• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The proposition that the Meiji Restoration and Japan's modernisation were caused by Western Imperialism does have its merits, though it must be said other factors played a prominent role in the development of Japan in the latter half of the 19th century.

Extracts from this document...


The proposition that the Meiji Restoration and Japan's modernisation were caused by Western Imperialism does have its merits, though it must be said other factors played a prominent role in the development of Japan in the latter half of the 19th century. These factors helped contribute towards the fall of the Tokugawa shogunate, while Western Imperialism seemed to help speed up the change that Japan underwent. The Tokugawa shogunate had ruled Japan for 800 years, with a decentralised form of government, relying on a rigid hostage system - the sankin kotai. Towards the middle of the 19th century, the Tokugawa shogunate had degenerated into an inefficient, corrupt government, ruled by an upper class which indulged in excesses much of the time, which created internal disunity in Japan. Their system of governance had created discontent in all the other classes of the feudal society of Japan. The daimyo of the ruling clans were discontent with the measure of control the shogunate exercised over them through the sankin kotai system, and weakened their financial status by forcing them to borrow from merchants and leaving them heavily indebted. The samurai also had reason discontent, due to their inactivity caused by the long period of peace in Japan. Thus, there was very little need for them, and they were subsequently paid less and had their rice allowances almost halved. This discontent created a small of group of intelligent samurai who laid the foundation for the anti-shogun movement. The internal disunity in Japan was further exacerbated by the oppression of the peasants, who had to tolerate corrupt officials, food shortages and heavy taxation on their lands and produce, which led to revolts and riots. ...read more.


This slogan, was a rallying point for the majority of the population, and severely undermined the grip of the Tokugawa shogunate. The result of this anti-Western feeling was the Choshu uprising. The Choshu's clan's uprising, led to an assault on Kyoto, which eventually led to the defeat of Bakufu forces. Other Western clans, including he prominent Satsuma clan, and merchants, as well as the British government conspired in an alliance to overthrow the shogunate, though it must be said that its role would have been somewhat limited. The shogunate was overthrown by these powerful forces, and the Meiji Emperor's powers restored. It is possible to see that the long suppression and oppression of the classes of the Japanese people, finally sparked into a revolt by the arrival of the Americans. The contribution the Imperialist policies of the West had to the Meiji Restoration cannot be questioned, but it is possible to argue that the impact of the West would not have been the same (significantly less) had the Shogunate's government proven more efficient, and more adept at preventing internal discord. Historians such as Minear argue that "The Tokugawa clan, headed by the shogun, had ruled Japan since 1603, and was now blamed for the shame which the unequal treaties had inflicted upon Japan. In the end, the Tokugawa shogunate was overthrown and a new group of leaders emerged at the same time a new emperor ascended the throne." It is clear that he feels that the unequal treaties, which caused anti-Western sentiment, are mainly to blame for the rise of the Meiji Emperor. ...read more.


One last aspect of Japan's modernisation which the West influenced a great deal was the ambitions it took once it felt developed enough. In order to feel completely modernised, Japan also felt it had to model its ambitions on the Western powers as well - by seizing land from other nations. Indeed, its rapid change from an agrarian society meant that the resources and raw materials available from a colony, territory or annexed land would be quite welcome. The West's help in trying to open up Korea, which lead to the Sino-Japanese War meant that Japan was able to profit greatly by taking the place of China as Asia's leading power. The Anglo-Japanese alliance also strengthened Japan's position as a modernised power, and helped it gain valuable resources from which it could further expand its booming industries. The Anglo-British alliance also served as protection for the Japanese from other Western powers, which allowed it to modernise and keep its hold on land it had seized. In conclusion, it must be said that Western Imperialism did, to a certain extent, help restore the Meiji Emperor to his throne. However, there were also many factors stemming from the discontent of the feudal classes of Japan which led to the fall of the shogun and the Emperor's subsequent rise. The modernisation of Japan must be said to have been greatly influenced by the West, for while the Japanese did not adopt the morals viewpoint of Western society, Western Imperialism had been able to project its influence sufficiently enough to greatly inspire and spur on the Japanese in their quest for modernisation. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Battling western democracy

    The United States have been supporting the GMD all the time. They had economic interest in China, but only GMD was their ally. The CCP was an ideological enemy to the United States. The latter had been directed from Moscow since the year 1921.

  2. Is the assertion that Britain was "Splendidly Isolated" in the latter years of the ...

    War was therefore avoided. Another time that Britain's avoidance of war was obvious was the Turkey incident, where Armenian Christians where being poorly treated by the Turks. Lord Salisbury had to appear anti-Turkish to appease the Christians, and at the same time not allow Russia to take control of Turkey

  1. "Keep the dogs hungry, they will follow you". Such was in essence, the ruling ...

    Taimur, self-exiled for several years, launched a movement aimed at overthrowing Sultan Said and restoring democracy,. Born of a Turkish mother, married to a German, speaking five languages fluently, Tariq had friends in the Western embassies in Kuwait and Beirut, and was thinking of raising a mercenary force to remove Said from power.

  2. In What Ways Were Britain's Imperial Policies Before 1952 Influenced By The Development Of ...

    This helped to bring about Russian evacuation and prevented the Soviets from attempting to carve out its own sphere of influence in the Middle East. Therefore to an extent the event did mark a victory for British imperial policy. However, historians such as Fawcett argue that the crisis in fact

  1. Many peoples have contributed to the development of the United States of America, a ...

    for each state (two senators each), to be chosen by the state legislatures. The powers of the national government were to be those previously exercised by London: regulation of interstate and foreign commerce, foreign affairs and defense, and Indian affairs; control of the national domain; and promotion of "the general welfare."

  2. Outline the various stages in the development of warfare since the middle of the ...

    Due to this, war has extended from armies to ordinary civilians, therefore potentially increasing death tolls and creating more fear among inhabitants of a country at war as attacks can be secret. The mobility and transport of armies has also changed which has an effect on the development of warfare;

  1. Africa and the role they played during both of the world wars.

    The African servicemen also suffered mentally, many Africans were taken away from the villages and families (most of them had never been away from there villages) and sent to Europe or other parts of Africa to work or fight in harsh conditions.

  2. To what extent do you agree with the statement: The Crimean War was the ...

    Moreover, the Turkish Empire had survived and the Eastern Question was put on hold for two decades. However, after 1856 Russia's main diplomatic aim in Europe was to remove the humiliation restrictions imposed on her naval power in the Black Sea and this was achieve in 1870-1871.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work