• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'We Were Soldiers' is a film that attempts to portray both sides of the conflict in Indo-China that became known in the West as the 'Vietnam War'.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

We were soldiers essay 'We Were Soldiers' is a film that attempts to portray both sides of the conflict in Indo-China that became known in the West as the 'Vietnam War'. After carefully analysing the film, it becomes apparent that this statement is essentially untrue. The film opens with a disembodied narrative from the voice of Joe Galloway, an American news reporter, sent over in the midst of the conflict to show the American people how men fought and died for their country. We hear him dedicate the story to all men who fought in the Vietnam War, from both sides. Implicitly, however the story is dedicated to the American men and the way in which the film is directed plays a part in conveying the Americans as righteous and patriotic and the Vietnamese as Ruthless and barbaric. Firstly, the way in which the camera shots are taken during American deaths compared to the way in which the Vietnamese deaths are shown makes us, as an audience feel compassionate towards the Americans. ...read more.

Middle

The scene is set in the middle of a dark field by a road. The lighting is very low and any light that is present comes from above. The camera is filming from below. When the American soldiers step into this light, it creates the effect of making the soldiers appear strong and tall. We never see the Vietnamese in a similar setting, possibly because they are already in the country in which the war takes place. This again makes the American soldiers seem stronger as they have to travel a vast distance from their homes. During the battle scenes we see Lieutenant Colonel Hal Moore (Mel Gibson) portrayed as an excellent leader, calm under pressure and a patriotic fighter, as well as having seen him shown as a good father in previous domestic scenes. However, as the battle progresses we see the Vietnamese Colonel only in a few scenes, and we learn nothing of his domestic life, this could lessen the audiences compassion for him, and his possible death may not affect us as greatly. ...read more.

Conclusion

When the only American-born Vietnamese soldier (fighting for the American side) is hit, a big issue is made of the fact that he was hit by friendly fire. However when the napalm bombs hit any Vietnamese soldiers, they do not get any comparable tribute paid to them; it is almost dismissed as being unimportant. The American-born Vietnamese soldier fighting for the Americans is paid particular attention to throughout the film, more so than many of the other soldiers, while this is not a racial issue, I feel that it reinforces the idea of the Vietnamese are the brutal enemy and suggests the fact that it may be novel for the Americans to be fighting with a Vietnamese person. In conclusion, I feel that the statement made at the beginning of the essay is for the most part untrue; while the film does in places attempt to convey both sides in the Vietnam War, the way in which the Americans are paid tribute far outweighs the negative way in which the Vietnamese soldiers are - after all, it is the victor that writes the history. Tom Clarkson 10-1 English ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. China's relationship with the West

    Eye-catching headlines were used, such as 'China warns West to shun dissidents'. In one article on this subject the journalist writes 'China, displaying an unyielding stance on human rights ...' Here the journalist is suggesting that China is refusing to act on the encouragement of Western countries to improve it's human rights.

  2. Khrushchev's attempts at modernisation.

    Khrushchev was also very conscious of the danger of nuclear war with President Eisenhower's United States and was eager to rid the Soviet Union of its confrontational Stalinist legacy in order to improve relations with the west. Khrushchev adopted the policy of peaceful-coexistence, which meant accepting that the West had

  1. How was opposition to the Vietnam War portrayed in contemporary literature, film and popular ...

    and heal the wounded, who arrived at the Mobile Army Surgical Hospital. Although it was set in South Korea, and not deliberately linked with Vietnam, it still related to the war efforts. In gave people an insight into the casualties at war, and even though it sometimes exaggerated the brutalities

  2. China's Relationship With The West

    He praised China's rich history and achievements, but he then added: "There is no point denying that we have our differences. I, like many in Europe, believe that human rights are universal and this is bound to be discussed. But I also believe, as I have said before that persuasion and dialogue achieve more than confrontation and empty rhetoric."

  1. The Vietnam War or Second Indochina War

    By the end of the war 1000's of American soldiers had lost their lives (58,226 is the figure recorded). Countless more were injured (153,303 being the ruff estimate of wounded) bringing American casualties to a total of around 211,529. This was in a war many did not understand and feel the need for involvement in.

  2. Discuss the subplot to the film "The Three Kings", comment and analyse on the ...

    It does not appear that anything significant is happening, but then an Iraqi appears somewhere in the distance. The soldiers are all talking to each other, with such irrelevant conversations, such as "do you want some gum" "I think I got a grain of sand in there [his eye]" and one man is just seemingly staring into space.

  1. China's relationship with the West 1) ...

    The Tiananmen Square incident, instigated by Deng in 1989, raised huge uproar in China. On the anniversaries of this event many people affected by Deng's 'crackdown on pro-democracy protests' gathered to protest against the murder of thousands of students. These people, marked dissidents by China and victims by the USA, received huge sympathy from Western countries and human rights groups.

  2. How was opposition to the Vietnam War portrayed in Contemporary Literature, Film and popular ...

    they too are going to try and make the articles one sided for they have the power to do so. Magazines were another source of information for the public to read up on current events in Vietnam, but would mainly target students who wanted to rebel and make their voices heard.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work