures6. The Home Guard, composed with voluntary units, totalled 123,242 men between 1949 and 19437. The Boy Scout Movement, created before World War One, is also part of this civilian militaristic organisation. Besides, women played a big role: they replaced men who left for the front in the industry, notably during World War Two. They, with children, demonstrated in the streets to push men to volunteer. They were on the Front Line as nurses. The newspapers supported this excitation. They exhorted people to take part in it, and most of them were conscriptionists. Moreover, taking part in war also consisted in giving money: to the state, for the aircraft or for the London children during the Second World War. ...read more.

Conclusion

Yet he never really seems to consider New Zealanders as highly militaristic. His counterarguments are: there was never a serious extension of the national frontiers, which contradicts the first aspect of the definition of militarism; there were no great victories; and no boasting about victories, which implies that the citizen and government had never been conditioned enough to think only regarding militaristic success. In conclusion, for him, the New Zealanders are not "the Prussians of the Pacific". In some aspects, the New Zealand response to the World Wars could justify their nickname of "Prussians of the Pacific". Indeed both the government, by using what it could control - legislation, propaganda, state finance, even repression - and the civil society - women, children, association, men by volunteering - had a rather militaristic behaviour during the wars, organising their lives around it. Nonetheless, New Zealand pragmatism prevented it from being highly militaristic: diplomacy and domestic policy remained important, so did opposition to war, and organisation was never optimally rationalized. This conclusion would thus tend to refute Sinclair's opinion. However, New Zealanders could be the "Prussians of the Pacific" for another reason: it has been said that Gallipoli was a "national 'baptism of blood'"18. Just as the Prussians became Germans on the battlefields of Sadowa in 1866 and against France in 1871, the two World Wars probably created a sense of nationhood in New Zealand. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Question 1 minus intro n conslus

    had very strong views and wanted them heard. They wanted education changed because the idea of "evolution" went against their beliefs of Adam and Eve. This could show a decline in the popularity of religion. There were not only negative phenomenon's that were occurring around 1919. There were positive and negative consequences of WW1 that affected the USA in 1919.

  2. American History.

    they set fire to Washington DC and burned it to the ground. The key battle then occurred at Baltimore in September 1814 - the Brits. Inflicted heavy damage, but the war was basically stalemated in the region. - The last campaigns took place in the South against the Creeks and

  1. Only Yesterday by Frederick Lewis Allen - review

    Advertising became a profession in itself, salesmen were being pressured to sell like never before, and business in general was booming at an all time high. Formerly typical stories that were generally not what one would be accustomed to seeing on the front page became front-page news simply because Americans

  2. Michael Moore's "Bowling for Columbine" - review.

    This suggests to the viewer, that since America views it as legal to buy, it is as if they are making it legal to use them to kill. However, despite the resentful tone of the voice over, the general tone of the sequence remains empathetic, and pitiful towards the students and those who died.

  1. To what extent was New Zealand 'born as a nation' in World War I?

    Yet this theory is eurocentric, because it assumes a nation into which Maori would be assimilated. Maori were in fact strongly divided in their desire to become citizens of the nation. There were many, however, who chose to support a nation that they increasingly saw themselves a part of.

  2. Anzacs and the Gallipoli Campaign of 1915. How useful are the views of the ...

    Whether this is achieved or not is a matter of opinion, because if you admire confidence over professionalism then the Anzacs are most assuredly made to look better. The source is also based during the time and so it is primary data, which is always more reliable than secondary data.

  1. Why did tension increase in Europe between 1900 and 1914?

    The Soviet Union was not prepared to do this. * In 1979 SALT II was signed by Carter and Brezhnev, but before it could be ratified relations between East and West broke down. The real crisis in Superpower relations, however, came in 1979.

  2. Dtente, meaning and definition.

    TRADE TURNOVER AND SOVIET EXPORTS (Rubles in millions) Countries Year Total Exports United Kingdom 1971 605 405 1972 558 371 1973 715 541 Italy 1971 495 223 1972 464 228 1973 624 310 France 1971 776 377 1972 816 381 1973 722 272 Japan 1971 734 377 1972 816 382

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work