• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Russian Revolution 1905 - Were the Underlying Causes Political?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

30/06/11 Dylan Asafo 13CHS FRA Essay Question: 'The underlying causes of the 1905 Revolution in Russia were not political. Whatever else the revolutionaries wanted, it was not the overthrow of the Tsar.' How far do you agree with this claim? A revolution is universally characterized, even defined, as a vast change in power or government structure within a relatively short period of time. Therefore to contend that 'the underlying causes of the 1905 Revolution in Russia were not political. Whatever else the revolutionaries wanted, it was not the overthrow of the Tsar' is greatly inaccurate; where it is clear that a political change must involve a political cause/s, including those with social or economic foundations. The bold and strongly implicative statement is largely incorrect in its phrasing and suggestions, including inaccuracies in the non-political nature of all the causes and t he intentions of the revolutionaries. However, there were notable social and economic aspects within the underlying causes of the 1905 Revolution; including wide social discontent due to poor living conditions and autocratic power, Bloody Sunday and the Russo-Japanese War. All these causes must be evaluated in further detail for a more balanced and fair view of not only the statement but the aetiology of the Revolution as a whole. ...read more.

Middle

Petersburg carried pictures of him, so it could have been evidence for the claim that they did not want "to overthrow the Tsar" in the sense the protest was not against him personally. However Father Gapon's March at St. Petersburg led to the dreadful massacre of 500 marchers shocking all of Russia and causing many agrarian riots and industrial strikes. Most significantly, Bloody Sunday became a turning point for many of the revolutionaries and working class, were more wanted more aggressive action and thus starting the revolution against Tsar Nicholas II. It is upon this analysis that one can safely say that to say that causes were not political is not only completely false, but immoral in removing any political responsibility in events so terrible in Russian history. In addition to social discontent among civilians, was the great dissatisfaction among the military. Though weaknesses had always been evident with the lack of financial support and structure from the Tsar's government, this was fully realised in the Russo-Japanese War (1904-05) where the army was substantially unprepared and suffered 50,000 casualties. In addition to this, the war worsened working and living conditions with reduced food supply leading to malnutrition and their loss was also a large blow to Russian nationalism and pride as a great power. ...read more.

Conclusion

Whatever else the revolutionaries wanted, it was not the overthrow of the Tsar' should always be greatly emphasized. This is for obtaining true accounts of the events themselves and to do so in the awareness of the existence of historical narratives which aim to wrongly alter historical events with intentions to form desired perceptions of certain figures and events for their own benefit. This has been previously evident in Russian history textbooks, memoirs and historical literature which could very well contain similar claims. It is then key in this particular instance that one limitedly appreciates , that although all underlying (and immediate) causes were essentially political, they did contain key social or economic elements that the claim unfortunately overstates ;such as social discontent due to autocratic policies and military dissatisfaction due to the weak management by the government. These were 'brought to the surface' by the triggering events Bloody Sunday and the Russo-Japanese War respectively. The second part of the claim, does have minor merits in acknowledging that the desire for the Tsar to be overthrown was not universal, however makes the crucial error in generalizing this to all of the 1905 revolutionaries, where the much more numerous and effective Social Revolutionary Party, Bolsheviks and Mensheviks clearly intended to overthrow the Tsar. One is therefore justified in disagreeing with the claim to a very great, even complete extent. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Major Causes of French Revolution

    4 star(s)

    start the revolution), like a 'revolutionary psychology' or game plan- the grounds were prepared for other means rather than ambitions. Wolf states that peasants were often spectators of political struggles and the peasants were slow to rise because they were too far away to understand what was happening in the 'city'.

  2. How far was the Russian Japanese war of 1905 the cause of the 1905 ...

    The Bloody Sunday can be considered as an immediate cause of the revolution. Another factor was the grievances of the peasants. Despite the emancipation reforms, their conditions were no better. They still had to pay redemption payments and were tied to the mir.

  1. Operation Barbarossa - Causes and Consequences

    Before the invasion took place, Stalin was warned many times of Hitler's true intentions. However, he preferred to trust his 'political instinct' rather than the secret reports he had been receiving for weeks. Convinced he had signed an eternal pact of friendship with Germany, he paid no attention to the evidence of Hitler's treachery his intelligence constantly presented to him.

  2. Lenin and the Bolshevik revolution.

    The slogan "Workers' Control", first developed by Lenin in May, also struck a responsive chord amongst the industrial workers. By "workers' control" Lenin meant that workers should have access to all the financial and accounting records of the enterprises by which they were employed, and that in addition they should

  1. Free essay

    What Were the Causes of the 1905 Revolution? Why did the Revolution Fail to ...

    This law turned Russia into a police state, and included Alexander employing a special police section called the "Okhrana". It was their job to crush any opposing political party. During Alexander's reign, there were no constraints to the Tsar's powers.

  2. Impact of the Russian revolution - Ideology matters.

    Imperialism represented a special, highest, stage of capitalism. The transition to a capitalism of this higher order was connected with an aggravation of contradictions, frictions, and conflicts. Monopolists assured profits by corrupting the upper stratum of the proletariat in the developed countries. The imperialist ideology permeated the working class.

  1. Assess the reasons for the 1905 Russian Revolution

    As a result of this famine strangled Russia and caused the peasants and the working classes more unrest and angst towards the tsar all of this coinciding with the peasants? anger all created a dangerous environment for the tsar.

  2. How far do you agree that the Russo Japanese war was the biggest cause ...

    The government was far too slow to export the necessary supplies and the transport system failed to cope. The government was also reluctant to send out food until they had ?statistical proof? that the province had no other means of food; but by then it was often too late.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work