• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Mussolini(TM)s rise to power up to 1922 owes more to the failures of others than to his own strengths. To what extent is this true?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Mussolini's rise to power up to 1922 owes more to the failures of others than to his own strengths. To what extent is this true? In the 1922 general election, Mussolini won no more than 2% of the parliamentary seats yet, by the end of the year the leader of the Fascist Party had become dictator of Italy. He had nowhere near enough electoral backing to establish a government and, had his march on Rome gone ahead his squads could easily have been crushed. He was handed the position by a few governing �lites; there was no election, little resistance and no seizure of power. The issue of who was to blame for this unelected success in Italy's so-called democracy is highly controversial and undecided amongst historians. While most historians accept that there were numerous contributing factors, there is disagreement as to the significance of each factor. In his book 'Modern Italy', Martin Clark1 places the emphasis on the failure of the King and the elite. However E. Tannenbaum primarily blames the governmental failure to rebuild a strong Italy after the unification2. In my opinion both are important, as are other factors such as Mussolini's own skills, the political system and the politician's failure to work together in strong coalitions. In this essay I will discuss the argument that the failures of others played a greater role in Mussolini's rise to power than his own strengths. I will explore all the contributing factors to his rise to power in order to reach my conclusion. Problems The Liberal governments had been unable to solve Italy's problems caused by her unification in 1861; leaving her vulnerable to extremists such as Mussolini in 1922. Mussolini's skills enabled him to exploit the situations in Italy to help his own means. The famous historian Denis Mack Smith stresses the role of Mussolini in manipulating a complex situation3. The �lite had agreed that they had to create a unified nation; D'Angelo famously said "we have made Italy; now we must make Italians"4. ...read more.

Middle

He underestimated Mussolini and was convinced that Mussolini could be tamed and his squads used to his own advantage. The pact gave the Fascists the springboard they needed to establish themselves as a serious political player and gave them 35 seats in the Chamber of Deputies. Mussolini carefully selected these candidates ensuring their respectability and moderation which was important as the Squadristi violence was starting to lose Mussolini governmental support. This shows that although Mussolini was aware that Squadristi violence was beneficial in some ways, this alone would not get him into government. The unintelligent, foolish decision made by Giolitti shows great weakness on his part. It also shows how easily Mussolini was able to exploit politicians; proving him to be good negotiator and showing his ability make the most of the weaknesses of others. Mussolini was also underestimated by D'Annunzio who saw Mussolini as his chief propagandist and fund raiser rather than as a rival or a threat; Mussolini used this to his advantage. He supported the Government's decision to crush D'Annunzio's coup of the Fiume; as a result D'Annunzio lost his power base and it removed all of Mussolini's rivals for power on the Right. Many of the Liberal politicians believed that they could use Mussolini to strengthen their position to defeat rivals. Mussolini cleverly played on this, negotiating with each politician about coalitions and political deals with the Fascists. None of the influential politicians were se men were willing to work together to prevent Mussolini nor did they have the power individually. Facta could have convinced Giolitti to end his differences with D'Annunzio and take steps towards forming a stronger coalition. Together Giolitti and D'Annunzio would have been considerably stronger than Facta's government and would have had the ability to put pressure on the King to use the Army to crush Mussolini's violence and end his "March on Rome. In order to combat the threat of this happening, Mussolini opened up his own negotiations with D'Annunzio in 1922. ...read more.

Conclusion

Mussolini's leadership and strategy gave the movement flexibility and energy which contrasted with the weak, tired government. The weak situation in Italy created by the unification and the war was handled poorly by the subsequent governments, leaving Italy's people discontented and willing to support extreme parties such as the Socialists and Fascists. The extremes deeply opposed each other using terror and violence which increased the view that Italy needed strong leadership which it did not find in the divided Liberal governments. The Liberal politicians failed to work together and wanted power for themselves. Italy's political situation of proportional representation forced politicians into coalition governments which along with their underestimation of Mussolini left them vulnerable to the Fascists. The Fascists took over because the Middle classes had become convinced that after the war, successive governments had been unable to combat the spread of socialism. The King's decision not to use the army against the March on Rome was a poor one, which lead to him handing power to Mussolini without a struggle or fight. 1 Source: Modern Italy 1871-1982, Martin Clark, Longman History of Italy 2 3 4 5 Source: Mussolini from Socialist to Fascist by David Williamson pg 14, Hodder and Stoughton. 6 7 8 9 10 Source: Mussolini from Socialist to Fascist by David Williamson p.23, Hodder and Stoughton, from quote in D. Mack Smith, Mussolini, Phoenix Paperback, 1994 p.51 11 Source: Modern Italy 1871-1982, Martin Clark, Longman History of Italy p. 221. 12 Source: Modern Italy 1871-1982, Martin Clark, Longman History of Italy p. 221. 13 Source: Mussolini from Socialist to Fascist by David Williamson pg 12, Hodder and Stoughton 14 Source: fascist Italy, John Hite and Chris Hinton, Advanced History Core texts, The Schools History Project official text, John Murray. ?? ?? ?? ?? Personal Study, Forth Draft Mussolini's rise to power owes more to the failures of others than to his own strengths. To what extent is this true? By Rebecca Haworth 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Why did Mussolini come to Power in 1922? How did Mussolini consolidate his position ...

    4 star(s)

    offices (Mussolini's former newspaper) and engaged in other acts of violence against socialists, such as pouring Castor Oil over them and simply beating them up. This was done not only by the Fascio di Combattimento but by other fascist squadrismo, completely independent of Mussolini's movement, although their leaders the ras realised the importance of Mussolini, particularly because of his newspaper.

  2. Assess the view that the failures of the Congress of Vienna outweighed the successes.

    own convenience and interest and took no account of the aspirations of the people.'21 This was a prime failure of the settlement, as in most cases where the principle of legitimacy was applied, there was another consideration at work, for example, in central Italy restoring Habsburgs dukes and principles was

  1. To what extent was Hitlers rise to power due to Economic Problems?

    Thirdly, the Germans who belong to the 'Aryan' race must keep themselves pure in order to become the 'master race'3, communism must be destroyed and lastly the peace treaty that Germany signed, according to Hitler by the 'November Criminals', must be cancelled and France must be destroyed.

  2. To What Extent Did Mussolini Achieve his Foreign Policy Aims of making Italy "Great ...

    This showed Mussolini's obsession with the image of Italy being great and respected. This was when Italy became involved in the Albanian civil war, Mussolini decided to support the rebel group Noli, fighting against Yugoslavia's prot�g�, Zogu. This was how Mussolini came to establish Italy's virtual protectorate over Albania.

  1. The most important reason for Mussolini being made Prime Minister was the actions of ...

    Fascist violence was a major factor in the rise of Mussolini as these led to the demise of the socialist

  2. Why was Mussolini appointed Prime Minister in 1922?

    Farmers, Factory workers, Artists, Poets, Anarchists, Nationalists and Publicans but these people didn't have the money to put into the movement unless there was a socialist revolution. However by 1922 Mussolini's ideas had changed from being left wing to right wing and as a consequence so did his supporters.

  1. Explain the reasons for the rise of Fascism in Italy between 1919 and 1922 ...

    On the night 27th October, Fascist squads seized town halls, telephone exchanges and railway stations throughout northern Italy.

  2. To What Extent Was Fascist Control of Italy The Result Of The Effective Use ...

    the government through certain methods, either by violence or sentencing them to confino a punishment where enemies of the state would be sent to isolated areas of Southern Italy with an allowance of 10 Lire a day.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work