• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Was there any truth in the Southern claim that slavery was both a benign and profitable institution in Mid-19th Century America?

Extracts from this document...


Was there any truth in the Southern claim that slavery was both a benign and profitable institution in Mid-19th Century America? Despite the abolition of slavery in the Northern states by 1820, it continued to grow in the South. By 1860 over 50% of all American slaves were employed on Southern cotton plantations, and there were nearly 4,000,000 slaves in the Southern slave states. The majority of White Southerners had no conflict of confidence in slavery; they only became more determined to maintain it as an institution after the rise of militant abolitionism in the North in the 1830s, claiming that slavery was an effective method of controlling the slave population. Throughout the last century, and before, historians have been disputing the merits of slavery as an institution; its success as an economic tool and the treatment of those it utilised. It is easier to judge the economic success of slavery than its effects on the slaves themselves for several reasons. Any comment about the treatment of slaves can only be a generalisation - there were fair slave owners, cruel slave owners and slave owners who fell somewhere in the middle. Most records are only from large plantations; there are very few from families who owned only a handful of slaves. ...read more.


While slaves were described as having a primitive, even savage, background, in reality it stemmed from diverse and often sophisticated tribal cultures. The horrific journey of the 'Middle Passage' and the further shock of then being sold into slavery is said to have left Africans newly arrived to America uprooted and without culture. Although the slave trade was made illegal in 1808, the slave population in America continued to grow and the initial restriction of culture later changed into a restriction of personality. In most states it was illegal for slaves to learn to read and write, and they were left untrained to ensure that they remained as slaves. As was written in 'De Bow's Review' at the time, it was believed that "whenever a slave is made a mechanic, he is more than half-freed". Supporters of slavery have argued that there was variety and organisation in the work of slaves, with possibilities of promotion or rewards - such as extra clothing, better food or even garden plots - for hard working slaves. To counter this argument, however, it has been said that it was possible to subvert the system; for example by working slowly or pretending to be ill; so that less hard-working slaves could still gain the benefits intended for others. ...read more.


For this reason slaves could decide not to take freedom. For the above reasons, it can be concluded that slavery in mid 19th Century America was certainly not, as the South claimed, a benign institution. Perhaps the most important comment that can be made with regards to this fact is that the racist views held by Southern planters at the time were carried through American society, causing segregation and prejudice for much of the next century. What is harder to determine is whether slavery was a profitable institution, since to some extent it was. For the Southern planters, and the Southern economy at the time, it was profitable. Slaves were a good investment and their labour was invaluable for supplying cotton. However, for the slaves themselves, slavery was completely unprofitable. They worked hard for very little, or no, gain to themselves. So, in conclusion, there was some truth in the Southern claim that slavery was a profitable institution - for the people who were making the claim - but as one slave mistress observed, for the slaves themselves, "They'd just as life clean the mud after themselves as [do] anything else - their time isn't any value to themselves." Sources: 'The Penguin History of the USA' - Hugh Brogan 'The Origins of the American Civil War 1846-1861' - Alan Farmer 'The Debate on the American Civil War Era' - Hugh Tulloch Sarah Ritchie 11th September 2002 Pg 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level History of the USA, 1840-1968 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level History of the USA, 1840-1968 essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    To what extent were Malcolm X and the subsequent Black Power Movement the 'Evil ...

    4 star(s)

    29 Sweet Land of Liberty p.201 - Cook, 1998 30 Cone, 1993 - Quoted in The Civil Rights Movement, Struggle and Resistance p.94 - Riches, 1997 31 America: A Narrative History p.1534 - Tindall and Shi, 1984 32 The Organisation of Afro-American Unity was a Black Nationalist group founded by Malcolm X in 1964.

  2. The Value of Multicultural Education in America

    Multicultural education is an idea which first took seed in the 1960's, germinated during the following two decades, and came to fruition in the 1990's. It is a means to becoming a tolerant society; a place where people having a variety of cultural and ethnic backgrounds can live harmoniously.

  1. US Popular Culture - Woody Guthrie Biography

    Jack later became a fairly big country and western star, and his biggest hit was "Oklahoma Hills".

  2. Shay's Rebellion

    Subsistence farmers as well as laboring people were hardest hit in these economic troubles. This brings the issue back to borrowing because the government borrows from other countries, the state government borrows from wealthy merchants and the small farmers and laboring people (who need money for taxes)

  1. Revision notes - the USA 1945 to 1980

    The Great Society program Civil Rights Education Medicare Urban renewal and the development of depressed regions Measures against poverty The right to vote. Civil Rights In 64 and 65 Johnson passed two major civil rights bills. The first, the Civil Rights Act, made the old Jim Crow laws in the southern states illegal.

  2. It is hard to pinpoint the exact beginnings of slavery in the United States. ...

    Although historically life expectancy was low in the 19th century, slaves had a considerably shorter life expectancy than the white Americans had. The 1860 census shows that, on average, 4.4% of white Americans would live to over sixty, whilst only 3.5% of slaves would reach this age.

  1. Essay on Frederick Douglass's views about slavery in the city and slavery on plantations

    Plantation slaves in the South were generally agricultural workers, and few owners had more than two dozen slaves. On a typical plantation, some slaves would be involved in domestic chores. Life on the plantation was grueling work, with little respite from the cruelty of the master or overseer's watchful eyes.

  2. The effects of immigration into the US in the 19th Century.

    Also Because of all the new jobs and businesses, unemployment rates went down, along with the rise in family income each year. The immigrants made the United States economy stronger. They caused more jobs to be created that they themselves would later fill.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work