• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The economic problems in Ireland were the same after the Great Famine as before In light of this comment, evaluate and assess the Irish economic situation prior to and after the Famine.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

?The economic problems in Ireland were the same after the Great Famine as before? [60] (1798-1882) The coming of the Great Famine irrevocably changed the majority of the aspects of the Irish economy. ?Economics? is however a broad term for developments in society encompassing political relations, finance and society as a whole, and it is important to distinguish and properly evaluate these differing transformations. Certain features of the Irish economy found themselves to improve after the Famine, and some deteriorated; change had certainly been predominant. Though one aspect of the Irish economy, that to some was the most fundamental component, and essentially determiner, of Irish economics and arguably an underlying ?evil? that all Ireland?s economic hardships swivelled around, failed to change. The continuation of the dominant landlord-tenant relationship in Ireland meant that, although the majority of economic issues in Ireland changed in some way, the major, inherent problem of the Irish economy remained. Many features of Irish politics and society can be evaluated in order to properly judge any change, or continuation, in economic problems. As alluded to in the introduction, the Irish land system played a big part in determining, and feeling the effects of, the economy. ...read more.

Middle

The Irish Land Acts of 1870 and 1881 brought about several changes: tenants were required to be evicted on a ?just? cause, compensation was made mandatory, and made it easier for a tenant to sell and buy land. This did help change the economy: trade was stimulated and over the years a 20% reduction in rent would be achieved. It is however key to put these changes into context- although the tenants had been put in a stronger position in their relationship with the landlords; it served as no real cure for the economic ills of Ireland. It did not impact at all on Irish economic growth due to the fact that, the source of the problem hadn?t been the tenant-landlord relationship, but the shortage of cultivable land. Perhaps what best epitomises the lack of significant change and continuation of the domination of the landlord post-Famine is the fact that in 1879 1000 families were turned off their land. It is, after all, unlikely that the clamour of the tenant right movement, and then the land league would have arisen had the landlord-tenant relationship changed in any way. ...read more.

Conclusion

All points taken into account, it is undeniable that the Irish economy had changed in some degree after the Great Famine (some aspects for better and some for worse), the real question is to what extent this change was significant. The individual fortune of Irish farmers, and Ireland on the whole, did increase owing to the fall in population- the incomes of farmers increased and industrial development in Ireland allowed for improvements in education and trade. However there are certain restraints to these ?changes?- for instance, agriculture continued to preside over industry, and a serious shortage of cultivable land remained. However the fundamental cause of economic problems in Ireland- land tenure and the relationship between landlords and tenants- failed to see any real transformation. This can best be epitomised by the occurrence of the agricultural depression of the 1870?s, and exploring its causes. It is perhaps the report of the Royal Devon Commission that best summates the Irish situation in the nineteenth century- ?the source of all Ireland?s misfortunes and poverty was the fatal system of land tenure existing in the country?. Ireland?s failure to prevent the continuation of the landlords? dominance over the tenants meant that the inherent component of Irish economic problems, or crucially causer of these Irish misfortunes, would remain. Thomas Smith ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. To what extent was Hitlers rise to power due to Economic Problems?

    The technique consisted in the tactic of linking the processes of revolutionary assault with lawful actions that a screen of legality hid the illegality of the system from view12. A smoke screen of nationalisation adopted these illusions and persuaded the civil service, the army, the political parties and trade unions,

  2. HOW DID WORLD WAR ONE CONTRIBUTE TO THE TRANSFORMATION OF IRISH POLITICS 1914-1918?

    Paul Adelman suggests "Redmond's alliance with the Liberals in effect came to an end with the formation of the coalition government ... All this played into the hands of extreme Irish Nationalists, who were already waiting in the wings to take advantage of the wartime difficulties of the British government."10

  1. How effectively did Irish Catholic and nationalist leaders advance their cause in the years ...

    This gave Ireland the greatest independence that any other leaders had, but not the Republic they were looking for. O'Connell achievement of Emancipation granted virtually full civil and political rights for Catholics, which had a positive effect on Catholics. The Coercion Act 1833 shows how some concessions were negative, as

  2. Impact of The Great Famine on Irelands Society, Economy and Politics

    People were reluctant to have large families and in some areas a culture emerged that refrained from having sex as a means of controlling the size of their family- this was because of poverty - the famine proved that a big family was a burden at a time when resources were stretched.

  1. How Effectively Did Irish Catholic and Nationalist Leaders Advance Their Cause 1801-1921 ?

    This led to a decline in Redmond's influence which Sinn Fein later benefited from. Furthermore Lloyd George's political skill was an unfavourable factor for the Irish nationalist leaders. For instance Lloyd George successfully managed to get both the Irish nationalists and unionists to agree his proposed Anglo- Irish Treaty by

  2. How effectively did Irish Catholic and Nationalist leaders advance their cause in the years ...

    They succeeded in rescuing Kelly; but also killed a police officer in the process. The British authorities reacted by arresting five Irishmen and three were hanged. Many felt that the hanged men were innocent, and therefore labeled them as the 'Manchester Martyrs'.

  1. Potato Famine

    Without food for themselves, the population needed to allocate food that would normally go to livestock to feed themselves and thus lost many of their livestock population, another damaging development during a famine. Ireland established a subcommittee to try to save healthy potatoes from becoming infected and to turn infected potatoes into something of value.

  2. 1798 Irish Rebellion notes

    The reasons for this change must be seen in the context of events in France, of course, but also in light of rising British panic about radical political activity in Ireland and in Britain. 3. Underlying this was a fear of French intervention in Irish affairs.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work