• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Source Questions - World War One

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Adam Painter Coursework - Source Questions 1) Both Sources paint a picture to describe how the war, however there is one significant difference, Source B is a primary source, and Source E is a tertiary source. Source B is a contemporary picture of German soldiers 'going over the top'. It shows the trench, men who have gone over the top and men in position, waiting to go over the top. Source E is a painting from the 1970's showing men waiting to go over the top. Source B shows a scene from a battle, in which German soldiers are going over the top. The battlefield does not contain an accurate representation of what the battlefields looked like at the time. The scene looks empty and quite barren and this was not what it was like. The fields of the Somme for example, were filled with corpses, shrapnel and mounds of barbed wire. In this picture there is no barbed wire to be seen, very unlikely for a scene taken at the trenches. The trench seems to be unusually dry and uncluttered, with troops rising from it with ease. Whereas the real trenches were extremely wet and often rat invested. ...read more.

Middle

3) Source C is an extract from The Great War by Marc Ferro, explaining the impact of the German assault. Ferro, a French historian wrote the book in 1973, and the basis of the book revolves around the period of 1914-1918. Source F, is an extract from the book Tales Of The Old Soldiers, and was written by George Jameson in 1993. Both sources give different accounts of events that happened during the First World War. Source C is about the impact of the German assault, on 21st March 1918, and describes how the British were broken through by the German Army. It shows that despite the fact that the British had superior artillery, the German fighting skill was greater, and had the British retreating towards the channel ports. Source F explains the same occurrence, however, it differs from the other account. Jameson tells us that although the German offensive had pushed them back, it did not break through the British line, and when the Germans eventually retreated, the British troops had gained advantage. Source C, written by a French historian, uses many other sources to back up the account. These sources could range from maps, personal testimony (like Jameson's) ...read more.

Conclusion

German forces had gained ground quickly and were pushing the British back towards the ports. The aim of this was to capture Flanders, separate the British from the French and gain access to the Channel ports. This is all documented in Source D. Also, the assault was to be launched across the Western Front before the American troops could grow in number. When this was done, the last task was to seize victory before the stranglehold on Germany increased. However, as the Germans got near Flanders, the German command realized that they were outnumbered and that the British and American forces were greater in size than previously expected. This is described in Source G. The British forces began to fight harder, and faster, as this is how the Germans foresaw themselves gaining victory. Eventually, the Germans were forced back further and further, and this is how the attack failed, as they could not gather troops quickly enough. This fact is shown in Source F, where Jameson explains how they had the Germans 'On the run.' As the offensive gathered pace, the German communications systems became over-stretched, and eventually collapsed. This was a vital factor in describing how the offensive failed. Troops became worried as morale was very low, and this is shown in Source E, where German assault troops are about to be sent out. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Vietnam Coursework Sources Questions

    This made the soldiers terrified to move around the jungle as a Viet Cong trap could be lurking anywhere. The Viet Cong had a series of underground tunnels they could escape into if they were ever pursued making it very difficult for the Americans to locate and kill any of them.

  2. The Origins of the First World War - Sources Questions

    Where as source five suggests that Weltpolitik was formulated on the basis of fear and encirclement. The nature of Weltpolitik puzzles historians; perhaps it was a combination of all those mentioned. Part B "The First World War was the result of a badly mismanaged Balkan Crisis in the summer of

  1. World War One Sources Questions

    Source D is an extract about Haig from the book 'Great battles of world war 1' written by Anthony Livesey. Source E is an extract from the biography written by Haig, called 'Field Marshall Haig' written by Philip Warner. Although these two interpretations are written around the same time, they

  2. Armed forces.

    This new strategic thinking would be augmented and amended by the opening of the Suez Canal in 1869. The world was becoming a smaller place at a rapid rate and maritime necessities would be prime in consideration for much of the Imperial expansion of the day.

  1. Vietnam source based work

    It changed many opinions. Source J is a photo taken in 1968 in My Lai when the My Lai massacre took place. Although it was taken in 1968 we are not told when it was released. It shows very frightened people who are frightened as a result of American action.

  2. Hiroshima Coursework This piece of coursework will concentrate on three questions, all source based.

    You have to take into consideration the narrators motive. It does not state when he was there. Was he there after the bomb was set off? Was he near the centre where the bomb was dropped? This is a limitation of this source. In conclusion I believe that source A is clearly the more useful source to understand the physical effect of the Hiroshima bomb.

  1. The Home Front 1914-1918, Women and work - source related study.

    The weaknesses of Sources A+ B is that they don't talk about what disadvantages or advantages in the home and social life came from working in a factory plus the sources mostly concentrate on time worked, wages and condition. However Source C doesn't give different views of woman and factory

  2. The home front (source based work) 1914 - 1918.

    for the same wages as normal time it can hardly be called freedom! However, Source C does support the evidence in Source B as the women in Source B must of 'prefer factory life' as the factory owner stated in Source C otherwise they would not stay and work for that factory.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work