• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Questions on "The use of the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki".

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Questions on "The use of the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki" 1. What are (a) the similarities and (b) the differences (if any) in the justifications given by Byrnes (Source A) and Makins (Source B) for the use of the A-bomb? The similarities between Source A and B are that both authors believe that the United States was under pressure and correct in dropping the bomb. The authors of the sources were Americans that were involved in the decision making whether to drop the bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki Source A states that, "....Any weapon that could bring an end to the war and save millions of casualties among American boys was justified..." a similar statement appears in Source B stating "Americans were poised for the invasion of Japan and it was estimated that that operation might cost up to a million lives." Both these quotes show justification that that the dropping of the bomb on the two Japanese cities was necessary. The differences between the two sources are that in Source A the author focus's on bringing the war to an end by stating, "It was our duty to bring the war to an end at the earliest possible moment." ...read more.

Middle

The difference in these two sources is that they are written by two different authors who saw this in a complete different way. Leahy saw this from the point of view as the chief of staff to Roosevelt and Truman where as Hart, a historian, saw his perspective years later after he had collected evidence to come up with a conclusion. Leahy states in his source that Japan was ready to surrender due to a number of reasons such as; the sea blockade that the United States had placed in the east, the starvation that had overcome due to war, and also the bombing of regular weapons in the country but scientists wanted to test the Atomic bomb. Hart as a historian states, "But president Truman and most of his chief advisors were now as intent on using the bomb to accelerate Japan's collapse as Stalin was on entering the war against Japan before it ended, in order to gain advantageous position in the Far East." The United States wanted to make sure that Russia did not claim any "spoils" from the war that were to be gained in the Far East. ...read more.

Conclusion

Source G was later written by Hart who was a historian; he was in no way involved with the government and stated his perspective from viewing different sources that were used as evidence. Both Makins and Brynes mention in their articles that the bomb was dropped on Japan to save lives and to end the war in a more effective way. Sources A & B have a biased point of view because of the scenario that they are in, being that both authors were involved with the United States government at the time, and also understanding the issue at first hand. Makins and Brynes know the motivations that the United States government had in dropping the bomb such as keeping Russia away from Far East. Hart on the other hand looks back and states that a strategic reason would have been more important. Also he believes that there was no need to drop the bomb on Japan because they were ready to surrender. In his article he states, "This surrender was already sure..." making this not a personal statement. Hart has the advantage of looking at two biased views and coming up with an objective that suits the situation. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Truman had several reasons for dropping the atom bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

    this was mostly in the form of posters showing the atrocities of destroyed fleet. Many scientists and historians have questioned whether part of Truman's decision to drop the bombs was to test this new type of weapon. A previous nuclear test explosion was conducted in a desert in New Mexico

  2. Vietnam Coursework Sources Questions

    This would have sparked off other protests and led to a feeling of general bitterness felt towards the government about the war in Vietnam. Another reason for growing concerns was the Tet offensive in 1968. This made many people feel that America had truly lost the war as the Viet

  1. Was The Dropping Of The Atomic Bombs On Hiroshima And Nagasaki Justified?

    Japanese were willing to fight against America until the death. This was a concern for America as they knew that Japanese had about five million men and five thousand suicide aircrafts, America had to fight back with power and chose the atomic bombs to do so.

  2. World War One Sources Questions

    For example we are shown a group of young men just leaving university which would indicate that they were middle class. Also, the source suggests that none of this mattered as men from all backgrounds were killed and injured in the war.

  1. The Prelude to the 1975 War and the Cairo Agreement.

    against Christian civilians: 31 August 1983 36 Christians had their throats cut in Bmarian 7 September 1983 200 people massacred in Bhamdoun 10 September 1983 64 slaughtered in Bireh, several victims were executed in the village church, some of them on the altar.

  2. An evaluation of the United States decision to use atomic bombs against Hiroshima and ...

    If they had, one of the available alternatives to the use of the atomic bomb may have been employed. The alternatives existing were a land invasion of the Japanese mainland, or the use of diplomatic negotiations such as modifying the American demand for unconditional surrender or using Russian aid as a threat against Japan.

  1. Why did President Truman Decide to Drop the Two Atomic Bombs On Hiroshima and ...

    However they were taking a terrible battering from US aeroplanes. Each month 40,000 tons of bombs were dropped onto Japanese cities, 60 cities had half there houses destroyed, 90% of the navy and merchant shipping had been sunk and Honshu (the largest of the 4 main Islands)

  2. was the dropping of the atomic bombs justified?

    of the Battleship in Pearl Harbor with the 3,000 youngsters underneath it who had no chance whatever of saving their lives. That is true of two or three other battleships that were sunk in Pearl Harbor. Altogether, there were between 3,000 and 6,000 youngsters killed at that time without any declaration of war.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work