• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

PEEL'S POLICIES TOWARDS IRELAND WERE REPRESSIVE RATHER THAN REFORMING IN THE PERIOD FROM 1829 TO 1846. HOW FAR DO YOU AGREE?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

PEEL'S POLICIES TOWARDS IRELAND WERE REPRESSIVE RATHER THAN REFORMING IN THE PERIOD FROM 1829 TO 1846. HOW FAR DO YOU AGREE? Peel's policies towards Ireland seem to swing backwards and forwards over the period 1829-46; he supported Catholic emancipation in 1829, yet his policy of coercion seems distinctly repressive, and this was then followed by conciliation, which could be considered reforming. Peel had to tread a thin line between firmness and assertion of authority without alienating any potential Catholic support. However, on balance we can consider that his policies were more reforming than repressive. Peel's support of Catholic emancipation in 1829 shows the reforming side of his policy. He supported it against a huge amount of scepticism from his own party and did it in the belief that it was for the good of the union - he thought it was a greater risk to refuse to satisfy their demands than to grant them. However, the restriction that Catholic emancipation placed on the franchise meant that it carried with reform an element of repression. ...read more.

Middle

This is perhaps the most openly repressive thing that Peel did in the period. This incident proved to be the turning point in O'Connell' political career; despite later being released from prison he never regained his full authority and subsequently his repeal movement began to fall apart. This was a clear victory for Peel's defence of the union, and gave him great support within the Conservative Party. However, Peel was convinced that a population that was more than 80% Catholic could not be coerced indefinitely and in early 1844 asserted that whilst the union itself was still the overriding objective, 'Equality of treatment for Protestant and Catholic Citizens was necessary' so that the Irish middle classes could be persuaded of the benefits of it. Peel's plan of conciliation sought to improve relations and win this crucial support within Ireland. The first step that showed Peel taking a more reforming line was to remove the staunch protestant defender de Gray as Lord Lieutenant of Ireland. He was replaced by Lord Heytesbury, who was happy to follow Peel's policy of giving Catholics equal opportunities in government. ...read more.

Conclusion

However, this was in the face of requests for Catholic colleges from the priests, something that Peel flatly refused to consider. With the coming of the potato famine in 1845, Peel found even greater problems in Ireland, which lead to further reform. Peel's worry about the dependency on the potato was justified, and many people in Ireland were starving. Peel made the decision to try and repeal the Corn Laws. He faced huge opposition from his own party at the suggestion, yet the Bill was passed with Whig support. This is the most reforming one of Peel's policies towards Ireland; however, there is the suggestion that his hand was forced politically. Overall, the evidence suggests that although there were some repressive elements to Peel's Irish policy, namely the period of Coercion, the majority of his policy can be considered as more reforming, as he acted to try and change and improve the conditions in Ireland and the relationships between Britain and Ireland. This is shown by Peel's reasoning that in order to preserve the Union (which was to him the most important matter), the Irish would have to be treated fairly and be shown the benefits of it. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics essays

  1. Disraeli's second ministry deserves the title a great reforming ministry Discuss how far you ...

    However both ministries were flawed though, for all Gladstone large and influential reforms he was voted out in 1874 and although Disraeli aimed not to lose any support he also was voted out in 1880. The reason why Gladstone was voted out were that his legislation was so wide ranging

  2. Assess the success of Peel

    In contrast the Companies Act of 1844 which aimed to make all companies legitimately registered and issue to prospectuses and regular accounts was not as successful. Its chief weakness was that the act did not apply to companies that needed to get special approval from parliament (e.g.

  1. INTER-WAR PERIOD

    The Midlands and the South suffered much less. If one was in employment, one could afford the cheaper food and the 'luxuries' such as vacuum cleaners etc. What measures did the government adopt to deal with the effects of the depression? * A return to protection - tariffs were put on goods coming into the country.

  2. Reform Chartism

    by agricultural depression of 1870's-1900- politics increasingly expensive and so many cut expenditure in politics * Political power of aristocracy eroded by more representative government- secret ballot, corrupt practise act of 1883 and 1884 extension of franchise to rural householders important in limiting aristocracy * Conservatives most successful party- electoral

  1. Assess the impact of the period from 1969-1982 on the IRA/Sinn Fein and their ...

    movement and inspired many to stand up and fight for the cause they all believed in. On 30 January 19725 in the city of Derry, Northern Ireland border, perhaps one of the largest single atrocities of the 'Troubles' period occurred.

  2. 'The Turn of the Screw'

    Being the daughter of a country parson, she sees it as her religious duty to protect the children. She sees Miles as being innocent, but corrupted by Peter Quint, which would have shocked Victorian readers. However, the governess begins to distrust the children, as it is revealed that they too

  1. How far do you agree that the Anti-Corn law League was the most important ...

    To conclude, the stem of the Corn Law repeal came from the Irish famine from within the cabinet and inside parliament, although the Corn Law was responsible for the conversion of Whig leader lord John Russell, this was not the case with Peel, still standing that it was Peels gradual conversion which lead to the repeal.

  2. To what extent can Gladstones first ministry be considered a great reforming ministry?

    The act as a whole, reflects upon success as it demonstrates his extreme effort to eliminate religious discrimination, providing equal opportunity for people with all beliefs. This act could be considered to be a great reform as it abolished the privileges? of different religions and gave people the right to make their own choices through equality of opportunity.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work