• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Sorce based questions on the role of women in the first world war.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

History GCSE Coursework, James Cunnington Source Questions 1. Source A comes from a broadcast on the BBC Home Radio and seems to be stating that now the great majority of men are away at war it is the job of women to pull together to complete essential war work. The speaker from the Women's Institute (WI) said, "We are all in it together. Don't be afraid of being alone in your sacrifice," suggesting that she believes every woman will have to give up some of their time or their personal security in order to win the battle that the entire country faced. The speaker is trying to push across the message that there is another battleground, within each family home. She says, "It's no longer a question of what is the most comfortable arrangement for each family." Telling us that the main role for women is to keep them and their families healthy and that's its just as important as what the men are doing. The fact that it is a member of the WI who aired these particular views may lead some to believe that it was simply one group of self-important women but there is more evidence to back up their claims. 2. It could be said that Source B is one such piece. It is quite clearly in favour of women taking part in war work, "women should get on with the job, (and) do it well," (B). It is an article written by a female member of the local council in West Ham in 1941, the author also states in the source that she did what would be considered a man's job during World War One an, "enjoyed it." Showing us that she is a proponent of women in the workplace, just as the woman in Source A said, "ever woman in the country needs to pull her weight to the utmost." ...read more.

Middle

This was done because this was the first time rationing of food across the whole country had been used and many people, especially the middle classes, were unsure of how to cope with it. With food being scarce, people were also being encouraged to grow their own on every available piece of land, one very famous campaign was called, 'Dig For Victory'. The government promoted the growth of root vegetables such as potatoes not only because they were healthy but they were also easy to produce in large numbers in Britain so they didn't have to be imported. This had the knock on effect that fewer supply ships would be need for food and therefore more money could be pumped back into the war effort. This is hinted at in C, where it says that potatoes, "save shipping space." Raising morale was also a major aim of the food leaflets and adverts. Both Sources C and D show this perfectly. C, a leaflet from the Ministry of Food, mentions how, "food is a weapon of war," in the very first sentence, telling women that they were fighting on the, "kitchen front," just as bravely and fiercely as, "their menfolk in the services." Although in a patronising style that was typical of the time, it shows how the women's feelings were being taken into consideration by the government and their needs and interests were being listened to and acted upon more so than ever before. This in itself could have been morale raising for women. Source D is in a similar style to C and has the same aims although it goes about putting them across in different ways. It was produced by the government with the purpose of getting women into the spirit of the War Work, by saying there were, "Medals for Housewives." Along with the cartoon picture of a woman with medals are several sections which include the information of the piece, "saving all the bread crusts and crumbs... for cooking," (D). ...read more.

Conclusion

Source f indicates that women were welcomed with open arms into the factories and field but Source G says the complete opposite. The woman, who actually was a Land Army girl and speaking 1983, said "the people were very resentful in the country, they didn't make it easy for you." These two distinct representations of how women went about their War Work make each other unreliable and therefore not very useful. Also, there are other questions over the reliability of the sources. For example, G is only one persons recollection many years after the event. She could have been the exception that proves the rule and we are not sure if she is biased in an unknown way towards the time she spent there. Without some independent evidence to back up what the woman is saying the source we can never really be sure that it is completely true. The same can be said for Source F as we have no idea of how popular it actually was, who wrote and about whom in particular. Without knowing these things neither of these sources are, I my opinion, useful enough to determine the what women's War Work was actually like. 5. On some levels I agree that the most important role played by women during the war was in the home but on others I have to disagree. Some might say it is true that women in the home did play a major role by keeping their households and families in order because "(women) on the kitchen front have the job of using these foods to the greatest advantage," (C). Saying that food was a weapon, as it does in Source C, is implying that women do just as much as the men on the front line and they are the most important part of any army or war as a whole and so, therefore, women must have been highly valued in the jobs they did. Another way in which it can be proved that they were highly valued is that ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Vietnam Coursework Sources Questions

    Booby traps were set by the Viet Cong that caused horrific deaths and injuries to the unexpecting Americans. Examples of these traps were pits in the ground with spikes in that were covered up so one wrong step and a person would fall to their death.

  2. Vietnam source based work

    The American government knew that public opinion was very important. If the public turned against the war then it would have been very difficult to carry on. The article is about the My Lai massacre in 1968. This story did turn the public opinion because it shows how awful the

  1. The Origins of the First World War - Sources Questions

    The two sources, however, do not deny the notion of an aggressive government. The deceitful (source two) and disagreeable (source three) actions of Germany could be perceived as war planning. However, the origins and nature of both sources undermine their relevance to our study.

  2. Hiroshima Coursework This piece of coursework will concentrate on three questions, all source based.

    You have to take into consideration the narrators motive. It does not state when he was there. Was he there after the bomb was set off? Was he near the centre where the bomb was dropped? This is a limitation of this source. In conclusion I believe that source A is clearly the more useful source to understand the physical effect of the Hiroshima bomb.

  1. In What Ways Did The First World War Affect The Lives Of People At ...

    The main effect that this had on the war effort was that Britain had more men than ever before come up to the front line and as this was a static war, a war of attrition where whoever had the most men would clearly and advantage.

  2. The home front (source based work) 1914 - 1918.

    First World War, as it is a propaganda poster recruiting women to work in munitions factories. The reason why the government made this poster is because of the munitions crisis in 1915 that is still not solved completely and to be able to solve this problem the government needed more women to work in the munitions factories.

  1. Africa and the role they played during both of the world wars.

    Even after the war was over, Africans were feeling the effects, the influenza epidemic inflicted between 1,5-2 million casualties after the war, which was carried back by returning soldiers and labourers from Europe. There were four campaigns against German colonies by the allies in Africa.

  2. What role did the media play in the war effort on the home front?

    The news was the main way of giving the public information on the war. The BBC broadcast all over Europe. They even broadcast in Germany; many listened even though it was banned. Radio was a major contributor to raising the public's moral.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work