• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The German surrender at Stalingrad, February 1943 Sources Question

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The German surrender at Stalingrad, February 1943 Sources Question 1. In Source A, the reasons for the German defeat at Stalingrad are not explained adequately. However, it does state some of the causes. Such as 'Troops without ammunition or food', the fact that they were 'without dressings or drugs' for the wounded soldiers. The other reasons for the defeat that are not stated are that the German supply line was cut off and that the Germans were not prepared for the harsh Soviet winter, and therefore thousands of men who were already weak from starvation perished. There was individual, one on one fighting in the streets, which the Germans were not used to; they were trained as fighting as a unit. The German forces went into this battle expecting to win easily and consequently as it was clear they were not going to win their morale dropped, as the Soviets' increased. The reasons for it possible not showing all of the reasons to why the Germans were defeated because the source is a message, so therefore what the source shows may only be an extract of a message that explained all of the reasons. However it is more likely that it was a radio message and had to be short and straight to the point instead of a long detailed message incase Paulus was cut off. The message was from Von Paulus who at the time was a General, and would therefore know the state that his men were in as he would have been suffering the same himself. The recipient of the message was the German Army High Command, which would have been Hitler, therefore Paulus knew what Hitler needed to hear to give permission for Paulus and his troops to surrender, as you cannot fight without ammunition, and you cannot survive without food. 2. Source B is a photograph that shows the back of a soldier holding the Russian flag, leaning over a balcony looking onto the city of Stalingrad. ...read more.

Middle

Source F is written by a Soviet, consequently having the opposite view to a German, they would be proud of their victory and therefore would want to brag about how many Germans they killed and how many they captured. It goes into detail about how they 'surrounded German- Fascist troops'; it's a negative viewpoint towards the German. Source F was written in the 1960s, therefore nearly twenty years after the German defeat at Stalingrad had happened. Also during this period was the Cold War, so the Soviets would want it to appear that they defeat the Germans on their own with little help from the other Allies. The audience of Source F would have been Soviet school children as it is written for a textbook, therefore they would want to make their children proud of their for-fathers and their country, this was done by adding in all the facts and figures. Apart from the above reasons the sources may be different because for Source E there may have been a lack of information available for the person reading the broadcast. The information would have come from the government, which would have been censored. There are no facts or figures stated about the loss of men, this may be because of censorship or it was too early after the defeat to calculate the numbers. However if the numbers were available they would not have been used to protect the civilians from the sheer scale of the defeat. Source F, does not give the number of Soviet casualties or the number of Germans that eventually returned, it is only focussing on the positive achievements made by the Soviets. Although historians usually give balanced views, the information given could have biased in the first place. As the Soviet Union was a totalitarian state everything would have been censored, yet due to the time gap some information may have been released. ...read more.

Conclusion

The purpose for the battle at Stalingrad for the Germans was so they could access the oil at the Caucuses. If the oil was available to the Germans it would have meant that she could have withstood a prolonged was, without having to depend on Romanian oilfields which were vulnerable to attack by Russian bombers. So as a medium-term consequence the Germans would have been short of oil and therefore not being able to withstand a long-lasting war. The defeat also meant that because of the loss of life the Germans could never again strike again on the Eastern Front. However it was not until the Germans lost in the battle of Kursk against the Russians that they were pushed back, and forced out of the Soviet Union. The defeat obviously had an impact of the German soldiers and their commanding officers; they lost faith in Hitler's ruling and felt he was not listening. During the battle at Stalingrad General Paulus was pleading with 'immediate permission to surrender in order to save lives of remaining troops' as displayed in Source A which is a message from Paulus to Hitler. So with the fallen morale due to the loss of life and defeat at Stalingrad, now as well' there were no doubts among civilians and military circles ...a mad corporal whose lucky gambles were no longer paying off' shown in Source H, that the people's confidence in Hitler was wearing away. At the time, February 1943, the defeat of the Germans at Stalingrad was important to both the Russians and the Germans, but after time had past the Germans only remember the tragic events of Stalingrad, whereas the Russians used it to their advantage, for example during the years of the Cold War. Although not all the Sources support my view, I still believe that the Nazi defeat at Stalingrad was more important to the Russians as it had long term effects whereas it only effected the Germans at that time and non there after. Words: 3,670 By Katie Matthews - 1 - Dunottar School ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    World War One Sources Question

    3 star(s)

    This entailed first crossing No-man's Land to attack enemy positions and break-in to the enemy trenches. Then breaking through the trenches to capture and occupy them, creating a gap behind enemy lines and then breaking out behind enemy lines by sending a large number of troops through the gap to encircle and defeat the enemy, achieving a victory.

  2. This graduation paper is about U.S. - Soviet relations in Cold War period. Our ...

    Marshall Plan, the Molotov Plan, and subsequent developments in Eastern Europe represented the economic, political, and military demarcations that would define the terrain on which the war would be fought. The Cold War had begun. Chapter 3: The Role of Cold War in American History and Diplomacy.

  1. UNIT 6: PAPER 6b: THE SOVIET UNION AFTER LENIN

    * It was quite common for whole families - three generations often - to live in one room. Dormitories were supplied for workers, who were often separated from families. Canteens at work provided food. Standard of living * There is no doubt that the standard of living fell for most ordinary Russians during the 1930s.

  2. Jane Austen's novel Pride and Prejudice is a tale of love and marriage in ...

    He says that the CIA ". . . supplied President Kennedy and his advisers with chosen reports on the unreliability of Castro's forces and the extent of Cuban dissent." Of the CIA's behaviour he concludes that, . . . By resorting to the typical organization strategy of defining the options

  1. WW1 Sources Question: War Recruitment Propaganda.

    In conclusion, the government issued post cards like source E so that no information, which would inform the enemy or demoralise the home front, left the front line.5)During world war one the press was carefully controlled, any information, which was contradictory to the pro-war euphoria, was not allowed to be published.

  2. American History.

    of Horseshoe Bend in March 1814 [Treaty of Fort Jackson, they had to give up 2/3rds of their land]; the British were defeated at the famous Battle of New Orleans on January 8, 1815 [the war had officially ended by then though].

  1. Reasons for the increasing support given to NSDAP by the German people in the ...

    Not for treason - but for patriotism." Most Germans living in the economic chaos of hyperinflation sympathised to a great extent with his voiced opinions and this layed down the beginnings of the Nazi party's support. However the NSDAP failed to extend on this good fortune as the leadership had become fragmented during Hitler's term in jail.

  2. Vietnam Question 2

    The inexperienced soldiers will have killed the innocent unintentionally. Hamer states that as the Americans walked through "rice paddies", they were attacked with mortar shells. This leaves many Americans dead and scores injured. The soldiers are left in a dilemma.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work