• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent was Hitler's 'charismatic authority' the basis of Nazi control in the period from 1933 to 1939?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

To what extent was Hitler's 'charismatic authority' the basis of Nazi control in the period from 1933 to 1939? Despite the general and traditional intentionalist or 'Hitlocentric' view of those such as Fest, that 'no one evoked so much rejoicing, hysteria, and expectation of salvation as he'1 or that 'Nazism was Hitlerism, pure and simple.'2 Adolf Hitler was indeed 'charismatic' as a leader but no distinctly authoritive. It is not plausible to maintain that 'to a virtually unprecedented degree, he created everything out of himself and was himself everything at once: (nor) his own teacher, organizer of a party and author of its ideology, tactician and demagogic saviour, leader, statesman and for a decaded the entire 'axis' of Germany.'3 Indeed, there were both numerous and significant factors equating to the success of Nazi control 1933-1939, 'he seemed to embody the very type of the 'agent,' one who acts for others.'4 Hitler's 'charismatic authority' and the establishment of the Fuhrer image functioned, 'in mobilizing the boundless energy and misplaced idealism of the fanatics and activists through orientation towards long-term 'cosmic' and 'utopian' goals.'5 Thus, 'Hitler's increasing aloofness from the State bureaucracy and the major organs of government marks, it seems, are more than a difference of style with Stalin's modus operandi.'6 Nazi Germany, however, politically was not only a personal dictatorship, it was also a one-party state, therefore claiming supreme political authority. ...read more.

Middle

ideological enemies such as threats to national morale, 'asocials' and biological outsiders were crucial to the maintenance and success of Nazi Germany, including Jews, gypsies, homosexuals and the mentally ill. Seemingly, 'an obsession with Aryanism and eugenic theory was the catalyst for Nazi policies of repression and extermination against gypsies and other 'asocials,' yet the extent of Hitler's direct involvement in exercising these practices is contentious. However, Hitler's extensive involvement in the manifestation of doctrines in schools to reinforce the Hitler youth (Hitler Jugend) should not be downplayed. Through the political aims and policies of the Nazi party, Hitler was indeed 'charimatic' but not authoritive. The underlying presence of 'unfretted competeition is one of the least understood features of the National Socialist regime. More significantly, the orthodox intentionalist interpretation of Hitler's foreign policy in relation to Lebensraum has been altered. Jackel views Hitler's ideas as a guideline for his foreign policy actions, which were often adapted to deal with specific problems.12 In implementing terror and propaganda, Hitler maintained a charismatic leadership. The significance and importance of terror and propaganda is undisputed, as Hitler's polycratic regime thrived on the emphasise of control. Despite Hitler's teleo-logical association with 'heroic' leadership, 'this notion...(was) widespread in right-wing circles before Hitler's rise to prominence.'13 Hitler's role within the pursuit of Nazi economic policies was but again 'charismatic' but lacking an authoritive stance. ...read more.

Conclusion

Nazi success and efficiency in stabilising the faltering German economy and producing sustained recovery after 1933 aided in exercising political control through unification and the establishment of a disciplined community. 'What he had always lacked was an awarness of the problems involved in translating policy into action.'22 1 Fest, J.C, Hitler, pp. 3 2 Kershaw, I., Hitler and the Uniqueness of Nazism 3 Fest, J.C., Hitler, pp.3 4 ibid, pp. 9 5 Kershaw, I., The Hitler Myth: Image and reality in the Third Reich, (1994), pp. 205 6 Kershaw I., 'Working Towards the Fuhrer: reflections on the nature of the Hitler dictatorship.', pp. 91 7 Noakes, J., Documents on Nazism, (1974), pp. 8 ibid 9 ibid 10 Noakes, J., Documents on Nazism, (1974), pp. 11 Welch, D., Nazi Propaganda and the Volksgemeinschaft: Constructing a People's Community 12 Jackel, E., Hitler in history, (1984), London 13 Kershaw, I., The Hitler Myth, History Today, (1985) 14 Heyl, J., Hitler's economic thought: A reappraisal, (1973) 15 Lee, S., Hitler and Nazi Germany, pp. 71 16 ibid 17 McDonough, F., Hitler and Nazi Germany, Cambrdige University Press 18 ibid 19 Kershaw, I., The Hitler Myth: Image and reality in the Third Reich, (1994), pp. 198 20 Kershaw I., 'Working Towards the Fuhrer: reflections on the nature of the Hitler dictatorship.', pp. 91 21 Noakes, J., Documents on Nazism, (1974), pp. 22 ibid ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. Was Hitler a weak dictator?

    This shows a major weakness in his way of ruling the nation. Hitler focused most of his policies to his foreign policy. Historians state as an anecdote that he didn't go to meetings if he didn't want to, however when it referred to foreign affairs he always did.

  2. Hitler and the Nazi Regime - revision sheet.

    Von Papen worked with Hitler to get him into office as long as von Papen would be vice-Chancellor. They devised a plan to hold an election to showcase that the Nazi Party was still important. When the German people showed their Nazi support.

  1. Evaluate the Nazis economic policies from 1933 - 1939. To what extent were the ...

    Hitler did succeed in making Germany ready for war by 1939 when he invaded Poland. It is because, firstly, Hitler was only given three years to do so. He had to and did spend time to deal with the economic problems at the beginning of his regime.

  2. Causes of show trials + purges of 1930s.

    However domestic serfs who did not work the land were not entitled to land which created further hostility. For state peasants the period of transition to freedom was five years. The landowners were not expected to surrender land freely, in compensation for the land that they transferred to the peasants they received payment in the form of government bonds.

  1. Hitlers Germany

    Another poster, entitled "Work and Bread," pictures an arm with a Nazi armband, the hand offering tools to the outstretched hands of the unemployed. For the middle classes, the Nazis exploited fears of the communist revolutionary threat to private property.

  2. The people(TM)s community(TM). How far did Nazi policies between 1933 and 1939 go ...

    Overall, they were politically programmed to obey the Nazis and the Hitler Youth did create enthusiasm. However, in the rural areas, there was a sharp decline in participation in the Hitler Youth as it was regarded as burdensome and they were increasingly irritated by the lack of freedom and the mindless drilling.

  1. The government of the Nazi state was chaotic and lacked coherence in the years ...

    also coherent the 'structure of Nazi state formed a complex mosaic of party and state agencies' of which were all 'striving to obtain a monopoly of power' and Goring set up power bases by 'combining government and party offices'. Ultimately, everyone had their own view of working towards the F�hrer and within that everyone interpreted it in different ways.

  2. To what extent did Hitlers Policies attract working class support between 1933 and 1939?

    We may suspect exaggeration of the economic factor from a Marxist historian, but he is correct to stress the strong position the regime had. The economic uncertainty allowed Hitler to be portrayed as a savior, but this connection arguably made his support fragile as economic progress was not guaranteed.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work