• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Stalin and Trotsky

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Stalin and Trotsky Miss Blom CHY 4UW Tuesday April 10th, 2007 Magdalena Nowakowska 1. a) In Source B, what is meant by the following statement: "Unlike Trotsky, Stalin believed that socialism could be introduced in one country without being accompanied by a world revolution" (3) In Source B, by the statement "Unlike Trotsky, Stalin believed that socialism could be introduced in one country without being accompanied by a world revolution," it is meant that Russia would have to serve as a proper example of socialism until the world revolution occurred. This doctrine permitted the Soviet Union to carry out a policy of "peaceful coexistence" with capitalist states if necessary, during international affairs. This also signified that the Soviet Union would be supporting socialist revolutions whenever possible. Stalin's opinion on "socialism in one country" was that it gave inner strength to the communists who had doubts about Stalin's outlook of a world revolution. Trotsky was continuing to argue a western Marxist account of the future revolution while Stalin had convinced the citizens of Russia that the revolution in socialism, which he had helped establish, was a Russian idea. Therefore Stalin was strongly supporting his nationalist views through his actions and propositions. b) ...read more.

Middle

This can also be associated with inexperience, innocence and a lack of understanding. 2. Compare and contrast the public reactions of Joseph Stalin and Leon Trotsky to the death of Lenin as seen in Source C and Source D. (6) The context of both Source C and D is that they are public reactions of Stalin and Trotsky to the death of Lenin. They are similar and can be compared because they are speaking of the same event. The nature of the two documents is also alike because they are speeches made to the general public of the Tiflis Station (Source D) and the Second All-union Congress of Soviets (Source C). There are several noticeable differences between Source C and D. Leon Trotsky, in Source D, is showing sympathy to Lenin; he is sorry and expressing his condolences to his death. Nevertheless, the tone of Source C is contrasting to Source D. Joseph Stalin, in Source C, is constantly referring to the Party of the Communists, also called the Party of the working class. The purpose of the two speeches was to address the death of Lenin. ...read more.

Conclusion

Stalin wanted to achieve 'socialism in one country', while Trotsky, along with Lenin, wanted 'Worldwide Socialism". Stalin knew that his idea would fail if it was not brought out at exactly the right time, proving that he was a strong opponent, willing to do anything to achieve his goals. Stalin did not make his views public until Trotsky's campaign became less popular. He proposed his theory in 1925, and his own original supporters were opposed of this plan. It was too late because Stalin had become too powerful. I speculate that Stalin only proposed his theory so late because it was in direct conflict with Trotsky's theory of a worldwide revolution. For Stalin to achieve his philosophy of 'socialism in one country', he needed to make the ideal and perfect socialistic/communist state. Stalin would only be able to accomplish this by making the Soviet Union a dictatorship, with him making all of its important decisions and thereby making Russia a totalitarian state. After long battles, Stalin finally beat Trotsky over this issue because he had the support of other members of the government who feared Trotsky. Therefore, that is why Joseph Stalin and Leon Trotsky are such tremendous adversaries. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. Compare the Characters and beliefs of Lenin and Stalin

    This is not what the majority of the Russian people wanted, they were losing out, they were desperately unhappy with Lenin and the new communist Russia. The rich minority of the Russian people however, gained from Lenin's new policies, they could become rich, whereas before that would be almost impossible.

  2. How did Stalin, who was illustrated by Leon Trotsky himself as 'the most eminent ...

    The 'too-damning' nature of the harsh criticisms of major Party personalities contained in Lenin's Testament consequently kept his wishes held in reserve until the following Congress in the following year. Furthermore, Lenin's Testament was also neutralized by Kamanev and Zinoviev; cleared of elements that would uplift Trotsky's name in order

  1. How Did Trotsky Contribute To

    This was abnormal because of the fact he had only just returned to the country but his popularity became obvious because of this. In the month of his appointment as chairman of The Petrograd Soviet he was also planning a coup on the provisional government with a Bolshevik attack.

  2. The enormous role that Trotsky played in the success of the Bolsheviks up until ...

    Trotsky, however, never the defeatists, rushed to Petrograd to take personal command. Trotsky described Zinoviev, the Bolshevik already in charge, as 'panic personified'. A week later Trotsky helped organise a successful counter-attack forcing the white armies to retreat. This was the turning point of the civil war that was later

  1. Stalin Vs. Trotsky.

    He spent much of the period between revolutions in jail or in exile, but made a few important trips abroad in 1912. By this time the Bolshevik organizations in Russia had been gravely weakened, and the Bolsheviks of the Caucasus had assumed an importance quite out of proportion to their numbers.

  2. Stalin, Joseph (1879-1953).

    The two advocated a policy of moderation and cooperation with the provisional government. Although he played a not insignificant role in the armed uprising that followed in November, Stalin was not remembered as a revolutionary hero. In the words of one memoirist, he produced the impression of a "grey blur".

  1. Russian Revolution Sources Questions

    post where he couldn't be the prime catalyst for a split, which must be avoided. 3. Study sources C, D, E and F. Does the evidence of sources C, D and E suggest that Stalin kept his promise (Source F)

  2. Compare the characters and beliefs of Lenin and Stalin.

    had fallen to 9 million tons or even electicity which by 1913 there was 2039 million kWH and by 1921 therewas just 520 million kWH. Even more a massive international aid corporation was mounted. Lenin had promised to end the War.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work